Jump to content

Looking for a reason why Beane should make a big trade before the deadline? Look no further than John Dorsey.


Recommended Posts

"John Dorsey was fired as GM of the Chiefs in June 2017, six months after the team finished a 12-4 season and less than two months after he drafted Patrick Mahomes."

Found this interesting factoid in an ESPN article about why current NFL GMs are trading way more than their counterparts of just 5 years ago did. Crazy to think that a guy could get canned after a season like that and then making a trade up and hitting on a true franchise QB.

 

Just goes to show that it's a win-in-the-playoffs league and swinging for the fences by moving draft capital isn't the awful idea it was once considered to be.

 

Here's the full article : https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/27919597/why-nfl-trades-increased-four-reasons-why-deadline-no-longer-dud

 

 

  • Like (+1) 3
  • Thank you (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

IMO, it's really just the teams with a franchise/reliable starter QB that can afford to trade away picks IAW the article's main points.  Otherwise, picks are still coveted as a team stockpiles them to draft at the top.

Edited by In Summary
missed a word
  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

33 minutes ago, ChevyVanMiller said:

"John Dorsey was fired as GM of the Chiefs in June 2017, six months after the team finished a 12-4 season and less than two months after he drafted Patrick Mahomes."

Found this interesting factoid in an ESPN article about why current NFL GMs are trading way more than their counterparts of just 5 years ago did. Crazy to think that a guy could get canned after a season like that and then making a trade up and hitting on a true franchise QB.

 

Just goes to show that it's a win-in-the-playoffs league and swinging for the fences by moving draft capital isn't the awful idea it was once considered to be.

 

Here's the full article : https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/27919597/why-nfl-trades-increased-four-reasons-why-deadline-no-longer-dud

 

 

Well at that time, I don't think anyone really knew what the Chiefs had in Mahommes....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Honestly, do you think a 12-4 season that doesn't end up in the Super Bowl is going to get Beane fired?

 

Beane is running this franchise not to be a one and done flash.  He wants to create a long-term, winning team.  He does not expect to win it all this year although obviously he would take it if it happened.  He's thinking about 3 and 4 years from now, when next spring's draft picks are the core of the 2023 team.  This is the process they're always talking about.

Draft picks are important from a cap management standpoint.  Teams use draft picks as relatively cheap labor for a few years.  The players who prove themselves get retained, and those who are marginal performers are replaced with the next batch.  Even the players who get cut get to come on board and make a lot more than most people make for a few years, so it's not like these are retail store managers who get burned and turned.

  • Like (+1) 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you have a very good QB and a strong coaching staff then you have the luxury of trading away picks.  If you are still building those picks are huge.   I think the Bills are still one year away from shedding first/second rounders to maintain playoff expectations.  I don’t see a significant trade this year. 

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, ChevyVanMiller said:

"John Dorsey was fired as GM of the Chiefs in June 2017, six months after the team finished a 12-4 season and less than two months after he drafted Patrick Mahomes."

Found this interesting factoid in an ESPN article about why current NFL GMs are trading way more than their counterparts of just 5 years ago did. Crazy to think that a guy could get canned after a season like that and then making a trade up and hitting on a true franchise QB.

 

Just goes to show that it's a win-in-the-playoffs league and swinging for the fences by moving draft capital isn't the awful idea it was once considered to be.

 

Here's the full article : https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/27919597/why-nfl-trades-increased-four-reasons-why-deadline-no-longer-dud

 

 

 

The season Record is not always the reason GMs are fired. However Beane has been on his role 2.5 years. 

 

In that time hes:

 

- completely resolved the cap.  

- Drafted a high potential QB for the offense and the defense. 

