Jump to content

Are the bills playing conservative intentionally? (hot take kinda)


Steptide

Recommended Posts

So, I know what I'm about to write sounds absurd, and I can't even bring myself to fully comprehend it, but hear me out a little. 

 

So obviously the bills offense hasent been to our standards through these first 2 games. It's hard to wrap our heads around after seeing how good they were last season. I was thinking about this a bit while at work today. All through camp all I heard from local media and sports guys on Twitter is how good the bills offense was. Passes from Allen rarely hit the ground in camp and the team was on par to take another leap this season. Then we watch them in pre season and for the most part, see the same thing we've been hearing about all throughout camp (even with trubisky playing). Fast forward to the regular season and all of a sudden our offense is anemic. I'm not saying in anyway that Josh is over and under throwing passes intentionally, or missing wide open guys by design. That would be ridiculous. However, I do wonder if to some degree the bills are intentionally being a bit conservative knowing that they have kc, Tampa and other opponents they have to beat if they wanna be super bowl contenders. I'm in no way saying the bills lost to the steelers intentionally or anything crazy like that. I just think this team is way better than what we've seen these last 2 weeks and it's hard for me to believe it's just a regression 

  • Angry 1
  • Agree 2
  • Haha (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Steptide said:

So, I know what I'm about to write sounds absurd, and I can't even bring myself to fully comprehend it, but hear me out a little. 

 

So obviously the bills offense hasent been to our standards through these first 2 games. It's hard to wrap our heads around after seeing how good they were last season. I was thinking about this a bit while at work today. All through camp all I heard from local media and sports guys on Twitter is how good the bills offense was. Passes from Allen rarely hit the ground in camp and the team was on par to take another leap this season. Then we watch them in pre season and for the most part, see the same thing we've been hearing about all throughout camp (even with trubisky playing). Fast forward to the regular season and all of a sudden our offense is anemic. I'm not saying in anyway that Josh is over and under throwing passes intentionally, or missing wide open guys by design. That would be ridiculous. However, I do wonder if to some degree the bills are intentionally being a bit conservative knowing that they have kc, Tampa and other opponents they have to beat if they wanna be super bowl contenders. I'm in no way saying the bills lost to the steelers intentionally or anything crazy like that. I just think this team is way better than what we've seen these last 2 weeks and it's hard for me to believe it's just a regression 

I think they are just trying to be more balanced and it's taking time for the offense to get in rhythm and for the o line to get in sync.

  • Like (+1) 4
  • Agree 5
  • Thank you (+1) 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not sure if what you're saying applies to what were seeing. To me, your theory seems counterproductive for the long haul. I mentioned in another thread that I couldn't understand how our passing offense became so stagnant after hearing about all the hype surrounding training camp and the 3rd preseason game. I even went as far to say "did releasing Brown throw Josh off"? There are some chalking it up to the Bills playing good defenses the first 2 weeks, but good QBs can still light up good defenses. In Allen's case, compared to last year, he didn't even play. I understand the sub par stats against the Steelers last year, but he absolutely shredded the Dolphins both times.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It could be a lack of preseason playing time. They have come out looking rusty and out of sync, tell tales of not enough live game speed and hits, they will get past it, but it is the price to pay for not playing your first team guys in the preseason.  That and the Steelers appear to use what KC did, game plan wise in there effort to beat us, could be other things as well, but this seems to be the most straight forward reasoning to me…,

 

Go Bills!!!

  • Like (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's wishful thinking as it was more gameplan specific.

 

They played pretty aggressively against the Steelers with a lot of 10 personnel because they thought they could find a matchup to exploit with their WR depth.  What they didn't count on is Josh to be off and our o-line to look like Bobby Hart x5.

 

Against the Fins, they were more balanced given the strength of their secondary and how anemic the Fins offense was.

  • Thank you (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think there is something to having to adjust to teams adjusting to us - it's not just Allen but Diggs isn't sneaking up on anyone anymore either.  

 

And we could be trying to work on some things while obviously trying to win.  

