Jump to content

Cam Newton, NFL MVP. Does any team want him 2021?


Nihilarian

Recommended Posts

Cam Newton 6'5'' 235, who was drafted #1 overall in 2011, 2015 NFL MVP...took the Panthers to a super bowl. Look at him now, a shell of what he once was due to injuries sustained by running the ball over the years in the NFL. Sure, he can still run the ball...now, he can't make a decent downfield throw to save his life.

 

Watch that 49ers, Patriots game week 6. 

 

I look at Josh Allen being the leading rusher for Buffalo against the Colts in the AFC Wildcard game! Leading rusher against the Ravens tied with Motor with seven carries in the AFC Divisional round! Leading rusher against the Chiefs in the AFC Championship game. 

 

Please make this stop! The last thing I want to see as a Bills fan is a supremely talented pocket QB like Allen ending up like Newton because of having to run to attempt to carry the team on his own.  With a 2020 69.25% completion percentage, there is no way that the Bills should even be thinking of letting this QB be the leading rusher in a game! 

 

The Buffalo Bills didn't even attempt a RB run in the entire first quarter against the Ravens and only one RB run in the second quarter. That vaunted, high scoring 2020 Buffalo Bills offense only scored 10 points against the Ravens. The Bills got very, very lucky against the Colts and Ravens as they were out played in both ToP and yards. The Chiefs ripped them a new one though! 

 

As for the Chiefs, they were in Nickle/Dime coverage mostly the entire game and basically daring the Bills to run the ball. Don't worry, the Bills OC didn't call a RB run very often, 11 carries all game for Buffalo RB's. 

 

The AFC Championship game was the second time the Bills faced this team this season, and with worse results! That first game Allen threw for 14 of 27 for 122 yards, 2 TD, 1 INT and rushed for 8 attempts. Singletary had 10 rushes. The first game should have shown the Bills what they were in for. 

 

Why is the Bills OC so damned and defiant about passing the ball when the opposing team is clearly shutting the passing game down?  Four sacks by the Chiefs and so many QB pressures that every time Allen dropped back he was getting harried. 

 

As a Bills fan I want to see Josh Allen as the Buffalo Bills QB in ten years and not looking like Cam Newton does today. McD/Beane, please fix the Bills OC's brain, O line and run game...balance!  

 

Rant off...

  • Like (+1) 1
  • Agree 2
  • Haha (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

N Man, I’ve thought the same thing in that the problem is in the running game as has been discussed so in haste they keep going back to Allen running.  As far as Allen’s designed runs, Id rather see him evolve into the style R. Wilson or even Mahomes adopts. They still run a bit, but more scramble to throw, and move in space.  Both of these QB’s avoid hits.

 

The last thing I want to see is Allen ending up like Cam.  His career is over.  He’ll be lucky to be a backup somewhere, but even that’s a problem as that city will be in a Flutie/Johnson debate all year.  I certainly want non of it in Buffalo.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

IMO injuries aren't the problem with Cam's throwing.

 

I'd argue it's more about mechanical problems and a relative lack of concentration on the fundamentals of the motion (not to even mention the lack of good players around him on offense). He's always gone in and out of tune with his motion, as Chris Simms has mentioned. He's never been all about throwing, and he's always had accuracy problems. He had games this year where his throwing looked pretty good. Then some where it looked awful.

 

I think his injuries would sooner affect his legs and his running, the area that's still his strong point.

 

I share your worry about Josh's long-term health if he keeps running. I think he's going to start sliding more and more as he grows older and cannier. We're seeing it already.

Edited by Thurman#1
  • Like (+1) 2
  • Disagree 1
  • Agree 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Nihilarian said:

Cam Newton 6'5'' 235, who was drafted #1 overall in 2011, 2015 NFL MVP...took the Panthers to a super bowl. Look at him now, a shell of what he once was due to injuries sustained by running the ball over the years in the NFL. Sure, he can still run the ball...now, he can't make a decent downfield throw to save his life.

 

Watch that 49ers, Patriots game week 6. 