- solidified the back up QBs position  

- put/kept together a top defense with young talent 

- rebuilt an offensive line from trash to treasure

- completely overhauled a WR corp, RB room and tight end room 

 

Is the winningest Bills gm since John Butler (that’s 20 years ago folks) 

 

Anyone thinking he’s going anywhere anytime soon for job performance is delusional 

Edited by Over 29 years of fanhood
  • Like (+1) 7
  • Thank you (+1) 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, ChevyVanMiller said:

"John Dorsey was fired as GM of the Chiefs in June 2017, six months after the team finished a 12-4 season and less than two months after he drafted Patrick Mahomes."

Found this interesting factoid in an ESPN article about why current NFL GMs are trading way more than their counterparts of just 5 years ago did. Crazy to think that a guy could get canned after a season like that and then making a trade up and hitting on a true franchise QB.

 

Just goes to show that it's a win-in-the-playoffs league and swinging for the fences by moving draft capital isn't the awful idea it was once considered to be.

 

Here's the full article : https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/27919597/why-nfl-trades-increased-four-reasons-why-deadline-no-longer-dud

 

 

 

I don't think that's the full story on Dorsey " fired as GM of the Chiefs in June 2017, six months after the team finished a 12-4 season and less than two months after he drafted Patrick Mahomes".  The Chiefs had salary cap issues.  Bad salary cap issues.  There were conflicts where allegedly Reid had been promised control over personnel matters but Dorsey had been promised the same personnel control as other GMs.  Basically I think it was more a "personality conflict" thing with cap issues tossed in.

  • Like (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Over 29 years of fanhood said:

 

The season Record is not always the reason GMs are fired. 

 

Beane has been on his role 2.5 years. 

 

In that time hes

 

- completely resolved the cap.  

- Drafted a high potential QB for the offense and the defense. 

- solidified the back up QBs position  

- put/kept together a top defense with young talent 

- rebuilt an offensive line from trash to treasure

- completely overhauled a WR corp, RB room and tight end room 

 

Is the winningest Bills gm since John Butler (that’s 20 years ago folks) 

 

Anyone thinking he’s going anywhere anytime soon for job performance is delusional 

He's not going anwhere....

But since you brought it up,

1. He created the cap mess with his trades/cuts

2. So far so good with Allen but still has a long way to prove his is a franchise QB

3. Oline is average but all in all the players he signed have done well. He cant be blamed for Incognito and Wood. But he continued his practice of overpaying for guys(see Star and Murphy) Morse is highest paid center in the league and he barely makes the top 10 in performance.  Feliciano is far better than I thought. Nsekhe is below average. Long is a waste of money. 

4. WR group is a mess but he had a significant hand in making. He traded away Watkins and traded for KB( a move I thought was good at the time). He made great signing in Brown. Beasley so far is ok. 

 

Don't agree with not picking up 5th year option on Lawson.  

 

Wallace is looking like a great find. Foster not so much anymore. Duke is TBD.

 

I am admittedly biased to win now mode. They will never have a better schedule, they are relatively healthy, and they have a chance for a deep playoff run in a weak AFC. I don't care about draft picks next year, I want a proven pass rusher and a player that can stretch the defense. 

  • Thank you (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

37 minutes ago, Utah John said:

Honestly, do you think a 12-4 season that doesn't end up in the Super Bowl is going to get Beane fired?

 

Beane is running this franchise not to be a one and done flash.  He wants to create a long-term, winning team.  He does not expect to win it all this year although obviously he would take it if it happened.  He's thinking about 3 and 4 years from now, when next spring's draft picks are the core of the 2023 team.  This is the process they're always talking about.

Draft picks are important from a cap management standpoint.  Teams use draft picks as relatively cheap labor for a few years.  The players who prove themselves get retained, and those who are marginal performers are replaced with the next batch.  Even the players who get cut get to come on board and make a lot more than most people make for a few years, so it's not like these are retail store managers who get burned and turned.

From a cap management standpoint, do you think we need $40M in space every year? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 minutes ago, whatdrought said:

I mean, I don’t see how a couple examples of guys losing internal power struggles and or being scape-goated means that GM’s should be more bold with trading... 

 

Correct sir...  that’s exactly what it doesn’t mean. 