 

 

 

Everyone keeps saying 2019 Josh which is ridiculous.  2019 Josh was essentially still a rookie (no longer raw).  There was reason for concern most of that season whether or not the O would be good enough.  Because Josh was still early in his development.

 

Looking forward to this more experienced Josh in 2021 make adjustments to the adjustments and continuing to grow because that's how he's programmed.   

Edited by Big Blitz
  • Agree 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ball placement. 33% from 10-25 yards these two games. 
For context he was at 62% last year in the 10-25 yard range. 
Defenses are learning his tendencies and favorite areas of the field to target and playing better coverage in those areas. Even still we are seeing him miss throws he was making with ease last year. I’m sure they are watching the film and making adjustments. 

  • Agree 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

No step, they aren’t holding back stuff, if anything they tried some dumb ars plays in game 1 when they didn’t have the fleeflicker down in practice, and the toss back on 4th and 1.  We had a bad game, a more balanced game in week 2, and it’s just a matter they have to get in a rhythm.  That can easily happen these next two weeks, and be ready for KC.  
 

It’s kind of like some over analysis so if you go to that stats sheet, we have the 2nd best defense in yards and pts.  Are they the 2nd best defense?  I don’t know, maybe they’ll be in the top 6 or so as there are some good defenses out there.  And are we the 23 rd best offense when we scored 35 pts Sunday?  I don’t think so.  It’s just a little too much analysis by paralysis.  I’m waiting a few weeks before I make any  significant opinions.  Allen just isn’t in a groove yet.  The sky isn’t falling.  I wouldn’t doubt you’ll see more of either or Gilliam or (not both at the same time) Knox out there in 11 personnel, as Moss/Motor can chip and be an outlet, and Knox can do the same.  The Tackles may just need a chip to give Allen just another half second and still be out 6 yards downfield.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I’m not a big fan of Aaron Rodgers or anything but he did have a good comment last night. Responding to all the criticism of their blowout loss in week 1.  

He said from his experience in NFL football nothing carries over from year to year.  The team literally has to learn how to win at the beginning of each season, as if they’ve never done it before. 

That probably holds true for Allen and the Bills right now. They are learning how to win again. They have the talent, a lot of the same players and they will ramp up pretty quickly i think.  They already figured something out after the Steelers 2nd half.  Look at that Miami 2nd half, Outstanding. 

  • Like (+1) 6
  • Thank you (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

43 minutes ago, Steptide said:

So, I know what I'm about to write sounds absurd, and I can't even bring myself to fully comprehend it, but hear me out a little. 

 

So obviously the bills offense hasent been to our standards through these first 2 games. It's hard to wrap our heads around after seeing how good they were last season. I was thinking about this a bit while at work today. All through camp all I heard from local media and sports guys on Twitter is how good the bills offense was. Passes from Allen rarely hit the ground in camp and the team was on par to take another leap this season. Then we watch them in pre season and for the most part, see the same thing we've been hearing about all throughout camp (even with trubisky playing). Fast forward to the regular season and all of a sudden our offense is anemic. I'm not saying in anyway that Josh is over and under throwing passes intentionally, or missing wide open guys by design. That would be ridiculous. However, I do wonder if to some degree the bills are intentionally being a bit conservative knowing that they have kc, Tampa and other opponents they have to beat if they wanna be super bowl contenders. I'm in no way saying the bills lost to the steelers intentionally or anything crazy like that. I just think this team is way better than what we've seen these last 2 weeks and it's hard for me to believe it's just a regression 

Are you sure you weren’t thinking about it A LOT at work? 😜🤣

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

49 minutes ago, Steptide said:

So, I know what I'm about to write sounds absurd, and I can't even bring myself to fully comprehend it, but hear me out a little. 