 

I look at Josh Allen being the leading rusher for Buffalo against the Colts in the AFC Wildcard game! Leading rusher against the Ravens tied with Motor with seven carries in the AFC Divisional round! Leading rusher against the Chiefs in the AFC Championship game. 

 

Please make this stop! The last thing I want to see as a Bills fan is a supremely talented pocket QB like Allen ending up like Newton because of having to run to attempt to carry the team on his own.  With a 2020 69.25% completion percentage, there is no way that the Bills should even be thinking of letting this QB be the leading rusher in a game! 

 

The Buffalo Bills didn't even attempt a RB run in the entire first quarter against the Ravens and only one RB run in the second quarter. That vaunted, high scoring 2020 Buffalo Bills offense only scored 10 points against the Ravens. The Bills got very, very lucky against the Colts and Ravens as they were out played in both ToP and yards. The Chiefs ripped them a new one though! 

 

As for the Chiefs, they were in Nickle/Dime coverage mostly the entire game and basically daring the Bills to run the ball. Don't worry, the Bills OC didn't call a RB run very often, 11 carries all game for Buffalo RB's. 

 

The AFC Championship game was the second time the Bills faced this team this season, and with worse results! That first game Allen threw for 14 of 27 for 122 yards, 2 TD, 1 INT and rushed for 8 attempts. Singletary had 10 rushes. The first game should have shown the Bills what they were in for. 

 

Why is the Bills OC so damned and defiant about passing the ball when the opposing team is clearly shutting the passing game down?  Four sacks by the Chiefs and so many QB pressures that every time Allen dropped back he was getting harried. 

 

As a Bills fan I want to see Josh Allen as the Buffalo Bills QB in ten years and not looking like Cam Newton does today. McD/Beane, please fix the Bills OC's brain, O line and run game...balance!  

 

Rant off...

The comparison is flawed in terms of character. Newton has always been a me first diva. If anything, Allen is more like Elway than anything like Newton. Look where Newton is today. A broke down and out clown that’s trying to be like Dennis Rodman with his insane asylum fashion.

 

Allen cares far more for the game and is too determined to be the best he can be to be compared to Newton 

  • Like (+1) 2
  • Thank you (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Nihilarian said:

Cam Newton 6'5'' 235, who was drafted #1 overall in 2011, 2015 NFL MVP...took the Panthers to a super bowl. Look at him now, a shell of what he once was due to injuries sustained by running the ball over the years in the NFL. Sure, he can still run the ball...now, he can't make a decent downfield throw to save his life.

 

Watch that 49ers, Patriots game week 6. 

 

I look at Josh Allen being the leading rusher for Buffalo against the Colts in the AFC Wildcard game! Leading rusher against the Ravens tied with Motor with seven carries in the AFC Divisional round! Leading rusher against the Chiefs in the AFC Championship game. 

 

Please make this stop! The last thing I want to see as a Bills fan is a supremely talented pocket QB like Allen ending up like Newton because of having to run to attempt to carry the team on his own.  With a 2020 69.25% completion percentage, there is no way that the Bills should even be thinking of letting this QB be the leading rusher in a game! 

 

The Buffalo Bills didn't even attempt a RB run in the entire first quarter against the Ravens and only one RB run in the second quarter. That vaunted, high scoring 2020 Buffalo Bills offense only scored 10 points against the Ravens. The Bills got very, very lucky against the Colts and Ravens as they were out played in both ToP and yards. The Chiefs ripped them a new one though! 

 

As for the Chiefs, they were in Nickle/Dime coverage mostly the entire game and basically daring the Bills to run the ball. Don't worry, the Bills OC didn't call a RB run very often, 11 carries all game for Buffalo RB's. 

 

The AFC Championship game was the second time the Bills faced this team this season, and with worse results! That first game Allen threw for 14 of 27 for 122 yards, 2 TD, 1 INT and rushed for 8 attempts. Singletary had 10 rushes. The first game should have shown the Bills what they were in for. 