 

In my view, What it does mean is the walls of secrecy between organizations have eroded a bit with the media probing and news cycle.... GMs collaborate more than they used to, because there are win-win deals out there.  It seems Team’s now are more introspective than ever about whether they are ready to win now or building to win later and are able to orchestrate exchanges of resources accordingly.  

 

I think it’s more to do with a youth movement in the gm ranks and a wave of pragmatism and analytical thinking permeating sports management  

 

And by youth I mean 40 years olds replacing 70 year olds.... which just brought along new modes of operation 

Edited by Over 29 years of fanhood
  • Like (+1) 2
  • Thank you (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, Over 29 years of fanhood said:

 

The season Record is not always the reason GMs are fired. However Beane has been on his role 2.5 years. 

 

In that time hes:

 

- completely resolved the cap.  

- Drafted a high potential QB for the offense and the defense. 

- solidified the back up QBs position  

- put/kept together a top defense with young talent 

- rebuilt an offensive line from trash to treasure

- completely overhauled a WR corp, RB room and tight end room 

 

Is the winningest Bills gm since John Butler (that’s 20 years ago folks) 

 

Anyone thinking he’s going anywhere anytime soon for job performance is delusional 

 

...so then we should expect "mea culpas" from the "...Fire McBeane....fire McDermott Gang" soon, right?......SMH.....organizationally, we are in equal shape if not better than to Polian era.......of course 17 years of "F Troop" making a mockery of OBD created some itchy trigger fingers and irrational exuberance for instantaneous success..... was NEVER gonna happen....making the playoffs, acknowledging a gritty effort year aided by Dalton engineered "Immaculate Reception" PREMATURELY raised the expectation bar for 2018 when the Bflo stars perfectly aligned.......logically it was a cleanup year with cap constraints, need to house clean the dead wood and make some stop gap signings to hopefully remain competitive....and also a year with a stellar draft......rinse and repeat stellar draft in 2019....if you don't think the McBeane/McDermott tandem has us on the most solid footing in years now and with a long term plan, I don't know what the hell to tell you IMO....

  • Like (+1) 3
  • Awesome! (+1) 1
  • Thank you (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

41 minutes ago, Utah John said:

Honestly, do you think a 12-4 season that doesn't end up in the Super Bowl is going to get Beane fired?

 

Beane is running this franchise not to be a one and done flash.  He wants to create a long-term, winning team.  He does not expect to win it all this year although obviously he would take it if it happened.  He's thinking about 3 and 4 years from now, when next spring's draft picks are the core of the 2023 team.  This is the process they're always talking about.

Draft picks are important from a cap management standpoint.  Teams use draft picks as relatively cheap labor for a few years.  The players who prove themselves get retained, and those who are marginal performers are replaced with the next batch.  Even the players who get cut get to come on board and make a lot more than most people make for a few years, so it's not like these are retail store managers who get burned and turned.

To put it succinctly, what happened to the Chiefs is not generalizable to other teams and is actually an outlier example.

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, CaptnCoke11 said:

They’ll most definitely need a lot of it if they want to re-sign a lot of these guys

No they don't. They already extended Hughes and Hauschka.  Poyer and Hyde are under contract. 

They have basically said they arent bringing Shaq back with how he is being used. Nsekhe and Feliciano signed two year deals.

That leaves Spain and nobody else. 

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, OldTimeAFLGuy said:

 

...so then we should expect "mea culpas" from the "...Fire McBeane....fire McDermott Gang" soon, right?......SMH.....organizationally, we are in equal shape if not better than to Polian era.......of course 17 years of "F Troop" making a mockery of OBD created some itchy trigger fingers and irrational exuberance for instantaneous success..... was NEVER gonna happen....making the playoffs, acknowledging a gritty effort year aided by Dalton engineered "Immaculate Reception" PREMATURELY raised the expectation bar for 2018 when the Bflo stars perfectly aligned.......logically it was a cleanup year with cap constraints, need to house clean the dead wood and make some stop gap signings to hopefully remain competitive....and also a year with a stellar draft......rinse and repeat stellar draft in 2019....if you don't think the McBeane/McDermott tandem has us on the most solid footing in years now and with a long term plan, I don't know what the hell to tell you IMO....

