Jump to content

Voluntary Opt outs


Recommended Posts

3 minutes ago, Buffalo716 said:

https://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2017/03/13/jordan-cameron-a-lot-of-us-in-the-nfl-dont-love-football/

 

https://www.denverpost.com/2011/02/01/do-players-really-love-money-more-than-the-game/

 

@Dopey

@Limeaid

 

It's really tough to gauge what the real number is. But a quick search it's easy to see lots players don't love the game

 

And I know lots of players who played high-level football who didn't love it

I put a skeptical emoji up on your post because you claimed 70-75 % of players don't like the sport and only 10% are passionate of the sport. My issue is someone claiming he got these numbers from his time in the sport and conversations you've had with players. I mean, unless this was an actual study, you haven't spoken to nearly enough players/ex players to produce those numbers.

That's roughly 1200 players not liking the sport and roughly 160 players that are passionate. I will was going to call bs.

Thanks for acknowledging it's hard to gauge the real numbers though.

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, Buffalo716 said:

https://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2017/03/13/jordan-cameron-a-lot-of-us-in-the-nfl-dont-love-football/

 

https://www.denverpost.com/2011/02/01/do-players-really-love-money-more-than-the-game/

 

@Dopey

@Limeaid

 

It's really tough to gauge what the real number is. But a quick search it's easy to see lots players don't love the game

 

And I know lots of players who played high-level football who didn't love it

 

You keep focusing on love of the game. I get it, hard on the body. 

 

Go find another job. I learned I didn’t love banking. 

 

People don’t usually love their jobs. That’s life. I pray people can find something they at least like. We are blessed, my wife LOVES her job as much as I used to love mine. She’s very good at it and as a result I don’t have to work. But I still miss my old job. It’s a nice feeling to be active and be good at something. I miss it. 

  • Like (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Dopey said:

I put a skeptical emoji up on your post because you claimed 70-75 % of players don't like the sport and only 10% are passionate of the sport. My issue is someone claiming he got these numbers from his time in the sport and conversations you've had with players. I mean, unless this was an actual study, you haven't spoken to nearly enough players/ex players to produce those numbers.

That's roughly 1200 players not liking the sport and roughly 160 players that are passionate. I will was going to call bs.

Thanks for acknowledging it's hard to gauge the real numbers though.

I should have said not passionate about the game, instead of not liking it

 

99% of the game at a high level is preparation work. And after years and years and years of that it just drains the passion for the game. Sure the actual 60 minutes of game time still could be enjoyable, but the actual job of being a player. The actual grind of preparation work sucks the passion out of tons of guys

 

 

  • Thank you (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Buffalo716 said:

https://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2017/03/13/jordan-cameron-a-lot-of-us-in-the-nfl-dont-love-football/

 

https://www.denverpost.com/2011/02/01/do-players-really-love-money-more-than-the-game/

 

@Dopey

@Limeaid

 

It's really tough to gauge what the real number is. But a quick search it's easy to see lots players don't love the game

 

And I know lots of players who played high-level football who didn't love it


I think there is a lot of nuance here and you are painting with a broad brush. I think the picture you are painting is more akin to Andre Agassi, which is consider an outlier. But as you get better at sport, whatever it may be, it’s no longer about the game but the pursuit of excellence. You learn to get through the year for a single opportunity at greatness, and the goal isn’t having fun, it’s being the best. I have a friend who came out of f retirement to try and win her 3rd Olympic gold. When asked why she said “because I want to prove I am the best in the world” it wasn’t “because I love rowing” 

 

You mentioned Tom Brady. He doesn’t have a chip on his shoulder because of his love of the game, he has a chip because he wasn’t to be the greatest. 
 

I owe my life to the sport of rowing. It allowed me to live at the Olympic training center for a number of years. But training isn’t fun. Hell, racing isn’t all that fun. It’s a huge ball of nerves for the terrible things you’re about to will your body to do. Matthew Pinsent, 4x olympic good medalist in 4 straight Olympics threw up at every single starting line of an Olympic final. Steve Redgrave, 5 Olympics, 5 straight gold medals said after his 3rd or 4th, if you see me in a boat again, you have permission to shoot me. People like that may have lost their juvenile “love of the game” but gained a much deeper respect, understanding, and love for sport as a whole.  
 