 

Why is the Bills OC so damned and defiant about passing the ball when the opposing team is clearly shutting the passing game down?  Four sacks by the Chiefs and so many QB pressures that every time Allen dropped back he was getting harried. 

 

As a Bills fan I want to see Josh Allen as the Buffalo Bills QB in ten years and not looking like Cam Newton does today. McD/Beane, please fix the Bills OC's brain, O line and run game...balance!  

 

Rant off...

One of these did not cause the other. Cam had one foot injury that shut a season down. 

 

He didn't get a torn labrum in his shoulder from running a football, thus impacting his ability to throw the football.

 

Running is a part of Josh's game and he ran significantly less this year. He's fine.

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Newton made a bad decision (or followed bad advice) when he injured his shoulder. Essentially the same injury Andrew Luck suffered,  it took luck what 18 months to recover? Newton continued to play further damaging the shoulder. 

 

He was never the same after the shoulder injury. I know he had a foot issue and various other things but they were all manageable. I think the shoulder injury hurt his arm strength and he never had the accuracy to make it work without the strength. 

  • Thank you (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Thurman#1 said:

IMO injuries aren't the problem with Cam's throwing.

 

I'd argue it's more about mechanical problems and a relative lack of concentration on the fundamentals of the motion (not to even mention the lack of good players around him on offense). He's always gone in and out of tune with his motion, as Chris Simms has mentioned. He's never been all about throwing, and he's always had accuracy problems. He had games this year where his throwing looked pretty good. Then some where it looked awful.

 

I think his injuries would sooner affect his legs and his running, the area that's still his strong point.

 

I share your worry about Josh's long-term health if he keeps running. I think he's going to start sliding more and more as he grows older and cannier. We're seeing it already.

 It looks like he's trying to throw a refrigerator anytime he attempts something over 10 yards. Painful to watch. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 minutes ago, H2o said:

Cam is washed up. His arm looks done. Imo he has become Chad Pennington without the brains. 

What makes you think he doesn't have the brains. He's had more success than Pennington.

3 hours ago, buffalo2218 said:

The comparison is flawed in terms of character. Newton has always been a me first diva. If anything, Allen is more like Elway than anything like Newton. Look where Newton is today. A broke down and out clown that’s trying to be like Dennis Rodman with his insane asylum fashion.

 

Allen cares far more for the game and is too determined to be the best he can be to be compared to Newton 

That sacrificed his body for his team and likely shortened his career because of it?

  • Like (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

When you're a physical freak you can make a decision to learn the nuances of the game and slowly replace your athleticism with intangibles, protect your body and have a long career.  Or you rely solely on your athleticism, not protect your body, and have a short career.   EIther the coaches around Cam didnt do a good enough job of teaching him the nuances, or Cam decided to not listen.  Either way his career is over because he relied on being bigger and faster than everyone else on the field.

 

I dont know how anyone could watch a guy throw 8 touchdowns in 15 games and think he is a viable starter.   While he may be able to come in as a backup and win a few games with his legs, I dont think he provides enough in the locker room to warrant a shot.   The guys net worth is somewhere around $100 Million so he doesnt need to play football.   He can get back to those birthday parties he missed this year and stop being a martyr in the media.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, klos63 said:

What makes you think he doesn't have the brains. He's had more success than Pennington.

Because if you ever watched Pennington play you would know he made up for his lack of arm strength with his ability to read a defense then get the ball out with timing. He did complete 66% of his passes for his career despite having a noodle arm, especially after the shoulder surgeries. Cam has relied on his legs most of his career and you could tell that the mental aspect was giving him some trouble in NE. His shoulder injury has changed his abilities. When your body starts breaking down then it is your wits that carry you on. I have never seen Cam be one to dissect a defense. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I’m not worried about Josh breaking down the way Newton has. Josh made huge strides this season in avoiding big hits and protecting his body. He is a weapon in the running game and while (I think) everyone agrees we need a better RB run game, you don’t take that part of Josh’s game away from him. 