The fire McBeane crowd will show again, wait for a loss, they will be acreaming that we should have signed Antonio Brown or Beckham, won the Super Bowl this year then drop into mediocrity like we did for 15 years; it's coming!

2 hours ago, OldTimeAFLGuy said:

 

...so then we should expect "mea culpas" from the "...Fire McBeane....fire McDermott Gang" soon, right?......SMH.....organizationally, we are in equal shape if not better than to Polian era.......of course 17 years of "F Troop" making a mockery of OBD created some itchy trigger fingers and irrational exuberance for instantaneous success..... was NEVER gonna happen....making the playoffs, acknowledging a gritty effort year aided by Dalton engineered "Immaculate Reception" PREMATURELY raised the expectation bar for 2018 when the Bflo stars perfectly aligned.......logically it was a cleanup year with cap constraints, need to house clean the dead wood and make some stop gap signings to hopefully remain competitive....and also a year with a stellar draft......rinse and repeat stellar draft in 2019....if you don't think the McBeane/McDermott tandem has us on the most solid footing in years now and with a long term plan, I don't know what the hell to tell you IMO....

Man they want it now!

2 hours ago, BringBackOrton said:

From a cap management standpoint, do you think we need $40M in space every year? 

Why not - gives you freedom to make the "RIGHT" move!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, CaptnCoke11 said:

Hold on to our picks and sign our own guys with contracts coming up.  

 

I like the way we draft, and I value our picks immensely. Having said that, if our FO feels like there’s a deal worth making....I’ll trust them and hope for the best. What other choice do I have? 

  • Like (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 minutes ago, vorpma said:

The fire McBeane crowd will show again, wait for a loss, they will be acreaming that we should have signed Antonio Brown or Beckham, won the Super Bowl this year then drop into mediocrity like we did for 15 years; it's coming!

Man they want it now!

Why not - gives you freedom to make the "RIGHT" move!

No one can seem to define the “right move” except for Beane not doing anything.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Ethan in Portland said:

No they don't. They already extended Hughes and Hauschka.  Poyer and Hyde are under contract. 

They have basically said they arent bringing Shaq back with how he is being used. Nsekhe and Feliciano signed two year deals.

That leaves Spain and nobody else. 

I for one think Poyer is not going to be resigned. With the flashes that J. Johnson showed during preseason he will be groomed to take Poyers spot.

Im not saying Poyer isnt good but i dont see him as a game changer. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, BringBackOrton said:

No one can seem to define the “right move” except for Beane not doing anything.

 

It’s been tough for me, for some reason the other GM’s are not taking my calls!  Go figure? 

  • Haha (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, ChattanoogaBills said:

I for one think Poyer is not going to be resigned. With the flashes that J. Johnson showed during preseason he will be groomed to take Poyers spot.

Im not saying Poyer isnt good but i dont see him as a game changer. 

 

I'm not so sure about this.  I think Poyer will be retained; him and Micah Hyde are among the best safety tandem in the league, and are the quarterbacks of the defense.  That is not something that McD would want to break up.  If anything, I think a CB is expendable.

  • Like (+1) 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Happy Gilmore said:

 

I'm not so sure about this.  I think Poyer will be retained; him and Micah Hyde are among the best safety tandem in the league, and are the quarterbacks of the defense.  That is not something that McD would want to break up.  If anything, I think a CB is expendable.

You might be right. Im just going on a hunch from seeing J. Johnson make plays in his limited preseason debut. That along with the fact you cant pay everyone top dollar for their production.

And that McBeane is following New England's cap strategy having the two top paid safetys in football doesnt seem very economical. And Hyde is the better player and more important of the two.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Ethan in Portland said:

He's not going anwhere....