 

So obviously the bills offense hasent been to our standards through these first 2 games. It's hard to wrap our heads around after seeing how good they were last season. I was thinking about this a bit while at work today. All through camp all I heard from local media and sports guys on Twitter is how good the bills offense was. Passes from Allen rarely hit the ground in camp and the team was on par to take another leap this season. Then we watch them in pre season and for the most part, see the same thing we've been hearing about all throughout camp (even with trubisky playing). Fast forward to the regular season and all of a sudden our offense is anemic. I'm not saying in anyway that Josh is over and under throwing passes intentionally, or missing wide open guys by design. That would be ridiculous. However, I do wonder if to some degree the bills are intentionally being a bit conservative knowing that they have kc, Tampa and other opponents they have to beat if they wanna be super bowl contenders. I'm in no way saying the bills lost to the steelers intentionally or anything crazy like that. I just think this team is way better than what we've seen these last 2 weeks and it's hard for me to believe it's just a regression 


i felt like against Miami they were definitely holding back on offense. Maybe less holding back, but more like setting them up a little for the next time we play them (which is only in a few more weeks).  For example, I noticed they ran a lot of motion and sort of jet sweep action, but we never did anything with it. I wonder if that’s part of the set-up to roll out some wrinkles the next time we play them. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No.  Other teams have adapted to what the bills were doing on offense and now we have to figure out how best to attack the new looks we are facing.  Have to mention Josh feeling too much pressure playing in front of crowds. 😃

  • Like (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

This isn’t college where we open with Mercer and SE Louisiana Tech so we can play vanilla for our upcoming game against Bama…

 

That Steelers loss could be the difference between a 1 seed and 2 seed.   
 

Zero chance they’re holding back, but they are absolutely working through things … I highly doubt the offense we’ve seen Weeks 1 & 2 will be what we see Weeks 11 & 12 etc. 

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Steptide said:

So, I know what I'm about to write sounds absurd, and I can't even bring myself to fully comprehend it, but hear me out a little. 

 

So obviously the bills offense hasent been to our standards through these first 2 games. It's hard to wrap our heads around after seeing how good they were last season. I was thinking about this a bit while at work today. All through camp all I heard from local media and sports guys on Twitter is how good the bills offense was. Passes from Allen rarely hit the ground in camp and the team was on par to take another leap this season. Then we watch them in pre season and for the most part, see the same thing we've been hearing about all throughout camp (even with trubisky playing). Fast forward to the regular season and all of a sudden our offense is anemic. I'm not saying in anyway that Josh is over and under throwing passes intentionally, or missing wide open guys by design. That would be ridiculous. However, I do wonder if to some degree the bills are intentionally being a bit conservative knowing that they have kc, Tampa and other opponents they have to beat if they wanna be super bowl contenders. I'm in no way saying the bills lost to the steelers intentionally or anything crazy like that. I just think this team is way better than what we've seen these last 2 weeks and it's hard for me to believe it's just a regression 

I don't think so but you did bring up a different point sort of.... For the last four season's McD and Leslie came out with a super nonaggressive defense. All the DL would just walk the OL back into the QB. Rarely trying to get around them. Fast forward to this year and we are playing our playoffs defense already. That is a huge change and I was wondering about that. Where does the defense go from here?

Josh is just playing poorly as evident in the Kurt Warner video and you can tell just by watching Josh play the last two weeks. No MVP there. I think the contract got to him a bit. I think the Stealers physicality got to him a bit. Miami's secondary is maybe the best in the league as well. Josh has a ways to go to match his play from last season. Daboll's O has been aggressive like always.... Maybe it's good that Josh is struggling now as opposed to later I guess. Hopefully Josh will be stronger because of this slump?

 

Go Bills!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, NewEra said:

No.  Other teams have adapted to what the bills were doing on offense and now we have to figure out how best to attack the new looks we are facing.  Have to mention Josh feeling too much pressure playing in front of crowds. 😃

Why can’t the coaches figure this out during the game? Josh has been staying in pocket more this year, feeling the pressure and not really maintaining mechanics. Think he will begin moving around more to find that time and making plays like last season. The Diggs TD is evidence

Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 minutes ago, Solomon Grundy said:

Why can’t the coaches figure this out during the game? Josh has been staying in pocket more this year, feeling the pressure and not really maintaining mechanics. Think he will begin moving around more to find that time and making plays like last season. The Diggs TD is evidence

Can’t figure it out.  What’s different this year?  A huge contract and stadiums have fans.  The precision that we saw last year has yet to be seen after two games.  Hopefully that changes sunday 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Everyone go back and see what Miami did to Mahomes last year and check back in on this thread. 