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, HOUSE said:

It's pretty bad when Matt Barkley is a better option

Fun fact. Broken down Cam’s qb rating 82.9 this year. Matt Barkley’s career qb rating 66.6 (😈)!!!! As a qb, Barkley best characteristic is he’s a really nice guy. 
 

cam ain’t cam anymore but as a backup, he’s not that bad if his shoulder isn’t completely shot (it may be). NE has dog 💩 offensive talent and Cam seemed to be good in the lockerroom.  And it’s nit really so much about Cam as it is about Barkley. I trust the guy who has won 75 games more than the guy who, super nice guy, has won 2.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Cam should head to the XFL. 
That’s not meant as a shot against him. But it would be a fantastic shot for him to face lesser competition and build some confidence. He would immediately be the face of the league (we know he enjoys the spotlight) 

And he needs to show teams he’s better than what happened in New England if he wants to continue playing. As of right now I don’t think anyone would sign him unless there’s a major rash of injuries like WFT had. As for Josh, I don’t see any real comparisons this year to MVP cam. 
Josh has better pocket awareness and doesn’t take half the nasty shots cam used to take behind the line. When running Josh has gotten down a lot more and is not a powerhouse goal line back like how Carolina used cam. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Thurman#1 said:

IMO injuries aren't the problem with Cam's throwing.

 

I'd argue it's more about mechanical problems and a relative lack of concentration on the fundamentals of the motion (not to even mention the lack of good players around him on offense). He's always gone in and out of tune with his motion, as Chris Simms has mentioned. He's never been all about throwing, and he's always had accuracy problems. He had games this year where his throwing looked pretty good. Then some where it looked awful.

 

I think his injuries would sooner affect his legs and his running, the area that's still his strong point.

 

I share your worry about Josh's long-term health if he keeps running. I think he's going to start sliding more and more as he grows older and cannier. We're seeing it already.

 

 It's your first line that I disagree with, at least in part. At best Cam was an average passer, but combined with his running that was enough to make him MVP like Lamar. But the shoulder injury had made him a bad passer so that teams can key on the run. He once had a strong arm and a low 60% completion which was good enough to keep the D guessing. We also never got to see him behind a competent OL or with an elite WR who makes you look great.

 

The sad thing is that he lied to Carolina coaches about his injury because he wanted to compete. Brave but stupid. He's done now. He should retire.

 

 Josh doesn't need to seek contact like Cam, but the designed runs are good to keep the D honest. In the playoffs when the Offense became one dimensional the Bills made it easier for the D.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Meh. Run game schmun game. The Bills are a much better passing team than running team. They way they have spent their cap $$s tells you what they want to prioritise. The result is they are not a very good running offense. Hard to be good at everything in the NFL. Would I like to see them try and get better at run blocking and add some speed at running back? Sure. But I don't want them to give up any passing efficiency to do so. The message I took from the Baltimore game is that is what an oline built to run block looks like in the pass game.... their (the Ravens) pass pro was atrocious. The easiest way of getting Josh hurt (and this is borne out by all the evidence) is to expose him to a lot of hits inside the pocket. I'd argue that was what hurt Cam and the Panthers more than using him in the run game. They had a run first offense with Stewart and the other older guy who ended up at Pittsburgh (was it DeAngelo Williams?) and then McCaffrey with an oline that run blocked better than it pass blocked and Cam got crushed in the pocket far too much. I think we all want them to get a bit better running the ball..... but it HAS to come after maintaining our passing efficiency in the priority list for me. 

Edited by GunnerBill
  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, GunnerBill said:

Meh. Run game schmun game. The Bills are a much better passing team than running team. They way they have spent their cap $$s tells you what they want to prioritise. The result is they are not a very good running offense. Hard to be good at everything in the NFL. Would I like to see them try and get better at run blocking and add some speed at running back? Sure. But I don't want them to give up any passing efficiency to do so. The message I took from the Baltimore game is that is what an oline built to run block looks like in the pass game.... their (the Ravens) pass pro was atrocious. The easiest way of getting Josh hurt (and this is borne out by all the evidence) is to expose him to a lot of hits inside the pocket. I'd argue that was what hurt Cam and the Panthers more than using him in the run game. They had a run first offense with Stewart and the other older guy who ended up at Pittsburgh (was it DeAngelo Williams?) and then McCaffrey with an oline that run blocked better than it pass blocked and Cam got crushed in the pocket far too much. I think we all want them to get a bit better running the ball..... but it HAS to come after maintaining our passing efficiency in the priority list for me. 