If you were to have a larger conversation other than “do you love football” you would find that these guys have a drive and need to compete inside of them that you cannot possibly empathize with. 
 

EDIT/ADD ON: there was a point when my physiology was really great. On my irregular cross train days I was getting pretty close to training numbers for the triathlon team. I considered when my rowing career was over heading to Colorado Springs to train sport specific. I didn’t love triathlons, but I was passionate about greatness. 

Edited by Mango
  • Like (+1) 1
  • Thank you (+1) 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 minutes ago, Mango said:


I think there is a lot of nuance here and you are painting with a broad brush. I think the picture you are painting is more akin to Andre Agassi, which is consider an outlier. But as you get better at sport, whatever it may be, it’s no longer about the game but the pursuit of excellence. You learn to get through the year for a single opportunity at greatness, and the goal isn’t having fun, it’s being the best. I have a friend who came out of f retirement to try and win her 3rd Olympic gold. When asked why she said “because I want to prove I am the best in the world” it wasn’t “because I love rowing” 

 

You mentioned Tom Brady. He doesn’t have a chip on his shoulder because of his love of the game, he has a chip because he wasn’t to be the greatest. 
 

I owe my life to the sport of rowing. It allowed me to live at the Olympic training center for a number of years. But training isn’t fun. Hell, racing isn’t all that fun. It’s a huge ball of nerves for the terrible things you’re about to will your body to do. Matthew Pinsent, 4x olympic good medalist in 4 straight Olympics threw up at every single starting line of an Olympic final. Steve Redgrave, 5 Olympics, 5 straight gold medals said after his 3rd or 4th, if you see me in a boat again, you have permission to shoot me. People like that may have lost their juvenile “love of the game” but gained a much deeper respect, understanding, and love for sport as a whole.  
 

If you were to have a larger conversation other than “do you love football” you would find that these guys have a drive and need to compete inside of them that you cannot possibly empathize with. 
 

EDIT/ADD ON: there was a point when my physiology was really great. On my irregular cross train days I was getting pretty close to training numbers for the triathlon team. I considered when my rowing career was over heading to Colorado Springs to train sport specific. I didn’t love triathlons, but I was passionate about greatness. 

I totally understand the drive to be great.  I played high-level football and sports my whole life

 

I've gotten into fights on the pickup basketball court because I'm so competitive. I don't think I struggle with competitors striving to be great

 

But by the time they reach that level a lot of them have lost their passion for the sport. You don't have to love something to strive to be great. That's just competitive nature

 

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, eball said:

[getting back on track]

 

So Star is the only Buffalo opt-out at this point?  Everyone had to report to camp yesterday for their first COVID test so maybe we’re in the clear?

He was the only one to opt out yesterday. They actually have until  8/4 to do so.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, YoloinOhio said:

He was the only one to opt out yesterday. They actually have until  8/4 to do so.

 

Right, but wouldn’t you think they’d have made their decisions before reporting?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, eball said:

[getting back on track]

 

So Star is the only Buffalo opt-out at this point?  Everyone had to report to camp yesterday for their first COVID test so maybe we’re in the clear?

 

5 minutes ago, YoloinOhio said:

He was the only one to opt out yesterday. They actually have until  8/4 to do so.

 

Once a player opts out, he can't reverse his decision. At least that's what I thought I'd heard. You may see a flurry at the deadline as guys seriously ponder what is best for them and their families.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 minutes ago, eball said:

 

Right, but wouldn’t you think they’d have made their decisions before reporting?

We don’t know who all reported other than the pictures we’ve seen from the Bills or the players on social Media. I heard that there are players (not necessarily Bills) that have made their decisions and notified the team but the paperwork isn’t done because there are lawyers involved, there are still issues to be worked out with the CBA, and therefore it hasn’t been filed yet 


I mentioned in another thread but I wouldn’t be surprised to see Hauschka opt out. His wife just had a baby and Bills drafted a kicker so danger of being cut. If he doesn’t want to move around to another team in a pandemic he might take the year off. 

Edited by YoloinOhio
  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

31 minutes ago, ExWNYer said:

 

Once a player opts out, he can't reverse his decision. At least that's what I thought I'd heard. You may see a flurry at the deadline as guys seriously ponder what is best for them and their families.

