Jump to content

EDIT: Total cost to taxpayers? Bills select sports firm to represent ownership in building new open air stadium in OP, targeted for 2025


Recommended Posts

22 hours ago, SectionC3 said:

I’ll say it again.  It’s not going downtown.  It’s time to put that hope to rest.

 

Say the state says that we’ll provide $600mil for a new stadium.  The cost in OP probably comes in around $900mil, from what I’ve gathered.  The Pegulas then cover $300mil for the stadium.  Maybe some of that is NFL money, maybe some of it is a 1031 from the sale of the Sabres (I’m assuming that’s happening).  Whatever.  Either way, it’s a $300mil bite in OP.  

 

Downtown is different.  There are land acquisition costs that they don’t have in OP.  There are infrastructure issues (new entrances/exits on the 190; reconstruction of arterial roads, perhaps a new practice facility, etc.).  There’s electric issues, sewer issues, parking issues . . . A whole raft of things that I wouldn’t normally think about.  Now, say the infrastructure costs requires a $1.2b outlay for the project.  All of a sudden (I’m sure everyone’s shedding crocodile tears for the rich folks now), the Pegulas need another $300m—for a total of $600m—to cover the costs of the stadium.  What’s the likelihood they recover that $300m in a time sufficient to justify the cost of that capital?  Post-pandemic, my guess is that it doesn’t happen.  Hence the focus on Orchard Park. 

It’s almost like Tim Graham read this before he wrote his recent article. 

23 minutes ago, Greg S said:

 

I looked it up and not only was she born in Buffalo but she still lives there with her husband and kids. From Wikipedia...

 

Hochul is married to William J. Hochul Jr., a former United States attorney for the Western District of New York.[73] They reside in Buffalo, New York, and have two children

 

Hamburg.  She’s from the burg. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 minutes ago, papazoid said:

i'm still predicting opening day of a new stadium not until the year 2030

You're probably not far off on that. Guess it depends on how all the issues and the many things this type of process takes gets sorted out and how quick or slow things can move. With 2030 being 9 years away and also probably won't even get started good for couple years, you may be pretty close.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Greg S said:

 

I looked it up and not only was she born in Buffalo but she still lives there with her husband and kids. From Wikipedia...

 

Hochul is married to William J. Hochul Jr., a former United States attorney for the Western District of New York.[73] They reside in Buffalo, New York, and have two children

 

She also worked with Tim Russert back when she was a teenager. I have a link but I'm not going to post it here... for fear of

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, LeGOATski said:

Exactly. Toronto had the biggest potential and we see how that turned out. Idk...maybe it's still a low-key option.

 

Honestly, San Antonio/Austin is the only other realistic option for an area who wants a team and could pay for it. That's why the rumor started. Hard to envision that move, though. It doesn't really make sense for the NFL. They'd be better off adding a couple expansion teams.

Wouldn’t it be just like the NFL to give say Austin the Bills and then give Buffalo an expansion team… just when the Bills got good again.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, PatsFanNH said:

Wouldn’t it be just like the NFL to give say Austin the Bills and then give Buffalo an expansion team… just when the Bills got good again.

 

Nobody's "giving" the Bills to Austin or anywhere else.  Don't you have a cheaters forum you can visit?

  • Like (+1) 1
  • Thank you (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, LeGOATski said:

Honestly, San Antonio/Austin is the only other realistic option for an area who wants a team and could pay for it. That's why the rumor started.

Yeah was a silly rumor at that. As far as San Antonio, I remember seeing that mentioned as to be more believable than Austin. Austin was just laughable to me. I would have called BS on  San Antonio also. Although not quite as complete non sense as Austin, it's not far off.

 

You think of all the Cowboy fans which I think out numbers Texan fans that majority of population are die hard Cowboys, you know as they say "Americas Team" lol. That alone makes it hard to believe...add in the fact that Austin officials had no clue and knew absolutely nothing at all about it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 minutes ago, PatsFanNH said:

Wouldn’t it be just like the NFL to give say Austin the Bills and then give Buffalo an expansion team… just when the Bills got good again.

History repeats itself...

 

I think serious expansion talk has already started within the NFL offices, though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Sheneneh Jenkins said:

Yeah was a silly rumor at that. As far as San Antonio, I remember seeing that mentioned as to be more believable than Austin. Austin was just laughable to me. I would have called BS on  San Antonio also. Although not quite as complete non sense as Austin, it's not far off.

