Jump to content

The hole on the Bills roster that could ruin the season


Recommended Posts

"If the starting QB goes down, your season is basically over" is the dumbest/weakest football statement that can possibly be made.

Every team in the league's season is basically over if their starting QB goes down. I believe three teams in NFL history have won championships with backup QBs in the lineup. That's it.

Do you really think Joe Flacco is taking the Jets to a Lombardi Trophy?

Essentially, if the biggest hole on your roster, and the only one to which a fan of a rival team can reasonably point to, is BACKUP QB, then it means you have an extremely good roster.

Ya know what's a bigger impediment to winning football games? Not having any good pass rushers or cornerbacks. That's the position the Jets are in. All things considered, I'll take "mediocre backup QB situation" over "no pass rushers or cornerbacks" all day long.

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

42 minutes ago, Logic said:

Every team in the league's season is basically over if their starting QB goes down. I believe three teams in NFL history have won championships with backup QBs in the lineup. That's it.
 

Of course sadly we were on of the teams to lose to a backup QB. Yeah yeah Billicheck, defense, running the ball more etc. 

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, JetsFan20 said:

I’m pretty surprised the Bills as a contender didn’t take out an insurance policy for Josh Allen. With Newton in the fold this division is going to be a dogfight and if Barkley/Fromm has to start meaningful games that could be the difference. 
 

I know you guys love Beane/McDermott and they are doing a great job, but to me they made a mistake here. 

Every team in the division has proven QBs behind their starter with the exception of the prohibitive favorite.  

 

I would not call Darnold the rock of Gibraltar of starters.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

50 minutes ago, ScottLaw said:

Guess you missed the Saints and Bridgewater play after Brees went down. 


Guess you missed the part where I said three teams in NFL history won a Lombardi with a backup QB in the lineup.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Logic said:

"If the starting QB goes down, your season is basically over" is the dumbest/weakest football statement that can possibly be made.

Every team in the league's season is basically over if their starting QB goes down. I believe three teams in NFL history have won championships with backup QBs in the lineup. That's it.

Do you really think Joe Flacco is taking the Jets to a Lombardi Trophy?

Essentially, if the biggest hole on your roster, and the only one to which a fan of a rival team can reasonably point to, is BACKUP QB, then it means you have an extremely good roster.

Ya know what's a bigger impediment to winning football games? Not having any good pass rushers or cornerbacks. That's the position the Jets are in. All things considered, I'll take "mediocre backup QB situation" over "no pass rushers or cornerbacks" all day long.

I agree, but right now there’s no reason not to have a solid backup.  There have never been this many good ones available.  Very few teams are likely to go on a tear with a backup the way New Orleans did, but a good team with a solid backup may go 2-2 whereas that same team may go 0-4 with Nate Peterman or Duck Hodges.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, JetsFan20 said:

I’m pretty surprised the Bills as a contender didn’t take out an insurance policy for Josh Allen. With Newton in the fold this division is going to be a dogfight and if Barkley/Fromm has to start meaningful games that could be the difference. 
 

I know you guys love Beane/McDermott and they are doing a great job, but to me they made a mistake here. 

Every team in the division has proven QBs behind their starter with the exception of the prohibitive favorite.  

 

When I looked last night New England was the favorite with the sportsbooks-- if someone were to be right about Buffalo winning the AFCE they could cash in at 1.5-1.6x their wager amount. New England was down around -110.

 

I actually do agree with your thesis here and was hoping for an upgrade at backup QB with all that cap room we came into the off-season with. Before it got started I was hoping Ryan Fitzpatrick might somehow shake loose, then I wanted your boy Flacco! Or Jameis. I have a degree of trust in the Bills' FO and coaches but I must admit I am unable to arrive at the same conclusion independently pertaining to why are they so comfortable with Matt Barkley.

 

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, JetsFan20 said:

I’m pretty surprised the Bills as a contender didn’t take out an insurance policy for Josh Allen. With Newton in the fold this division is going to be a dogfight and if Barkley/Fromm has to start meaningful games that could be the difference. 
 