 

Yes Mahomes threw for almost 400 yards - but threw 3 INTs, lost a fumble, and took a 30 yard sack.  Travis Kelce, as usual, was the X Factor with 140 yards not getting covered by Howard or Jones.   Hill ran a long one for a TD and the Chiefs returned a punt for a TD - which really ended the game bc Miami couldn't overcome Tua.  

 

While you're at it, check out the Steelers in weeks 1-6 and what they did to QBs.  

 

 

Everyone wants to compare him to Mahomes well there you go I just did.  Lol.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Doc Brown said:

It's wishful thinking as it was more gameplan specific.

 

They played pretty aggressively against the Steelers with a lot of 10 personnel because they thought they could find a matchup to exploit with their WR depth.  What they didn't count on is Josh to be off and our o-line to look like Bobby Hart x5.

 

Against the Fins, they were more balanced given the strength of their secondary and how anemic the Fins offense was.

 

I'll take it a bit further.  Yes, they played aggressively against the Steelers with a lot of 4WR and 5WR sets, because they were expecting Pittsburgh to do what they did last year -be "Blitzburgh", especially with Tuitt on IR - and they figured they'd find matchups to exploit that way.

 

Instead, Pittsburgh caught the Bills with their "football pants" down by being able to take our OL to the woodshed with 5 guys - which is not entirely on those 5 guys given that Pittsburgh was clever about disguising pressure, overloading one side of the line, and dropping the other side into coverage.  They were also clever flooding the areas that are Allen's bread-and-butter with 7 DB.  Allen commented that he had some short passes, but he tried to be aggressive and go for the deep stuff and missed. 

 

The Fins were more aggressive in their pressures and counted on man coverage, but they played the same thing - to take away the bread-and-butter middle stuff.  Except this time, Allen was prepared to take the short passes and the Bills were prepared to run the ball down their throats.  So we won.


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, Steptide said:

So, I know what I'm about to write sounds absurd, and I can't even bring myself to fully comprehend it, but hear me out a little. 

 

So obviously the bills offense hasent been to our standards through these first 2 games. It's hard to wrap our heads around after seeing how good they were last season. I was thinking about this a bit while at work today. All through camp all I heard from local media and sports guys on Twitter is how good the bills offense was. Passes from Allen rarely hit the ground in camp and the team was on par to take another leap this season. Then we watch them in pre season and for the most part, see the same thing we've been hearing about all throughout camp (even with trubisky playing). Fast forward to the regular season and all of a sudden our offense is anemic. I'm not saying in anyway that Josh is over and under throwing passes intentionally, or missing wide open guys by design. That would be ridiculous. However, I do wonder if to some degree the bills are intentionally being a bit conservative knowing that they have kc, Tampa and other opponents they have to beat if they wanna be super bowl contenders. I'm in no way saying the bills lost to the steelers intentionally or anything crazy like that. I just think this team is way better than what we've seen these last 2 weeks and it's hard for me to believe it's just a regression 

 

The pass protection has been a shell of what it was last year...teams used to blitz and not even get close to Allen last year...now they are only rushing 4 and half the time Allen is getting flushed or hurried, meaning they can drop more into coverage AND still force early throws....not a good combo

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think Josh is pressing too hard, mixed with decent defenses.  With his big payday and his performance last year, I believe he is in his own head and trying to do too much.  He is forcing passes, looking for the pass further down the field and when its not there, the short pass that was open isn't anymore.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On PFT Live just now, Chris Simms was defending Allen a bit and said the Bills' offensive weapons are way overrated and that teams only have to worry about Stefon Diggs but it's not like he's Tyreek Hill. Also said there's a reason Emmanuel Sanders is on his third team in 3 years. Not impressed with our offensive talent.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They're probably not showing their best trick plays with KC in mind, but that's about it. The offense and Josh is working through the Tampa-2 defense that it's now being defended by. Thankfully, the defense and run game are coming along very nicely.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, SCBills said:

This isn’t college where we open with Mercer and SE Louisiana Tech so we can play vanilla for our upcoming game against Bama…

 

That Steelers loss could be the difference between a 1 seed and 2 seed.   
 