 

That’s correct, the decision is final once made.  I just would have thought any players considering the opt-out would have already discussed this with their families/agents prior to reporting to training camp for COVID testing.  But you’re right, there are probably still some guys on the fence and as Yolo noted, perhaps the paperwork being filed is another delay.

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

40 minutes ago, YoloinOhio said:

We don’t know who all reported other than the pictures we’ve seen from the Bills or the players on social Media. I heard that there are players (not necessarily Bills) that have made their decisions and notified the team but the paperwork isn’t done because there are lawyers involved, there are still issues to be worked out with the CBA, and therefore it hasn’t been filed yet 


I mentioned in another thread but I wouldn’t be surprised to see Hauschka opt out. His wife just had a baby and Bills drafted a kicker so danger of being cut. If he doesn’t want to move around to another team in a pandemic he might take the year off. 


 

As the CBA part drags on - the timing on opt outs goes further down the road.  
 

Originally it was 8/1, but they are talking about 7 days after the agreement and players are sent the final letter - so currently it is the 4th, but that could extend until after the agreement and some players are waiting to see the final agreement because if they can get designated a high risk versus a normal opt out - that additional year of service might be critical.

 

My guess is we will still see a flurry over the next couple of days, but then there will still be a trickle until everything is settled.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It may not be "just get it and get over it" - News like this should give athletes something serious to consider.

 

https://www.msn.com/en-us/health/medical/80-of-covid-patients-have-this-life-threatening-symptom-study-says/ar-BB17iwXc

 

Quote

Throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, we've learned that the coronavirus attacks much more than just your respiratory system. There are symptoms of the virus that affect everything from your mouth to your digestive tract. Now, a new study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) Cardiology has found that one of the more frightening lingering effects of COVID-19 is also very common. According to the JAMA Cardiology study, nearly 80 percent of COVID patients have heart damage.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, Buffalo716 said:

I totally understand the drive to be great.  I played high-level football and sports my whole life

 

I've gotten into fights on the pickup basketball court because I'm so competitive. I don't think I struggle with competitors striving to be great

 

But by the time they reach that level a lot of them have lost their passion for the sport. You don't have to love something to strive to be great. That's just competitive nature

 

 

I know numerous professional soccer players who really did not like playing soccer. One of them even played for England against Brazil in a World Cup Quarter Final. People would give their right arm for that.... he'd change the channel if he put the TV on and it was showing soccer.

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

52 minutes ago, eball said:

 

That’s correct, the decision is final once made.  I just would have thought any players considering the opt-out would have already discussed this with their families/agents prior to reporting to training camp for COVID testing.  But you’re right, there are probably still some guys on the fence and as Yolo noted, perhaps the paperwork being filed is another delay.

Tom Pellisero from NFL Network tweeted that there are dozens of more players who are going to opt out.  Attorneys are involved on both sides trying to clarify who qualifies for the different opt outs.  

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

41 minutes ago, Rochesterfan said:


 

As the CBA part drags on - the timing on opt outs goes further down the road.  
 

Originally it was 8/1, but they are talking about 7 days after the agreement and players are sent the final letter - so currently it is the 4th, but that could extend until after the agreement and some players are waiting to see the final agreement because if they can get designated a high risk versus a normal opt out - that additional year of service might be critical.

 

My guess is we will still see a flurry over the next couple of days, but then there will still be a trickle until everything is settled.

I think you're right.  And if someone or a few players test positive on a particular team before the deadline I think that will increase the numbers substantially.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

49 minutes ago, DCbillsfan said:

Tom Pellisero from NFL Network tweeted that there are dozens of more players who are going to opt out.  Attorneys are involved on both sides trying to clarify who qualifies for the different opt outs.  

 

Florio and Simms alluded to something similar this morning. This could get interesting (a/k/a FUGLY). 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Rochesterfan said:


 

As the CBA part drags on - the timing on opt outs goes further down the road.  
 

Originally it was 8/1, but they are talking about 7 days after the agreement and players are sent the final letter - so currently it is the 4th, but that could extend until after the agreement and some players are waiting to see the final agreement because if they can get designated a high risk versus a normal opt out - that additional year of service might be critical.

