Whatever Happened To Mike Quick?

[Buffalo86]

18 minutes ago, Misterbluesky said:

I heard they had a actual jail in the basement...or maybe that was the old Giant stadium? But yes..Veterans had the worst field in those days and they had massive seams on the turf to cover up where the base areas were (Phillies).

 

Not only did the Vet have a jail, it also had a courtroom.  Unruly drunks were given due process before they even had a chance to sober up.

Edited April 13, 2019 by Buffalo86

[gobills1212]

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mike_Quick

[chris heff]

This topic is really odd, upon reading the title I assumed there must be another Mike Quick. Surely this couldn’t be about a somewhat obscure Eagles WR, but I was wrong.

Edited April 13, 2019 by chris heff

[cba fan]

40 minutes ago, chris heff said:

This topic is really odd, upon reading the title I assumed there must be another Mike Quick. Surly this couldn’t be about a somewhat obscure Eagles WR, but I was wrong.

 

[TigerJ]

I want my starting WRs to be named Jack B. Nimble and Mike B. Quick.

[Hapless Bills Fan]

14 hours ago, BillyWhiteShows said:

Take a break from NFL Draft talk and let’s talk 1980’s football.  Some people will have to fill me in here.  As a youth I remember reading old NFL books in our school library and seeing a WR on the Eagles called Mike Quick.  An extremely interesting name considering his position.  That’s like a QB called Johnny Strongarm.

 

I digress.... Anyway by the time I started watching football, Quick was long gone and as a kid I always wondered what happened to him.

 

Recently I came across the name when looking up 99 yard TD scoring plays.  I happened to check out Quick’s stats and he put up some huge numbers his first few years.    He had the potential to be a top WR of the 1980’s, if not a HOF talent if he kept up the pace of his first 4 seasons.   Like a Jerry Rice level talent. 

 

But he didn’t - he fell off a cliff big time.  I’m wondering what happened with Quick?  I know he retired because of knee problems in 1990 but his stats seemed to have hit the wall years before then.

 

Http://www.nfl.com/player/mikequick/2523644/careerstats

 

At a hunch: Switch from Jaws to Cunningham at QB.  Quick's best years coincided with Jawarski's best years throwing for the Eagles.  Took Cunningham a few years to improve as a passer, and when he did he had other preferred targets (Kenny Jackson then Cris Carter)

 

But it may have just been injuries/age.  He had a 9 season career, and a lot of players didn't take as good care of themselves then as they do now.  He didn't start that many games his last 3 seasons, may have been struggling with injuries.  29 year old WR considered kind of ancient in the late '80s.

[Formerly Allan in MD]

51 minutes ago, TigerJ said:

I want my starting WRs to be named Jack B. Nimble and Mike B. Quick.

What happened to Lotsa Space.

Someone please close down this thread!

[BillyWhiteShows]

10 minutes ago, Hapless Bills Fan said:

 

At a hunch: Switch from Jaws to Cunningham at QB.  Quick's best years coincided with Jawarski's best years throwing for the Eagles.  Took Cunningham a few years to improve as a passer, and when he did he had other preferred targets (Kenny Jackson then Cris Carter)

 

But it may have just been injuries/age.  He had a 9 season career, and a lot of players didn't take as good care of themselves then as they do now.  He didn't start that many games his last 3 seasons, may have been struggling with injuries.  29 year old WR considered kind of ancient in the late '80s.

 

Interesting.... I didn’t consider the QB’s coming into play.

[Hapless Bills Fan]

1 hour ago, BillyWhiteShows said:

 

Interesting.... I didn’t consider the QB’s coming into play.

 

I think that impacted him in '86 and '87, Cunningham's first years.  '86 he played a full season, and dropped off the most per-game.  Cunningham was more of an improvisational passer, especially his first years.  He rebounded in YPG the following season - as the lightbulb started to come on for Cunningham.

 

As the link posted above indicates, he broke a leg in '88 and then suffered limiting injuries the next 2 years.  All it takes....