 

You think of all the Cowboy fans which I think out numbers Texan fans that majority of population are die hard Cowboys, you know as they say "Americas Team" lol. That alone makes it hard to believe...add in the fact that Austin officials had no clue and knew absolutely nothing at all about it.

I wouldn't look at them as exclusive markets. SA+Austin are basically a package deal for an expansion team. And I wonder if they could call themselves the "Texas Somethings" using the whole state as their moniker instead of a city. The same way Arizona, Tennessee, Minnesota, New England do. Would be a tough sell with Dallas and Houston already there. But Houston named themselves the Texans, so...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, LeGOATski said:

I wouldn't look at them as exclusive markets. SA+Austin are basically a package deal for an expansion team. And I wonder if they could call themselves the "Texas Somethings" using the whole state as their moniker instead of a city. The same way Arizona, Tennessee, Minnesota, New England do. Would be a tough sell with Dallas and Houston already there. But Houston named themselves the Texans, so...

I just find it hard to see another team in Texas at all. That's just me though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

$1.4B budget for an open air stadium in OP is absolutely mind boggling. Minnesota just built a state of the art, glass domed stadium in downtown Minneapolis for $1B. One of the nicest stadiums in the league. I know construction costs are higher now due to Covid, but it still makes no sense. 

 

I would've thought a stadium in OP would cost half of what they are budgeting.

  • Like (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

38 minutes ago, Sheneneh Jenkins said:

Yeah was a silly rumor at that. As far as San Antonio, I remember seeing that mentioned as to be more believable than Austin. Austin was just laughable to me. I would have called BS on  San Antonio also. Although not quite as complete non sense as Austin, it's not far off.

 

You think of all the Cowboy fans which I think out numbers Texan fans that majority of population are die hard Cowboys, you know as they say "Americas Team" lol. That alone makes it hard to believe...add in the fact that Austin officials had no clue and knew absolutely nothing at all about it.

 

Of course it was BS - Pegulas are partnering with Legends owned by Jerry Jones.  The only way Texas gets another team is if Jerry is owner and it is in AFC.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Patience said:

I usually hate the type of post that I'm about to make, but take it for what it is:

 

Have a friend (yeah, one of those deals) whose family is long entrenched and active in NYS and local (West Seneca, Orchard Park area) politics, and I've been communicating with him regarding the stadium issue since the new stadium report came to light.  He's assured me that there is "zero chance" that the stadium deal doesn't get done, and therefore there is "zero chance" the team moves.  Take it for what it is, I suppose.  But he's given me insight on non-Bills related matters that turned out the way he said they would.  

 

I’m hearing the same thing.  I know that EC has been preparing for this day.  I assume the state would have been doing the same thing.  I just don’t trust that the stadium deal is done until it actually gets done.  Logic tells me that it’s going to happen.  But I’m guarded in my optimism, especially after what occurred with Amazon in NYC. Bottom line:  hopefully Kathy makes this a top priority (in addition to the sea of other things she has to do) and gets this thing moving ASAP.  Quite honesty, if I was her, I’d put Poloncarz in charge of the deal because he’s exceptionally competent, he knows the game, they know him, and he can get it done fast. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

31 minutes ago, LeGOATski said:

3 teams in New York, 3 in California, 3 in Florida....

 

What's so hard about it?

1 team in NY. What's hard to see it for me is I think the fan base for Cowboys are larger than the Florida and Cali teams fan base. Probably whole lot more, along with just Texas itself. I mean basically majority of Texas are Cowboys fans. More than Texans I'd assume. 

 

Just done see another team if moved to Texas having the fan base needed. 

13 minutes ago, Limeaid said:

 

Of course it was BS - Pegulas are partnering with Legends owned by Jerry Jones.  The only way Texas gets another team is if Jerry is owner and it is in AFC.

Even then if that scenario happened, I don't see another team in Texas. Doubt enough Cowboy fans would jump ship. Some probably. Just don't see it in Texas.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, YoloinOhio said:

I’m upset that I subscribe to the athletic, I’m logged in, but it won’t let me read the tim graham article on the stadium stuff. I contacted customer support. Can anyone summarize 

 

Try logging out and then back in if you haven't already. Sometimes it be like that....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

59 minutes ago, Sheneneh Jenkins said:

Try logging out and then back in if you haven't already. Sometimes it be like that....