 

My guess is we will still see a flurry over the next couple of days, but then there will still be a trickle until everything is settled.


that they may need to report before the terms of opt out are finalized seems not ideal. 
 

you think in a perfect world the window would be a few days prior through a few after (can avoid showing up or can come in and see protocols in action if you want)

Edited by NoSaint
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, eball said:

 

That’s correct, the decision is final once made.  I just would have thought any players considering the opt-out would have already discussed this with their families/agents prior to reporting to training camp for COVID testing.  But you’re right, there are probably still some guys on the fence and as Yolo noted, perhaps the paperwork being filed is another delay.


I believe that the NFL and NFLPA are still hammering out how this works with the CBA. The deadline is either 5 or 7 days after that is finalized. So it is a moving target at the moment. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

55 minutes ago, NoSaint said:


that they may need to report before the terms of opt out are finalized seems not ideal. 
 

you think in a perfect world the window would be a few days prior through a few after (can avoid showing up or can come in and see protocols in action if you want)


 

Agreed, but we all know and CBA process takes longer than it should.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, Buffalo716 said:

I totally understand the drive to be great.  I played high-level football and sports my whole life

 

I've gotten into fights on the pickup basketball court because I'm so competitive. I don't think I struggle with competitors striving to be great

 

But by the time they reach that level a lot of them have lost their passion for the sport. You don't have to love something to strive to be great. That's just competitive nature

 


“I got in a fight playing pick up basketball. I understand what it’s like to be an elite athlete” 

 

-Basically you

 

My dad in his late 30’s got kicked out of a hockey league for getting in a fight, he also played varsity hockey, sign him up for team USA! 

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Was just a few weeks ago, the players were unified in a “we want to play” message to the NFL.  Now, that Opt-Out parameters are in place with a stipend that still puts these athletes in the top 1%, this is all political to preserve their contract another year; hence also the reason for no preseason games.  All about job security under the guise of protecting my family.  I call B.S.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, Mango said:


“I got in a fight playing pick up basketball. I understand what it’s like to be an elite athlete” 

 

-Basically you

 

My dad in his late 30’s got kicked out of a hockey league for getting in a fight, he also played varsity hockey, sign him up for team USA! 

 

Buf716 is not having the greatest run on this board recently...

  • Like (+1) 2
  • Haha (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Lieutenant Aldo Raine said:

Was just a few weeks ago, the players were unified in a “we want to play” message to the NFL.  Now, that Opt-Out parameters are in place with a stipend that still puts these athletes in the top 1%, this is all political to preserve their contract another year; hence also the reason for no preseason games.  All about job security under the guise of protecting my family.  I call B.S.

 

I hate to be so cynical, but if a player has no underlying health issues and/or immediate family with underlying health issues, it certainly seems as though the opt-out is all about making sure you get paid regardless of how it effects your team.  Star has every right to exercise this option, but I would be shocked if he was locking himself inside his house as to avoid catching COVID.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, SCBills said:

 

I hate to be so cynical, but if a player has no underlying health issues and/or immediate family with underlying health issues, it certainly seems as though the opt-out is all about making sure you get paid regardless of how it effects your team.  Star has every right to exercise this option, but I would be shocked if he was locking himself inside his house as to avoid catching COVID.  

 

The first story/picture of an opt-out player hanging out on a crowded beach or playing basketball with friends is going to be fun.

  • Like (+1) 1
  • Haha (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

29 minutes ago, SCBills said:

 

I hate to be so cynical, but if a player has no underlying health issues and/or immediate family with underlying health issues, it certainly seems as though the opt-out is all about making sure you get paid regardless of how it effects your team.  Star has every right to exercise this option, but I would be shocked if he was locking himself inside his house as to avoid catching COVID.  

I am still confused on the details..but if a player is putting at risk big money on whether the season will or will not occur,  and he gets screwed if the season gets cancelled after a game or two...i would absolutely opt out if i was that player.

 

Again, i don't fully understand these rules, so i could just be blowing smoke too

Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 minutes ago, plenzmd1 said:

I am still confused on the details..but if a player is putting at risk big money on whether the season will or will not occur,  and he gets screwed if the season gets cancelled after a game or two...i would absolutely opt out if i was that player.

 

Again, i don't fully understand these rules, so i could just be blowing smoke too

My understanding is guaranteed money is lost if the season is canceled.  Star was scheduled to make $4.5 M guaranteed money this season.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 minutes ago, DCbillsfan said:

My understanding is guaranteed money is lost if the season is canceled.  Star was scheduled to make $4.5 M guaranteed money this season.  

yea, i mean that a lot of cash to bet on a season be played

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Mango said:


“I got in a fight playing pick up basketball. I understand what it’s like to be an elite athlete” 

 

-Basically you

 

My dad in his late 30’s got kicked out of a hockey league for getting in a fight, he also played varsity hockey, sign him up for team USA! 