I know you guys love Beane/McDermott and they are doing a great job, but to me they made a mistake here. 

Every team in the division has proven QBs behind their starter with the exception of the prohibitive favorite.  

 

 

You're like Jimmy Spagnola Lite.  It's cute.  I like it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

58 minutes ago, The Firebaugh Kid said:

Barkley can win games. His first start here was fantastic. 

Remember 2013 when there was the Barkley, Nassib, Manuel, Glennon, Geno debate and which one would best fit Marrone's West Coast system.  What a waste of time.

  • Haha (+1) 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, Doc Brown said:

Remember 2013 when there was the Barkley, Nassib, Manuel, Glennon, Geno debate and which one would best fit Marrone's West Coast system.  What a waste of time.

 

lol mediocrity at its finest. 

 

we are forever cursed with terrible offensive coaches. 

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, JetsFan20 said:

I’m pretty surprised the Bills as a contender didn’t take out an insurance policy for Josh Allen. With Newton in the fold this division is going to be a dogfight and if Barkley/Fromm has to start meaningful games that could be the difference. 
 

I know you guys love Beane/McDermott and they are doing a great job, but to me they made a mistake here. 

Every team in the division has proven QBs behind their starter with the exception of the prohibitive favorite.  

 

Dude I agree 100% huge mistake. Most Bills fans like Barkley for some reason. The guy is a huge liability and would not have a job on any other roster.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, JetsFan20 said:

I’m pretty surprised the Bills as a contender didn’t take out an insurance policy for Josh Allen. With Newton in the fold this division is going to be a dogfight and if Barkley/Fromm has to start meaningful games that could be the difference. 
 

I know you guys love Beane/McDermott and they are doing a great job, but to me they made a mistake here. 

Every team in the division has proven QBs behind their starter with the exception of the prohibitive favorite.  

 

We could put Fromm at QB and beat your sorry ass team.....twice

 

So....there is that

  • Like (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, JetsFan20 said:

I’m pretty surprised the Bills as a contender didn’t take out an insurance policy for Josh Allen. With Newton in the fold this division is going to be a dogfight and if Barkley/Fromm has to start meaningful games that could be the difference. 
 

I know you guys love Beane/McDermott and they are doing a great job, but to me they made a mistake here. 

Every team in the division has proven QBs behind their starter with the exception of the prohibitive favorite.  

 

You don’t like Barkley ? 
The last game that he started still gives you nightmares? 
 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, GunnerBill said:

I mean our backup situation is bad. I am a little surprised they are content with Barkley. 

Bringing in another QB is a delecate situation....if you bring in a vet who has been a starter and had success....you run a chance of creating a problem

 

I thought the bills handled it right.....Fromm wont be looked at as a threat to Allen but had a lot of college success....so he might be good

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

McBeane are not shy about signing former Panthers, obviously.  The best-known of former Panthers, they passed on. 
 

If you haven't noticed, they have a plan.  Call it a process.  Signing an expensive backup QB, especially a guy who considers himself a starter, isn't part of the plan.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

37 minutes ago, JoPoy88 said:

This is funny because Barkley beat the brakes off the Jets. 
 

Does Jetfan even revisit his own threads anymore? Or does he just drive-by troll us now?


The Jets completely quit on Todd Bowles that game. I think Barkley’s overall body of work speaks for itself. 
 

The Bills had ample opportunities to upgrade that position this offseason and decided not to. 

3 hours ago, John from Riverside said:

Bringing in another QB is a delecate situation....if you bring in a vet who has been a starter and had success....you run a chance of creating a problem

 

I thought the bills handled it right.....Fromm wont be looked at as a threat to Allen but had a lot of college success....so he might be good


Its the most important position on the field. If Allen can’t beat out Joe Flacco, Colt McCoy, Andy Dalton, Jameis Winston, or Marcus Marietta than he’s probably not the guy. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, GunnerBill said:

I mean our backup situation is bad. I am a little surprised they are content with Barkley. 

They probably aren’t. I don’t think Fromm is the answer either; maybe they do. But Cam wasn’t signing with any team that he wouldn’t be at least competing to start. 