Zero chance they’re holding back, but they are absolutely working through things … I highly doubt the offense we’ve seen Weeks 1 & 2 will be what we see Weeks 11 & 12 etc. 

More likely that KC game is the difference between a 1 and 2 seed.  We needed to beat them almost certainly, but I agree they are not holding things back.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, CarolinaBillsFan said:

I think Josh is pressing too hard, mixed with decent defenses.  With his big payday and his performance last year, I believe he is in his own head and trying to do too much.  He is forcing passes, looking for the pass further down the field and when its not there, the short pass that was open isn't anymore.

This I may have something to do with it, but I think he’s confused by what he’s seeing.   Defenses are scheming to take away last season’s bread and butter throws. These are not crazy exotic defenses.  Teams are just more often using coverage schemes that take away the intermediate throws he killed them with last season.  Other stuff is open though (as Warner showed).  Allen will need to hit deep throws and take some short ones when nothing else is there.  Also we are going to have to run the ball more.

 

That he’s feeling extra pressure due to his new, huge contract could certainly be true.  But there’s some other stuff at play here.  Daboll has been using spread formations and the shotgun to simplify reads and keep Allen’s eyes up and on the defense.  That’s why we don’t see much in the way of real play action where Allen’s eyes initially would be looking back at the RB.

 

So what do they do?  The team isn’t built to run a Shanahan style offense which leans on running, traditional play action and a lot of 2 TE and/or 2 RB sets.  I’m not sure how Allen would do in it either.  What we’re running is a lot like the offense NE ran with Brady.  Allen is going to have to make quick decisions and get the ball out fast to be successful.  Presnap reads will be huge.  Then he can hit defenses on the longer stuff when they cheat up.  Or he will have to be patient and kill them with the short stuff.

Edited by BarleyNY
  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

IMHO something is wrong with Josh. It could be some niggling little injury that is hampering his mechanics, could be his big contract is messing with his mind (god I hope not), maybe something even on the home front messing with him. If you have any of last years games saved on your DVR, look at his body language post snap, pre release. He would get the ball, get to his "spot" and set up in a firm steady base and either throw the ball or decide to roll out or run. This year he just looks indecisive, he never "sets his base". Shoot last year sometimes he'd stand soooooo stock still I would think the TV picture had frozen, this year his feet never stop moving.

 

I have no doubt he (and the offense) will shortly return to last years form no matter what the problem is, and with Washington and Houston on our immediate horizon we have a better than average chance to win even at a diminished capacity .... as long as the ship is righted prior to KC & Tenn I'll be happy.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Na I think daboll kind of outsmarted himself week 1 trying to create mismatches with the steelers dbs rather than running the football into the brick wall front 7 of the pit defense and Josh never got comfortable. 

6 hours ago, Gen2 said:

IMHO something is wrong with Josh. It could be some niggling little injury that is hampering his mechanics, could be his big contract is messing with his mind (god I hope not), maybe something even on the home front messing with him. If you have any of last years games saved on your DVR, look at his body language post snap, pre release. He would get the ball, get to his "spot" and set up in a firm steady base and either throw the ball or decide to roll out or run. This year he just looks indecisive, he never "sets his base". Shoot last year sometimes he'd stand soooooo stock still I would think the TV picture had frozen, this year his feet never stop moving.

 

I have no doubt he (and the offense) will shortly return to last years form no matter what the problem is, and with Washington and Houston on our immediate horizon we have a better than average chance to win even at a diminished capacity .... as long as the ship is righted prior to KC & Tenn I'll be happy.  