But since you brought it up,

1. He created the cap mess with his trades/cuts

2. So far so good with Allen but still has a long way to prove his is a franchise QB

3. Oline is average but all in all the players he signed have done well. He cant be blamed for Incognito and Wood. But he continued his practice of overpaying for guys(see Star and Murphy) Morse is highest paid center in the league and he barely makes the top 10 in performance.  Feliciano is far better than I thought. Nsekhe is below average. Long is a waste of money. 

4. WR group is a mess but he had a significant hand in making. He traded away Watkins and traded for KB( a move I thought was good at the time). He made great signing in Brown. Beasley so far is ok. 

 

Don't agree with not picking up 5th year option on Lawson.  

 

Wallace is looking like a great find. Foster not so much anymore. Duke is TBD.

 

I am admittedly biased to win now mode. They will never have a better schedule, they are relatively healthy, and they have a chance for a deep playoff run in a weak AFC. I don't care about draft picks next year, I want a proven pass rusher and a player that can stretch the defense. 

 

No he didn't create cap issues. He repaired them.

  • Awesome! (+1) 1
  • Thank you (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Utah John said:

Honestly, do you think a 12-4 season that doesn't end up in the Super Bowl is going to get Beane fired?

 

Beane is running this franchise not to be a one and done flash.  He wants to create a long-term, winning team.  He does not expect to win it all this year although obviously he would take it if it happened.  He's thinking about 3 and 4 years from now, when next spring's draft picks are the core of the 2023 team.  This is the process they're always talking about.

Draft picks are important from a cap management standpoint.  Teams use draft picks as relatively cheap labor for a few years.  The players who prove themselves get retained, and those who are marginal performers are replaced with the next batch.  Even the players who get cut get to come on board and make a lot more than most people make for a few years, so it's not like these are retail store managers who get burned and turned.

However, that five year process fails, if you don't get a Franchise QB.   Everything pivots around having a successful Franchise QB

Link to comment
Share on other sites

30 minutes ago, Joe in Winslow said:

 

No he didn't create cap issues. He repaired them.

 

He created them first. We were not in cap hell. We had a lot of our money spent, sure, but we were far from in hell and that money was spent on good players. But they were not the players McDermott and Beane wanted. I don't criticise them for doing the tear down before they started to rebuild. It was my preferred method too but had they simply tried to build on the roster that was here there was enough cap flexibility to do that. They created the dead money and by Beane's own admission it was a "rip off the band aid" approach. 

 

We had this conversation ad nauseam in the summer but the tear down was a choice. It wasn't obligatory. I happen to think it was the right choice and that results in the long run will show that. 

 

1 hour ago, Happy Gilmore said:

 

I'm not so sure about this.  I think Poyer will be retained; him and Micah Hyde are among the best safety tandem in the league, and are the quarterbacks of the defense.  That is not something that McD would want to break up.  If anything, I think a CB is expendable.

 

They would be well advised to keep that duo together. It because they have those two they are able to change coverages so late before the snap. Their communication (including non verbal) with one another on the field is a sight to behold. Their level of understanding borders on telepathic.  Hyde is the more complete of the two but I have no doubt they both make each other better. 

  • Like (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Ethan in Portland said:

He's not going anwhere....

But since you brought it up,

1. He created the cap mess with his trades/cuts

Physically yes. But those trades/cuts were necessary as those players were over-hyped and over paid.   None of them have gone on to be all-pro's for any teams.

 

4 hours ago, Ethan in Portland said:

2. So far so good with Allen but still has a long way to prove his is a franchise QB

Agreed.  Time will tell

 

4 hours ago, Ethan in Portland said:

3. Oline is average but all in all the players he signed have done well. He cant be blamed for Incognito and Wood. But he continued his practice of overpaying for guys(see Star and Murphy) Morse is highest paid center in the league and he barely makes the top 10 in performance.  Feliciano is far better than I thought. Nsekhe is below average. Long is a waste of money. 

