Jump to content

So far Bills Secondary appears to be weaker for 2017


gjv001

Recommended Posts

I don't think many GM's or coaches in the NFL would trade Stephon Gilmore and Aaron Williams for Micah Hyde and Jordan Poyer.

 

Really? Depends on the system. And you cant count Aaron Williams at all, he needs to retire. That said, have we drafted yet? Seems every GM agrees this is the deepest DB draft possibly ever. We can get TWO starters in the first 4 rounds.

 

So lets all just relax and let the offseason play out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 169
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Williams is a better safety than Hyde. But as far as versatility and durability, Hyde has more value as a player. I'll take slightly reduced safety play for a full season of play. JMO

 

Aaron Williams played 10 games out of a possible 32 the last two years.

 

Hyde played 31 out of 32 and has only missed one game in the last 4

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not disagreeing with you but I am not agreeing with you either. It is way to early to tell. Let's see what happens on the football field. I will say this, Aaron Williams will probably retire because of his injuries and if he doesn't he is one hit away from good bye NFL. You would rather take a chance on him staying and getting injured again or retiring instead of getting a quality safety now while you have a chance. The money we are saving on these guys will help us in other areas. We simply couldn't afford Gilmore and his shaky inconsistencies. He didn't play like he wanted to be here. How could you shell out big dollars for his up and down performance last season? I'm sure he will be an annual pro bowl player with the Pats but he didn't show us that type of play last year. I'm not saying we will be better but I honestly would take Hyde over Williams knowing what may happen with Williams. Lets hope Seymour gets better under our new coaching staff and we probably will draft another DB.

Edited by offsides#76FredSmerlas
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I am not pretending anything. There Re many scouting reports that talk about his ball tracking abaility. And that happens when his eyes went into the backfield. It happened at FSU and it jas happened here and been talked about by out own coaches.

 

But again guess we all just make **** up and really dont know anything about football

 

Help get them yet another ring so i am sure they are ok with that 4M they gave Hogan

again...NOT the question! I asked if he was worth it for US
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not disagreeing with you but I am not agreeing with you either. It is way to early to tell. Let's see what happens on the football field. I will say this, Aaron Williams will probably retire because of his injuries and if he doesn't he is one hit away from good bye NFL. You would rather take a chance on him staying and getting injured again or retiring instead of getting a quality safety now while you have a chance. The money we are saving on these guys will help us in other areas. We simply couldn't afford Gilmore and his shaky inconsistencies might prove he didn't want to be here either. How could you shell out big dollars for his up and down performance last season? I'm sure he will be an annual pro bowl player with the Pats but he didn't show us that type of play last year. I'm not saying we will be better but I honestly would take Hyde over Williams knowing what may happen with Williams. Lets hope Seymour gets better under our new coaching staff and we probably will draft another DB.

 

re: AW, I think this was the reason behind letting him go. Our secondary was a complete mess without him last year, even though he missed most of the previous season as well. Too much risk. We're better today, imo, than we were for most of last year.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Appears? It is a tire fire

 

However be ready to be flamed. The Rose color glasses of "no matter who the Bills sign it is an awesome signing" are out in full force last two days

 

I don't know, but call me crazy, maybe...... just maybe........ Bills fans are waiting till after FA period and the draft to make their final opinions known. Crazy, right??

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The real test for the front office will be finding upgrades rather than stop gaps. Really early, but we need to find talent that will be with the team for an extended period of time and represent an upgrade over the talent being replaced.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I watched him LIVE. He gets lost when eyes go in backfield. Which is exactly why he has Ball tracking Problems.

 

He will struggle in zone concepts because he gets lost when eyes go in backfield.

 

So your anecdotal amateur opinion is of more value than this guy who makes a living out of it? Got it

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Going back to the 4-3 should allow more pressure on the qb without blitzes and less confusion then Hex had...Also McDermott runs more zone coverages lessoning the need for a big physical corner like Gilmore...Not like he played all that physical anyway

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No I'm as critical as anyone of the Bills, but making off the wall statements that don't even mesh with his scouting report is beyond me. Plenty of things to be critical of,

I don't need to pretend I was watching Darby's eyes at FSU while he was in zone coverage.

 

 

Clearly MAJ was paying close attention to Darby, because he was so highly touted and all and he observed every single football player he has ever watched in college football.

Of course it is weaker. There is no debate. The Bills lost their #1 Corner. You can say that the Patriots overpaid but you can't dispute that the Bills just lost the hardest piece to find in a secondary. #1 Corners don't fall from the sky. There is reason teams pay $$$$ for them in FA.

 

Can we wait until at least preseason to form our judgements?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't think many GM's or coaches in the NFL would trade Stephon Gilmore and Aaron Williams for Micah Hyde and Jordan Poyer.

 

Williams was never going to play again and Gilmore was not worth 14 million a year. Hyde was listed by ESPN as one of the best signings of the day. Neither will replace Gilmore. That will come in the draft, but either one is better than Williams right now.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It is weaker on paper. But unless they shelled out for Gilmore or magically healed AW's neck, that was inevitable. They will almost certainly pick DBs at the draft as well. What matters is how they come together as a unit to execute the new scheme. Because they were **** at the old scheme.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

I loooooove seeing this. hahah the best team, a coaching staff in the NFL believes he does. I'll go with their perspective over anyone's on this board.

 

we will miss Gilmore.

This is such a lazy mindset. The Patriots have made and will continue to make bad moves, it is not like they are infallible.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

LOW HANGING FRUIT BOBBY! Stay down there for awhile get and your credibility up.