I tried and it’s so weird. I’m logged in fine, it recognizes me and the articles I want, but it won’t show me the whole thing and keeps telling me to subscribe even though I’m an active subscriber. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, YoloinOhio said:

I tried and it’s so weird. I’m logged in fine, it recognizes me and the articles I want, but it won’t show me the whole thing and keeps telling me to subscribe even though I’m an active subscriber. 

That happened to me a few weeks back. I emailed customer support and whatever they did/suggested seemed to work. Can’t recall specifically what they said to do. 

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, YoloinOhio said:

I tried and it’s so weird. I’m logged in fine, it recognizes me and the articles I want, but it won’t show me the whole thing and keeps telling me to subscribe even though I’m an active subscriber. 

Yeah that's weird. Support is about the only thing you can do then.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 8/9/2021 at 8:55 AM, Rochesterfan said:


 

Nope a hotel attached and restaurants do very little for 350 days a year.  
 

At least downtown those hotels and restaurants can cater to the working people that are there everyday - plus you hit hockey, baseball, festivals, just a ton of potential dates, but in OP - there is nothing to feed it.  
 

You would need to build a stadium, a fan experience, a hall of fame with gift shop, hotel, restaurants, an office complex to help support the restaurants during the off season, some shopping and movie spots to bring customers to the area.  

 

Basically you are building the galleria mall around the stadium and hoping it can bring enough people that it doesn’t collapse on itself with the cost.  You are also doing this at a time that destination shopping and restaurants are starting to go under as people order items from Amazon, Grub Hub, Door Dash, etc.  those exact type of things are going under all over the country.

I think if you had gaming on-site slots, poker, sport betting it would work for at least 22-30 weekends a year once you factor in a few concerts, festivals etc. One reason I haven't been back after living in S.FL is its cheap to see them play in Miami, family friendly environment and the kids can hang in the lounge with the wife without worry. In Buffalo a hotel and entertainment then my wife would be happy to stay in the room watch from above and the kids play or watch tv maybe come down for half the game. 

 

Coming to buffalo now you have crappy hotel options near the stadium, crappy family environment at the game and not so great weather. So if you are going to pull in those families you need better amenities and lodging. Drunk college kids aren't going to spend the money a Dad will with 2-3 kids and wife in tow at the venue and in the town.

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, Back2Buff said:

Now is the time to get this funding with the governor being from the area.  

 

If someone is going to understand what the Bills mean to the entire area/tourism, it's going to be someone from the area.  Get this done before she leaves office.

 

There is no other option, as the current lease expires in less than 2 years and a deal needs  to be done well before then, to even make an extension viable.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thing is, I do want a new stadium but we are a small market team. I do not expect the  Bills to spend lavishly. I’d be happy with a $750M stadium! Maybe Terry can go halfsies with NYS. 
 

Tear down RWS stadium and just put up a cost effective dome there! Tailgating stays the same, location stays the same. They can host concerts, WWE events and random other venues in offseason. Have that puppy paid off in 5 or 10 years no problem! Come up with a cool design, cut capacity which will also cut traffic and congestion. Be smart about it.

  • Agree 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Victory Formation said:

Thing is, I do want a new stadium but we are a small market team. I do not expect the  Bills to spend lavishly. I’d be happy with a $750M stadium! Maybe Terry can go halfsies with NYS. 
 

Tear down RWS stadium and just put up a cost effective dome there! Tailgating stays the same, location stays the same. They can host concerts, WWE events and random other venues in offseason. Have that puppy paid off in 5 or 10 years no problem! Come up with a cool design, cut capacity which will also cut traffic and congestion. Be smart about it.

It’s gonna be 50/50, OP is the main place for the new stadium as it’s the cheaper option. The new stadium is probably going to be more than 750 million.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Buffalo619 said:

If I were Pegs, I would expect 50/50 from state. NFL to pick up half of my 50. Total out of pocket 25% of total cost. Have the city and state throw in a new 6 lane parkway to the stadium and some other perks. I would raise ticket prices 50-60%, PSLs for season holders and cut the price of beer and other concentions* to a doable $6 a pint and $3 teds hotdogs. 

 

attract the few local cooperations with state of the art boxes/ suites.  

 

 

Yeah…

 

: whistles :

 

That’s a pretty sweet deal!!!  