Agreed.  Beane has tried hard this year on the OL after doing nothing last year. However, the results have been mixed.  We are yet to see a solid OL that is winning CONSISTENTLY in the trenches.  That is the hallmark of great teams.    Our OL play has been underwhelming for the money poured in it.

 

4 hours ago, Ethan in Portland said:

4. WR group is a mess but he had a significant hand in making. He traded away Watkins and traded for KB( a move I thought was good at the time). He made great signing in Brown. Beasley so far is ok. 

 

Agreed. They also traded for that Cleveland WR  (forget his name) and still we are lagging behind in this spot.  Jones did not work out as a high draft pick that also required additional draft capital for a trade up. 

 

4 hours ago, Ethan in Portland said:

 

Don't agree with not picking up 5th year option on Lawson.  

This is a tricky one.  You can't pay 12M to a guy who has under performed.  You are setting wrong expectations especially when your stars like Hyde and Poyer are making peanuts.

 

4 hours ago, Ethan in Portland said:

 

Wallace is looking like a great find. Foster not so much anymore. Duke is TBD.

 

I am admittedly biased to win now mode. They will never have a better schedule, they are relatively healthy, and they have a chance for a deep playoff run in a weak AFC. I don't care about draft picks next year, I want a proven pass rusher and a player that can stretch the defense. 

 

The important point is that Beane is TRYING.  If you don't even try, then how do you expect to win.   Has he been successful; at this point I would say less than stellar...but if Allen turns out to be a Franchise QB, then all wiill be forgotten.    What Beane has done is take the formula of building the team with good draft picks that can last their 4-5 rookie contract.  After all a GM and HC get only around 4 years to turn a team around.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, Over 29 years of fanhood said:

 

The season Record is not always the reason GMs are fired. However Beane has been on his role 2.5 years. 

 

In that time hes:

 

- completely resolved the cap.  

- Drafted a high potential QB for the offense and the defense. 

- solidified the back up QBs position  

- put/kept together a top defense with young talent 

- rebuilt an offensive line from trash to treasure

- completely overhauled a WR corp, RB room and tight end room 

 

Is the winningest Bills gm since John Butler (that’s 20 years ago folks) 

 

Anyone thinking he’s going anywhere anytime soon for job performance is delusional 

 

This.

 

I expect Beane to see full term and re-upped prior to term expiring.

 

He’s a keeper. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, Ethan in Portland said:

He's not going anwhere....

But since you brought it up,

1. He created the cap mess with his trades/cuts

2. So far so good with Allen but still has a long way to prove his is a franchise QB

3. Oline is average but all in all the players he signed have done well. He cant be blamed for Incognito and Wood. But he continued his practice of overpaying for guys(see Star and Murphy) Morse is highest paid center in the league and he barely makes the top 10 in performance.  Feliciano is far better than I thought. Nsekhe is below average. Long is a waste of money. 

4. WR group is a mess but he had a significant hand in making. He traded away Watkins and traded for KB( a move I thought was good at the time). He made great signing in Brown. Beasley so far is ok. 

 

Don't agree with not picking up 5th year option on Lawson.  

 

Wallace is looking like a great find. Foster not so much anymore. Duke is TBD.

 

I am admittedly biased to win now mode. They will never have a better schedule, they are relatively healthy, and they have a chance for a deep playoff run in a weak AFC. I don't care about draft picks next year, I want a proven pass rusher and a player that can stretch the defense. 

You’re an example of a “live in the moment “ kind of person. I’m thankful you aren’t our Gm.

 Bean gets it.... great leaders are ones that plan for longevity and now for the immediate show. Those that live for the moment are people that flame out.

  • Thank you (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, fishgrappler said:

You’re an example of a “live in the moment “ kind of person. I’m thankful you aren’t our Gm.

 Bean gets it.... great leaders are ones that plan for longevity and now for the immediate show. Those that live for the moment are people that flame out.

We’ve seen all we need to of that. From gm to hc hires. Good riddance 

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...