 

Didn't your Momma teach you its not nice to speak poorly of the recently departed?... :death:

 

So your anecdotal amateur opinion is of more value than this guy who makes a living out of it? Got it

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That's not how it works.

 

AW saved us $1.7M, not $6.

 

Gilmore didn't save us $14M, that's not an addition.

isn't this a comparison of if Gilmore & Williams stayed on team vs replacement ?

 

had we kept gilmore , he would likely ave $14 mil on the cap

 

had we kept AW , he would have a cap hit of + $6 mil

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't think many GM's or coaches in the NFL would trade Stephon Gilmore and Aaron Williams for Micah Hyde and Jordan Poyer.

 

 

Lately I've been pretty pessimistic on the Bills, however the secondary I actually am more optimistic on this year for 2 reasons.

 

1. Consistency. Last year the moment Aaron Williams went down the whole secondary became a massive tire fire because they could be beat regularly deep. He really was instrumental in keeping things going well. Darby seemed to be kinda wrecked by the coaching staff's communication issues so I would be willing to give him a bit of a shot that his play was partially hurt just by coaching. Additionally while I thought Gilmore is a good player he was a tire fire himself the first half of last year and even when he improved he had zero safety help the back half of the year. Last year the secondary just wasn't dependable when you needed it and the lack of consistency killed the Bills.

 

2. Scheme. McDerms scheme puts the emphasis on the front 7 and less on the back end. It also is a scheme that plays to his players strengths and is far less confusing compared to Rex/Robs which players were ripping on its confusion regularly.

 

I think the team still needs to draft another SAF/CB in rnd 1 or 2 and sign a guy like Alteneer Verner. But while this years secondary may not have the sexy names like A Williams or Gilmore, I think it will be a bit more dependable and better against big plays then last year. My prediction is the pass defense ends up still being in the top half of the league.

 

What I am down big time on is our LBs with Zach Brown likely gone. Ragland is unknown so I won't assume him to be great and Preston Brown has stunk the last 2 years and I am not convinced he can get back to his play as a rookie even back in a 4-3 defense.

Edited by corta765
Link to comment
Share on other sites

My brehs.....I totally agree....our secondary is a mess... everything else im ok with even WR if we can grab Britt, keep Hunter, and a good rookie in the 2nd or 3rd

 

 

 

I don't think many GM's or coaches in the NFL would trade Stephon Gilmore and Aaron Williams for Micah Hyde and Jordan Poyer.

 

Appears? It is a tire fire

However be ready to be flamed. The Rose color glasses of "no matter who the Bills sign it is an awesome signing" are out in full force last two days

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't think many GM's or coaches in the NFL would trade Stephon Gilmore and Aaron Williams for Micah Hyde and Jordan Poyer.

 

 

For the amount of $$ Gilmore was asking for he should have been gone he's not as good as he thinks he is & he probably gave the Pats a discount but wouldn't give the Bills one .

 

As far as Williams goes i hate to see him go he is a team guy a Bills type player not the all about me thing but for the Bills to give him a roster spot like they have for the past 2 years & for him a huge part of the secondary to sit & the team pay the price literally & figuratively didn't make sense !

 

I think they almost had to make this decision for the team & ultimately to not have to bare the blunt of if Williams got hurt & it change the rest of his life in a bad way !!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not sure about the backfield but it seems the fan base is getting more and more annoying.

 

Yeah both Sabres and Bills fans.. but when you've been this inept for so long there isn't much left to agree upon.

 

 

We made the right moves for salary cap reasons. Williams for sure was done, and this team could not afford to tie up $15m in a better than average CB when we will most likely get one of the top CB's in this draft as a replacement. Now we move that money over into multiple holes....

Edited by ddaryl
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Unfortunately Aaron Williams was not even an option for us because of the serious injury. We don't know if he plays again. Micha Hyde is a great player and replacement. Very similar play to AW. Happy Gilmore is gone. He's not a competitor. Let's use that money on football players and draft one of the young CBs in the draft. Many good ones to choose from. Also K. Seymore is going to surprise many in McDermotts scheme. I'm happy how things have tuned out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hey guys. The bills will suck forever and ever. How do unknown this? Because I read MAJBobbys posts. #wah

 

We all knew we weren't a contender and had a multitude of free agents while not having much cap room or draft picks. It's going to be a rebuilding ear without completely tanking. Hopefully we can ad some good young players in FA and the draft that can help us this year and that we can build around. That's thets reality. Get used to it.

Edited by NewEra
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oooo yeah this Carolina Fan knows but another fan doesnt. Nice. Got it you dont like what i say. Cool and i could also be wrong. But i also onow what i have watched and i know the way i have seen something. And i stand by my watching and looking at a player.

 

Try it sometime instead of just taking other peoples word for it. It is kinda fun in life to be out there on your own

So since you got clowned on your constant Tyrod assessments last year, Darby is going to be your target this year?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think Hyde is a good replacement at Safety. Losing Gilmore will hurt but lets see who else the Bills bring in. Gilmore is a good corner but not worth the money he is getting from the Pats. Lets see how the Bills secondary plays with the new scheme before passing judgement.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The secondary doesn't appear to be weaker. It is and the dropoff is Huuuuuge.

For,those that don't think the team will miss Gilmore (and others) they are in for a surprise.

Darby is now their top DB. How was his play last year?

I sure hope they are ready to play tomorrow, oh wait. They don't play for 6 months and have plenty of time to continue to build the roster.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...