 

For the Pegulas.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Buffalo619 said:

If I were Pegs, I would expect 50/50 from state. NFL to pick up half of my 50. Total out of pocket 25% of total cost. Have the city and state throw in a new 6 lane parkway to the stadium and some other perks. I would raise ticket prices 50-60%, PSLs for season holders and cut the price of beer and other concentions* to a doable $6 a pint and $3 teds hotdogs. 

 

attract the few local cooperations with state of the art boxes/ suites.  
 

build a couple parking garages and offer valet. Offer a no wait line for those who are pre-checked (similar to tsa) for a small monthly fee, $25. Valet for $50. $45 for season ticket holders. 

Put a casino on grounds, with sport betting. A couple bars/ restaurants. Make it an attraction. 

somehow find a way to get a super bowl here. 
 


 

 

If you live in buffalo you know there is 0% chance of the first bolded . 

 

And the second half would only happen if Terry pegula 100% footed that restaurant/casino 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 hours ago, Victory Formation said:

Thing is, I do want a new stadium but we are a small market team. I do not expect the  Bills to spend lavishly. I’d be happy with a $750M stadium! Maybe Terry can go halfsies with NYS. 
 

Tear down RWS stadium and just put up a cost effective dome there! Tailgating stays the same, location stays the same. They can host concerts, WWE events and random other venues in offseason. Have that puppy paid off in 5 or 10 years no problem! Come up with a cool design, cut capacity which will also cut traffic and congestion. Be smart about it.

 

The stadium I could see the Bills getting is something similar to what the Colts have. It's a nice stadium but its not crazy expensive like the Cowboys, Rams, Chargers,  all have. Buffalo is also a tailgating fanbase To have all the bells and whistles of a new stadium like restaurants, bars, and shops would be a waste. Who wants to spend an arm and leg on food, and beer when they can do it much cheaper and have more fun in the parking lot.

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I understand the negotiations are done behind closed doors, but it is BS that the designs have not been released for a stadium that is going to be funded by at least 40% taxpayer money.  The stadium study was completed sometime last year.  Even if some of the bells and whistles change going forward, what is it that is so secretive as of today?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, Buffalo619 said:

If I were Pegs, I would expect 50/50 from state. NFL to pick up half of my 50. Total out of pocket 25% of total cost. Have the city and state throw in a new 6 lane parkway to the stadium and some other perks. I would raise ticket prices 50-60%, PSLs for season holders and cut the price of beer and other concentions* to a doable $6 a pint and $3 teds hotdogs. 

 

attract the few local cooperations with state of the art boxes/ suites.  
 

build a couple parking garages and offer valet. Offer a no wait line for those who are pre-checked (similar to tsa) for a small monthly fee, $25. Valet for $50. $45 for season ticket holders. 

Put a casino on grounds, with sport betting. A couple bars/ restaurants. Make it an attraction. 

somehow find a way to get a super bowl here. 
 


 

 


 

I don’t expect even close to 50/50.  I think the Pegula’s big concession is having the stadium in OP.  I would expect a final split along the way of 75/25 maybe 70/30 public/private with a 40 year lease with pretty good terms and the county/state picking up renovations along the way.


I also would expect part of this to be more land given to the Pegula’s from the ECC lot and I could see them getting most of the parking minus some fees to help cover the cost.

 

I think that helps keep ticket prices slightly lower and keeps PSLs to minimum.  I would also expect to see them work on including parking into ticket prices to begin to limit street/private lot parking.

 

I could see a casino maybe on site, but trying to “make it an attraction” doesn’t really work in OP.  The restaurants and bars would struggle to survive with basically 300+ days of down time between football season.  
 

If it was downtown - at least you could draw festival crowds on weekends and downtown workers during the week, plus Crowds from Baseball games during the summer and Hockey games during the winter.  You suddenly have potential clients most days to help supplement the off season - whereas in OP you have none of that.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, Buffalo619 said:

If I were Pegs, I would expect 50/50 from state. NFL to pick up half of my 50. Total out of pocket 25% of total cost. Have the city and state throw in a new 6 lane parkway to the stadium and some other perks. I would raise ticket prices 50-60%, PSLs for season holders and cut the price of beer and other concentions* to a doable $6 a pint and $3 teds hotdogs. 

 

attract the few local cooperations with state of the art boxes/ suites.  
 

build a couple parking garages and offer valet. Offer a no wait line for those who are pre-checked (similar to tsa) for a small monthly fee, $25. Valet for $50. $45 for season ticket holders. 