Hes got both eyes on the offensive line cuz he has no confidence in those guys and he's had happy feet the last couple games...happened last season at times too.  Last years form included games like that...TEN absolutely embarrassed us he was horrible that game.  He doesn't think he has time to set his feet cuz he's getting hit/evading pressure all game long when teams aren't even blitzing.  Better qbs have had far worse games under those circumstances than the last two josh has had 

Edited by Generic_Bills_Fan
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 9/21/2021 at 8:26 PM, Don Otreply said:

It could be a lack of preseason playing time. They have come out looking rusty and out of sync, tell tales of not enough live game speed and hits, they will get past it, but it is the price to pay for not playing your first team guys in the preseason.  That and the Steelers appear to use what KC did, game plan wise in there effort to beat us, could be other things as well, but this seems to be the most straight forward reasoning to me…,

 

Go Bills!!!

🤦‍♂️
 

so, when we drop a second preseason game for an 18th Regular Season game (next year?) we’ll be even worse to start the year?😳

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Generic_Bills_Fan said:

Na I think daboll kind of outsmarted himself week 1 trying to create mismatches with the steelers dbs rather than running the football into the brick wall front 7 of the pit defense and Josh never got comfortable. 

Hes got both eyes on the offensive line cuz he has no confidence in those guys and he's had happy feet the last couple games...happened last season at times too.  Last years form included games like that...TEN absolutely embarrassed us he was horrible that game.  He doesn't think he has time to set his feet cuz he's getting hit/evading pressure all game long when teams aren't even blitzing.  Better qbs have had far worse games under those circumstances than the last two josh has had 

 

I don't think it's going to get any better this week with WFT's front....I believe we'll win but I think Josh is going to have happy feet again unless Dabs can ring up some faster developing routes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 hours ago, Chandler#81 said:

🤦‍♂️
 

so, when we drop a second preseason game for an 18th Regular Season game (next year?) we’ll be even worse to start the year?😳

Likely so, live snaps my man, live snaps, and game speed, nothing, and I mean nothing can take their place as preparation for regular season play, the switch to eighteen games just means that those first two games are what the old preseason games where in quality of play, it’s nothing more than a rearrangement of the deck chairs, oh, and two additional game checks, 😁👍

 

Go Bills!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This same sort of idea was put forth by "Bulldog" a few days ago on Schopp and Bulldog.

 

His basic theory was that we are intentionally holding our offensive scheme back right now, so as to keep some things in reserve for when we are going to really need them against big teams later in the year, particularly the playoffs.

 

I laughed out loud and consider that beyond ridiculous.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 9/22/2021 at 8:21 AM, Giuseppe Tognarelli said:

On PFT Live just now, Chris Simms was defending Allen a bit and said the Bills' offensive weapons are way overrated and that teams only have to worry about Stefon Diggs but it's not like he's Tyreek Hill. Also said there's a reason Emmanuel Sanders is on his third team in 3 years. Not impressed with our offensive talent.


I think teams seem to worry a fair bit about taking away Beasley

 

Sanders, jury still out on whether he’s washed or just hasn’t built rapport with Allen yet.  One pass I saw I think Davis would have gotten it (if healthy)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, Hapless Bills Fan said:


I think teams seem to worry a fair bit about taking away Beasley

 

Sanders, jury still out on whether he’s washed or just hasn’t built rapport with Allen yet.  One pass I saw I think Davis would have gotten it (if healthy)

 

Diggs and Beasley were #1 and #2 in targets on the team last year, teams are scheming to force the ball away from those two. Last year teams weren't ready for 14 and 11, this year they are (at least up to now). We've either faced some very good defenses that can shut down our 2 best receivers, or teams are just making sure that whatever happens make sure you know where 14 and 11 are and don't let them catch the ball.

 

I think we'll be fine. Just need to lean on the run game which looks much better (so far) and draw up plays where 14 and 11 aren't the first or second read while we iron out the kinks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...