Newton’s injury problem has absolutely *nothing* to with hits taken either inside or outside the pocket. https://247sports.com/nfl/carolina-panthers/ContentGallery/Cam-Newton-shoulder-injury-timeline-of-events-126689960/#126689960_2

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, dave mcbride said:

Newton’s injury problem has absolutely *nothing* to with hits taken either inside or outside the pocket. https://247sports.com/nfl/carolina-panthers/ContentGallery/Cam-Newton-shoulder-injury-timeline-of-events-126689960/#126689960_2

 

It was actually the TJ Watt hit referenced in that article that was in my mind's eye. It is fair to say though that it wasn't a single trigger. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, GunnerBill said:

 

It was actually the TJ Watt hit referenced in that article that was in my mind's eye. It is fair to say though that it wasn't a single trigger. 

The injury already had happened by that point. I’m sure the hit was painful, but it didn’t change anything. A torn rotator cuff is a torn rotator cuff. He couldn’t throw the ball 50 yards going into that game.

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

23 minutes ago, Seoulofstone said:

 

 It's your first line that I disagree with, at least in part. At best Cam was an average passer, but combined with his running that was enough to make him MVP like Lamar. But the shoulder injury had made him a bad passer so that teams can key on the run. He once had a strong arm and a low 60% completion which was good enough to keep the D guessing. We also never got to see him behind a competent OL or with an elite WR who makes you look great.

 

The sad thing is that he lied to Carolina coaches about his injury because he wanted to compete. Brave but stupid. He's done now. He should retire.

 

 Josh doesn't need to seek contact like Cam, but the designed runs are good to keep the D honest. In the playoffs when the Offense became one dimensional the Bills made it easier for the D.

 

 

 

Well, I guess we can agree to disagree.

 

But I don't think he's got some unfixable arm problem. Take a look at this:

 

 

 

Go to 2:05.

 

That's a dime, this year, 55 yards in the air, without stepping into it.

 

Might he have injured himself later in the year? Yeah, sure. But I don't think arm strength is a problem for this guy. Throwing is. He hasn't been accurate with any consistency. I think he might get it back together. I'm not saying he will, but IMO he might.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just some food for thought here.

 

The entire NFL world was watching that AFC Championship game and how the Chiefs beat the Buffalo Bills so handily 38-24.

 

All opponents will attempt to duplicate exactly what the Chiefs did in that game on defense. 

 

The Bills don't necessarily need to run more often as they just need to get better at running when needed. However, they needed to run the RB's more often in those playoff games. 

 

2020 Buffalo Bills, #2 overall offense from mostly passing, 20th in rush yards, 20th in yards per attempt in 2020. That's with QB Josh Allen the third leading rusher. Singletary 687, Moss 481, Allen 421, with 2, 4, 8 TDs respectively.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, C.Biscuit97 said:

He’s better than our current backup qb. 

As atrocious as Cam was at times, the dude can still make a couple plays to swing a game for you to gut out a win.

 

If your backup has to play, you’re in trouble but Cam had 20 TD’s last season. Not sure any of our backups put up 20 TD’s starting 15 games.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Newtons arm is done. 

 

Rumblings that he's struggled in the film room for years. Would he be a pillar for Josh to lean on? I doubt it

 

He would be more distraction than anything. I want him nowhere near the Bills. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Cam may have had the worst post-MVP career since Shaun Alexander. I thought he'd have some sort of bounceback this year at least.

 

They were both so dominant during those seasons..

 

He's an intriguing backup for JA only for the reason I always pegged their games as quite similar. But I don't see it happening or really mind either way.

