Ethan in Cleveland

No he doesn't. He can't get open against NFL DBs. The best play he made in the game was getting tackled at the 9 yard line. If he didn't fall down he would have ran into the endzone leaving Baltimore time for a comeback. He then disappeared for the next 18 games. His only hope to make the final 53 is that Brady values a blocking WR as much as McD did. That's the only role he has on this team, a WR#4 blocking WR. If Bell can block at all, then Coleman is not making the final 53. Diggs or Cooks would be far better additions to the WR group. He is spent cost at this point. Time for Beane to admit his mistake and move on.

Christie kicked in the SuperBowl

Apparently you get to play special teams for the Bills Get rid of Coleman and sign Cooks and let this be your 6th WR to play teams.

Half this board didn't want to sign him. You know who you are.

QB Josh Allen RB LeSean McCoy - so close to going with Cribbs FB Cookie Gilchrist - I love Cookie more than I hate FBs so he stays WR Stephon Diggs WR Eric Moulds WR#3 Lee Evans LT Jason Peters OG Reuben Brown C Eric Wood OG Reggie McKenzie RT Spencer Brown TE Dawson Knox - the worst position in franchise history so I'm going with one of my favorite players DE Super Mario DT Ted Washington DT Pat Williams DE Aaron Schobel OLB Bryce Paup MLB Sam Cowart - never like London Fletcher but almost went with Spielman OLB Takeo Spikes CB Nate Clements CB Terrence McGee Nickel Taron Johnson S - Micah Hyde S - Jordan Poyer PK Gary Anderson - he was drafted by the Bills so I'm picking him P Paul Maguire - We are never punting with this team so he can entertain guys on the sideline

Has great instincts but is too small to play the position. Terrible extension. It's true he made more plays than Edmunds, but so did your average LB. Shaq made more plays than Edmunds. He is emblematic of the failure of the McD defense. I'm worried he is even more exposed without two DT's in front of him. Even before he got hurt last year he was not playing well. Even McD pointed that out in his PCs. That said, he is a very good pass rusher and I think he could make plays as an inside pass rusher with late blitzes. He is decent in zone coverage and he is still the best option for MLB in the nickel defense. Hope he stays healthy but not counting on it.

I'd take Shaq, Tre, or Von back on a vet minimum salary. All three would make the final 53. Shaq could still start. Von could get decent number of rotational snaps. And Tre would be a massive upgrade over anyone on the team now that will be CB#4.

My top 5 Allen Garrett Stafford Jefferson Chase

We all saw them forcing the ball to Coleman early in the season and it was not working. This is why the OTA's and training camp doesn't matter. Hopefully Brady has some balls and forces Beane to trade him. I'd much rather see a speed guy like Hardman or Cooks as the 5th WR and Bell as WR#4. And no I don't care that none of these guys can play special teams. Either keep a 6th WR for teams or use back-up DBs for teams.

Great stuff! Love me some Dawson Knox. He had less drops this year but he had a brutal drop in the end-zone against the Browns.

12th man has not been used in years I haven't read the list, but hope they don't put Bills Mafia up there. Never liked it. But it is at least ours alone. If you want a non-player phrase on the wall put up "Fandamonium"

Thurman Thomas was always and still is now my favorite. Allen may overtake him in time. I started watching in 1980 so I can respect the guys before that but since I was not a fan at the time none of them are in my favorite list. Others that are in my top 10ish favorites Joe Cribbs Jerry Butler LeSean McCoy Kent Hull Antoine Winfield Dawson Knox Aaron Schobel Fred Jackson Jason Peters Stephon Diggs Sam Cowart

You really think Kubiak would want to coach Mendoza over Allen?

Don't feel any different. I would have waited for Kubiak. I also would have fired Beane and cleaned house. I don't trust anything that comes from OTAs or training camp. Ask this question on October 19th. We will all have a better idea then. The first six games are brutal with a combination of tough opponents and west coast travel. If he goes 4-2 to start that would be a great way to begin the year.

Good decision. His place is in the record books and the Hall of Fame. No need to put his name up in the new stadium.