I guess it’s still better than, I watch a lot of espn, therefore I understand what it’s like to be an elite athlete. ?‍♂️ 

 

pro games also being so scripted and rehearsed, it takes the fun of freelance streetball out of it. I think it was farve that made a comment about trying to find ways to make the game fun. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

33 minutes ago, plenzmd1 said:

I am still confused on the details..but if a player is putting at risk big money on whether the season will or will not occur,  and he gets screwed if the season gets cancelled after a game or two...i would absolutely opt out if i was that player.

 

Again, i don't fully understand these rules, so i could just be blowing smoke too

 

Oh, I get it... He's just not a guy i'd want to ride with, especially when (so far) nobody else on our team has opted out....but I completely understand Star's point a view.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, Over 29 years of fanhood said:


I guess it’s still better than, I watch a lot of espn, therefore I understand what it’s like to be an elite athlete. ?‍♂️ 

 

pro games also being so scripted and rehearsed, it takes the fun of freelance streetball out of it. I think it was farve that made a comment about trying to find ways to make the game fun. 


Unsure if you’re first sentence is about me, but if you read my post above, I commented on what the shift is among elite/pro athletes. Specifically from my time living at the Olympic Training Center. 
 

To your second point. I agree, a coach needs to be able to integrate fun into the program. Loosen the reigns a bit and get back to the basics. Short term you may not see the effects on the athlete or team, but long term it does a whole lot.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, Buffalo716 said:

I totally understand the drive to be great.  I played high-level football and sports my whole life

 

I've gotten into fights on the pickup basketball court because I'm so competitive. I don't think I struggle with competitors striving to be great

 

But by the time they reach that level a lot of them have lost their passion for the sport. You don't have to love something to strive to be great. That's just competitive nature

 

We are the same side this time. I believe your points have merit. Take the big bucks out of the game and a lot of zeal and enthusiasm from many players would be gone. As you have pointed out and everyone typically agrees; it is a brutal game, especially at the highest level. Players walk away now, take the fat stacks away and many more will follow. I would say that many play because they have to. The skill set for football doesn’t transfer to many things and certainly none that pay as well. 

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, Mango said:


Unsure if you’re first sentence is about me, but if you read my post above, I commented on what the shift is among elite/pro athletes. Specifically from my time living at the Olympic Training Center. 
 

To your second point. I agree, a coach needs to be able to integrate fun into the program. Loosen the reigns a bit and get back to the basics. Short term you may not see the effects on the athlete or team, but long term it does a whole lot.


nope not at anyone was just first thought upon reading the other comment.

 

in general I do think like all occupations, some truly love what they do, some do just it for the money, some lust for power or greatness.  Sports is no different. 

  • Like (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, eball said:

 

That’s correct, the decision is final once made.  I just would have thought any players considering the opt-out would have already discussed this with their families/agents prior to reporting to training camp for COVID testing.  But you’re right, there are probably still some guys on the fence and as Yolo noted, perhaps the paperwork being filed is another delay.

 

Just because NFLPA agreed does not mean they will not take NFL to court and try to get exceptions, changes. etc.  What they cannot get at bargaining table they try to get in court.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Lieutenant Aldo Raine said:

Was just a few weeks ago, the players were unified in a “we want to play” message to the NFL.  Now, that Opt-Out parameters are in place with a stipend that still puts these athletes in the top 1%, this is all political to preserve their contract another year; hence also the reason for no preseason games.  All about job security under the guise of protecting my family.  I call B.S.

 

Only those ruled for medical reasons get stipends for which every player's laywer is claiming applies to his client.

 

The standard one is an advance but how the NFL is going to collect from players who are opting out and were undrafted and will probably spend the money is unclear.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hard to believe that healthy young men are afraid of this virus, opting out means 1 of 4 things to me, 1) you don’t love the game 2) you are absolutely paranoid by everything the media says 3) you knew you were getting cut so you took the money 4) Because I know there was one case, your life mission is to help others and football doesn’t fit right now.

  • Like (+1) 1
  • Sad 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...