Edited by YoloinOhio
  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, FieldGeneral said:

Who is Tampa's insurance policy? Or SF? Or KC? Or Baltimore?


San Francisco has Nate Mullens who is pretty highly regarded around the league. 
 

Baltimore has RG3 who is far more accomplished than Barkley. 
 

KC and TB are up against the cap so they really don’t have that luxury. That said both of their coaches are offensive masterminds who can probably get solid play out of a Chad Henné type. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

51 minutes ago, JetsFan20 said:


The Jets completely quit on Todd Bowles that game. I think Barkley’s overall body of work speaks for itself. 
 

The Bills had ample opportunities to upgrade that position this offseason and decided not to. 

 


The Bills are in the same position as 90% of the league, and that includes your Jets and NE - if they lose their starting QB for any significant length of time, they’re in big trouble. Bridgewater and NO last year notwithstanding, most backup QBs in this league are bad.

 

And it’s comical that you think Flacco isn’t completely washed up after flaming out in Denver last year. I’d be more worried about your starter if I were you anyways. Him, and the fact that your best player is routinely talking trash online trying to get outta town. Worry about that.

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, JoPoy88 said:


The Bills are in the same position as 90% of the league, and that includes your Jets and NE - if they lose their starting QB for any significant length of time, they’re in big trouble. Bridgewater and NO last year notwithstanding, most backup QBs in this league are bad.

 

And it’s comical that you think Flacco isn’t completely washed up after flaming out in Denver last year. I’d be more worried about your starter if I were you anyways. Him, and the fact that your best player is routinely talking trash online trying to get outta town. Worry about that.


I think Flacco can be a Pro Bowl starter for the Jets by years end. Perhaps he had a Vinny Testavetde type run.

 

  • Haha (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, JetsFan20 said:


I think Flacco can be a Pro Bowl starter for the Jets by years end. Perhaps he had a Vinny Testavetde type run.

 

I guess  you are alright, this gave me a good laugh! You Jests fans can be funny! 

 

Adam Gase is up for coach of the year already.......

Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 hours ago, JetsFan20 said:

I’m pretty surprised the Bills as a contender didn’t take out an insurance policy for Josh Allen. With Newton in the fold this division is going to be a dogfight and if Barkley/Fromm has to start meaningful games that could be the difference. 
 

I know you guys love Beane/McDermott and they are doing a great job, but to me they made a mistake here. 

Every team in the division has proven QBs behind their starter with the exception of the prohibitive favorite.  

 


cool username 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 hours ago, DCbillsfan said:

Based on what Beane and McD have done so far, I give them the benefit of the doubt.  They know Cam very well.  Perhaps they didn't believe he would be a good fit.  

Cam wants to be #1.  The Bills don't want a challenger to Allen on board at this point.  I agree w that assessment.  Barkley is #2, knows it, and is supportive of Allen from a vets perspective...perfect to help get Allen's head right.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 hours ago, JetsFan20 said:

I’m pretty surprised the Bills as a contender didn’t take out an insurance policy for Josh Allen. With Newton in the fold this division is going to be a dogfight and if Barkley/Fromm has to start meaningful games that could be the difference. 
 

I know you guys love Beane/McDermott and they are doing a great job, but to me they made a mistake here. 

Every team in the division has proven QBs behind their starter with the exception of the prohibitive favorite.  

 

The only hole I see on the team is at TE, but that's not enough to derail the season.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, ScottLaw said:

You want a back up who can come in and win you a few games if your starter is out. Someone who can keep the ship afloat... if Allen is out for a 4-5 weeks, the Bills are screwed. They'll lose every game with Fromm/Barkley.

 

I agree. 

2 hours ago, YoloinOhio said:

They probably aren’t. I don’t think Fromm is the answer either; maybe they do. But Cam wasn’t signing with any team that he wouldn’t be at least competing to start. 

 

Oh I know. I wasn't expecting the Bills to sign Cam. I just was surprised earlier in the offseason they were not more aggressive at that spot. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...