NoSaint

I think sometimes folks forget some WR1 get a lot of slot volume, like ceedee, etc…

Once you get out of the top ten or so superstars that just win at everything, it starts to turn into scheme fits creating tiers/ledges id say he is in that 30-40 ledge, where he generally starts everywhere, rarely is a clear WR1, and value could vary depending on his fit.

If we are the only team he doesn’t get a ring with I’ll be genuinely annoyed

you could say this about any term. Unless you dictate the rookie contract template, it is what it is.

to be fair, they list 26

I think it’s just a matter of is he an injury risk in a unique way, or is it just basic risk management of it being a huge drop off Josh isn’t an injury risk, in general but you protect him because of the drop in this case I don’t think the worry was hugely worthys injury risk so much as the room being depleted and only putting so much on a young guys plate

with him having 900 snaps and very limited depth remaining at WR

you manufacture touches for guys that can house it any given touch. if his snap count is going to go down on offense you get him touches elsewhere just echoing your point

I hate to say it but if everyone is eating and we aren’t trying to force feed the guy…. can you imagine Brady scheming him up? sure he wouldn’t be a big run blocker but…. Jeeeze. It seems we’ve been trying to fill the speedy gadget guy roll forever with modest luck at best. Whether McKenzie or Hines or Samuel or…. If we weren’t getting a potential WR1 boundary guy to feed- a matchup nightmare with Brady sure would’ve been fun and never expected to get 120 touches or anything so durability only a modest concern anyway. tyreek played 40% of offensive snaps his rookie year. to billlllls point, if not for all the challenges at WR worthy might’ve gotten looks elsewhere, like PR, to manufacture touches…. But he was on the field in most packages

I mean, if he’s going to miss a couple days I guess you can steal a day or two looking at an extra guy?

yet tied for the fewest championships until it changes, unfortunately, it won’t change

I debated Josh in only that the standar md has gone from very very good to one of the best in the history of the league he could regress and still be pretty darn good. see I was interested in it because after multiple years of very stunted impact is a regression just missing all 17 games? if it’s whether he’s regressed compared to 2022, sure, I’d say likely but not likely a fair situation for this debate

How is Green Bay? How is Seattle? The lions? I saw a bunch of articles this offseason without looking for them. It’s common place in high demand markets that aren’t begging to fill seats. I don’t think teams like the optics of a huge number of visiting fans, fans don’t like waitlists while resellers profit… I’d venture the guess that the long term attend every game seat is also much more pleasant to police on game day than is a rotating cast.

I don’t know what the threshold will be but would not be shocked if selling 6 out of 8 regular season games starts discussions

I’m not sure workplace conduct punishment for union employees doing dumb stuff off the clock vs jeopardizing on the clock outcomes is how I judge that

to be fair: which jeopardizes the on the field product more? Rice also faces criminal and civil penalties for his involvement in something worse for society at large

they might not like you much

I just looked out of curiosity… and yes, Jerry jones attorney and also a Texas state senator of 30+ years. A recent lengthy extension to move the trial outside the legislative session of January through June.

doesnt he have Jerry jones attorney or some such? Its been so long that im getting blurry on details

I’ll say as a public statement 18 months out, that actually gives me a bit of pause on whether it’ll be ready.

yea- he wasn’t locked on revis island but to say he made revis look like trash is definitely mythology surpassing reality

meh- I’ve gone back and forth and sometimes your best shot doesn’t come on 4th down so you have to take the coin flip for a 30 yard gain on second down if the opportunity arises because you are unlikely to get a better chunk play later and winning one coin flip is easier than winning 3 coin flips. there were plenty of days I hated in the moment but ultimately like more than seeing a 7 play turnover on downs or failed Hail Mary I think a good example of defining terms being important. below average starter and below average nfl player at his position are very different I think universally the board would call him a below average starter (ie around 20th) not below average on a roster (say 40th)

honestly I would be curious if the numbers support my theory that he was fitz tragic because he could play within his limitations most of the day to keep it close but didn’t have the arm talent when it was crunch time and everyone was giving 110% and you couldn’t live for another down because you are down 5 with 38 seconds left…. Seemed he was smart enough to know he had to throw it still and see what happened at that point. Even if his arm made it less likely to connect than Josh - still better than running out of bounds short of the sticks,

it’s ultimately a case of “this guy has flags for being self centered and clueless” this isn’t proof he will fail but it’s surely another data point in the wrong column if you are invested in his success. to do it twice this month is likewise a data point in the does not learn from mistakes column

Call me crazy but I still think that Coleman was drafted to let Shakir walk and now our pass catching resource allocations are all kinds of messed up with a million slot guys, the leagues richest backup tight end and prayers Elijah Moore can get behind a corner occasionally if you gave beane truth serum I think the hope was Keon, Samuel and a higher end WR addition - see something like Devante, DK but Keon hasn’t shown to be a real starter, and Samuel struggled and now that high end salary has to split between Palmer and Shakir to fill multiple roles.