Put a casino on grounds, with sport betting. A couple bars/ restaurants. Make it an attraction. 

somehow find a way to get a super bowl here. 
 


 

 

Will never happen with an OP stadium. Especially if open Air and not domed. 

 

Also, not enough infrastructure, hotels being the main piece in the direct area to handle it. 

1 hour ago, Mat68 said:

Timing is everything.  Buffalo just came off AFC Championship game.  Looking like a good team for awhile.  Change in the Gov is the cherry on top.  No politican is going to let a playoff team walk out the state.  Pegulas have 100% of the leverage.  Imo the deal is all but done.  Does the state pay 100% maybe not but the vast majority.

THE NFL DOES NOT CARE, This needs to be said 1000000 more times apparently.

 

Also, please stop acting like politicians are sports fans, how many examples do we need of politicians screwing up player names, team names and events to show that.

 

The NFL wants money, if they don't get money here they will get it somewhere else.

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

42 minutes ago, CountDorkula said:

Will never happen with an OP stadium. Especially if open Air and not domed. 

 

Also, not enough infrastructure, hotels being the main piece in the direct area to handle it. 

THE NFL DOES NOT CARE, This needs to be said 1000000 more times apparently.

 

Also, please stop acting like politicians are sports fans, how many examples do we need of politicians screwing up player names, team names and events to show that.

 

The NFL wants money, if they don't get money here they will get it somewhere else.

My point is I expect the State and county to pay.  Politicans dont care about the Bills and Buffalo.  They do care about re election and exposure.  A playoff team possibly championship team brings national exposure.  Keeping the Bills in Buffalo helps re election.  Multiple factors pointing to the state paying.  Thats what makes them stay. 

 

Teams leave when they want to or dont get money they want.  I think Peguals would LIKE to stay.  Now if needed I dont doubt they would move.  I think the money gets worked out.  Buffalo is the only playoff in the State including Jets and Giants.  I dont think the Bills could have drawn up a better circumstance to negotiate a stadium deal.  They have all the leverage. 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, CountDorkula said:

Will never happen with an OP stadium. Especially if open Air and not domed. 

 

Also, not enough infrastructure, hotels being the main piece in the direct area to handle it. 

THE NFL DOES NOT CARE, This needs to be said 1000000 more times apparently.

 

Also, please stop acting like politicians are sports fans, how many examples do we need of politicians screwing up player names, team names and events to show that.

 

The NFL wants money, if they don't get money here they will get it somewhere else.

They’re getting the money from here, the Bills aren’t leaving Buffalo and that’s a fact. Pegula would have to give up the Sabres which he isn’t doing and it cost more to move the bills. We’re getting a new stadium and per Tim graham, he confirmed that the Pegulas aren’t expecting the taxpayers to front the whole cost and the whole Austin thing was made up by a reporter cause he wanted clicks. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If this really ends up an open air stadium in OP, I will be semi-disappointed by the bush league, short-sighted move, but not surprised at all as that is typical Buffalo MO.

 

Great to keep the tailgating and weather elements. But really missing out on a opportunity to progress the city.

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

7 hours ago, Rochesterfan said:

 

I think that helps keep ticket prices slightly lower and keeps PSLs to minimum.  I would also expect to see them work on including parking into ticket prices to begin to limit street/private lot parking.

 

 

I do not see the Pegulas doing a $nyder who limited people who could walk into stadium requiring people to either park or talking a shuttle bus which they needed to pay for.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, Limeaid said:

 

 

I do not see the Pegulas doing a $nyder who limited people who could walk into stadium requiring people to either park or talking a shuttle bus which they needed to pay for.


 

If either side makes money from parking - why wouldn’t you do everything to make it part of the price.  Why give free money to the side lots?

 

The stadium being out in the middle of the suburbs allowed parking in people’s houses.  You just add a parking fee to the ticket - people can still park wherever, but either the county or the team gets the money.  
 

Then you make the lots free to park - so the neighborhood lots can’t match the price and you open up a big area by the stadium as a party zone with food, drinks, merchandise, games, etc to draw people and if you couple that with opening the lots later - you can get more people to buy your stuff rather than bring their own.

 

The object for the teams is to make money and if people tailgate with their own food and drinks and park in private lots - that is money you lose.  Plus it allows people to get way to drunk before even entering the game.
 

It is not just Snyder- most stadiums are associated with public owned lots that bring good money to the area if you want to park close - if not they have public transport, buses, subway, etc that again give money to the community.  

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...