Edited by FormerlyPT5P
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Balanced teams have a better chance at winning a SB then 1 dimensional teams like Buffalo. The only time Josh should ever be running is on a scramble. Daboll made a concerted decision this season to not make our running game much of a priority. Motor, Dingleberry whatever you want to call him regressed. Moss showed some limited progress but got hurt. And TJ was in jail all year. I don't want Josh to flame out like Cam or RG3 and someday Lamar. Teach his OL how to run block without losing their pass protection skills. Draft RB's faster than 4.6 and keep Josh from that season ending injury we all dread.

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, Nihilarian said:

Cam Newton 6'5'' 235, who was drafted #1 overall in 2011, 2015 NFL MVP...took the Panthers to a super bowl. Look at him now, a shell of what he once was due to injuries sustained by running the ball over the years in the NFL. Sure, he can still run the ball...now, he can't make a decent downfield throw to save his life.

 

Watch that 49ers, Patriots game week 6. 

 

I look at Josh Allen being the leading rusher for Buffalo against the Colts in the AFC Wildcard game! Leading rusher against the Ravens tied with Motor with seven carries in the AFC Divisional round! Leading rusher against the Chiefs in the AFC Championship game. 

 

Please make this stop! The last thing I want to see as a Bills fan is a supremely talented pocket QB like Allen ending up like Newton because of having to run to attempt to carry the team on his own.  With a 2020 69.25% completion percentage, there is no way that the Bills should even be thinking of letting this QB be the leading rusher in a game! 

 

The Buffalo Bills didn't even attempt a RB run in the entire first quarter against the Ravens and only one RB run in the second quarter. That vaunted, high scoring 2020 Buffalo Bills offense only scored 10 points against the Ravens. The Bills got very, very lucky against the Colts and Ravens as they were out played in both ToP and yards. The Chiefs ripped them a new one though! 

 

As for the Chiefs, they were in Nickle/Dime coverage mostly the entire game and basically daring the Bills to run the ball. Don't worry, the Bills OC didn't call a RB run very often, 11 carries all game for Buffalo RB's. 

 

The AFC Championship game was the second time the Bills faced this team this season, and with worse results! That first game Allen threw for 14 of 27 for 122 yards, 2 TD, 1 INT and rushed for 8 attempts. Singletary had 10 rushes. The first game should have shown the Bills what they were in for. 

 

Why is the Bills OC so damned and defiant about passing the ball when the opposing team is clearly shutting the passing game down?  Four sacks by the Chiefs and so many QB pressures that every time Allen dropped back he was getting harried. 

 

As a Bills fan I want to see Josh Allen as the Buffalo Bills QB in ten years and not looking like Cam Newton does today. McD/Beane, please fix the Bills OC's brain, O line and run game...balance!  

 

Rant off...

Correlation does not imply causation.


Holy crap.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, DrDawkinstein said:

I havent seen this many incorrect hot takes about Cam Newton since the 2012 Scouting Season.

 

For shame.

 

Cam's career passer rating is 85.8.    That puts him in mediocre QB territory.         In contrast career passer ratings for elite QBs like your Brady/Brees/Rogers   and  the latest generation of Mahomes / Watson / Wilson   are in the high 90s to low 100s.           

 

So which hot take is incorrect?  That Cam was good or that he was mediocre?

 

 

Edited by prissythecat
sentence edit
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, prissythecat said:

 

Cam's career passer rating is 85.8.    That puts him in mediocre QB territory.         In contrast career passer ratings for elite QBs like your Brady/Brees/Rogers   and  the latest generation of Mahomes / Watson / Wilson   are in the high 90s to low 100s.           

 

So which hot take is incorrect?  That Cam was good or that he was mediocre?

 

 

Cam was absolutely a star at his peak. He also had 20 TD’s to 10 INT’s last season.

 

How many back up QB’s in the NFL put up 20 TD’s on offense on that Pats roster?

 

Is Cam still great? No. Is Cam probably one of the best backups in the NFL? Absolutely.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...