[LSHMEAB]

10 hours ago, CaptnCoke11 said:

I must be lost.. Can someone point me in the direction of the Bills message board TBD?

We're all about the Pack attack and the early 90's Eagles now. I guess you didn't get the memo.

[SoTier]

5 hours ago, Albany,n.y. said:

The 1980 & 1981 seasons on the field don't erase all the blunders & bad decisions made by the Bills until Bill Polian took over and why they were the NFL's laughingstock until Marv showed up in 1986.  I'll start one year before the 1980s, also it should be noted that the Bills were a laughingstock in the late 1960s and mid-late 1970s.  Most of this caused by Ralph's penny-pinching (I'd like to thank author Sal Maiorana and his book Relentless in aiding in the details of the accounts of some of the events below.  I remembered most of them but used his book as a reference to add to the details) :

  

1979-The Bills become the 1st, and to this date the only, team to ever lose the top pick in the entire NFL draft to the CFL.

 

1980-Rather than pay him, the Bills trade future HOFer Joe DeLamielleure to Cleveland at age 29, still in his prime.  He played 5 seasons with the Browns after the trade.  

 

1981-Let's start with the draft, one of the worst in team history, led by #1 pick Booker Moore who missed his rookie year with Guillain-Barre Syndrome and whether it was the aftereffects of the disease or just that he was a bust, he was a bust.  The best picks were in the 9th-11th rounds. 

 

In June Jim Haslett got so frustrated with his contract negotiations that he filed unfair labor practice charges against the Bills with the National Labor Relations Board.  He later fired his agent & re-signed in August.

 

1982-The aforementioned Perry Tuttle blunder.  Overall another horrible draft with only Eugene Marve in the 3rd round providing any long term contribution.  

 

In one of the strangest moments in Bills history the Bills cut rookie kicker Gary Anderson, who went on to a long career in the NFL and kept Nick Mike-Mayer who ended up getting cut in September.  For years there have been rumors that Anderson was so upset with being drafted by the Bills that he tanked preseason so that he could get cut & picked up by the Pittsburgh Steelers.  

 

In a strike year when no games were played from late September until November 21st Joe Cribbs held out and didn't report until November 24th.  

 

1983-Chuck Knox resigns after the 1982 season, starting the eras of Kay Stephenson & subsequently Hank Bullough.

 

Jim Kelly is in the Bills offices talking contract and the USFL calls to tell him not to sign with the Bills.  A secretary takes the call & interrupts the meeting so Kelly can talk with the USFL representative-IN THE BILLS OFFICE!   He signs with the USFL and we lose 3 seasons without him before finally signing him in 1986.

 

In July Joe Cribbs has now had enough with the Bills and signs a future contract with the USFL. He plays in 1983 and leaves for the USFL after the season.  Losing him and Jim Kelly set the stage for back to back 2-14 seasons although Cribbs does return in midseason 1985. 

 

1984-The Bills are now a laughingstock on the field as well as off it, going 2-14 and having the worst record in the NFL. 

 

1985-In spite of having the worst record in 1984, the Bills retain coach Kay Stephenson.

 

The Bills deal the 1st pick in the supplemental draft to Cleveland so that Cleveland can draft Bernie Kosar.  Part of the deal includes sending talented LB Chip Banks to Buffalo.  Banks refuses to report & the trade is revised where Banks is allowed to return to Cleveland rather than ever play for the Bills.  

 

In October the Kay Stephenson era ends with his firing and the elevation of the man who will go down in history as one of the worst, if not the worst head coaches in Bills history, Hank Bullough.  

 

Later in October Joe Cribbs returns from the USFL.  Within a month he has become so disgruntled that he put strips of athletic tape on his locker with a sign that read "Buffalo Prison"  

 

1986-The Bills finally started doing things right, signed Jim Kelly and under new GM Bill Polian's urging, got Ralph to loosen his wallet and put together a decent staff off the field.  Of course, the Marv Levy era didn't start until after the Bills traded the multi-year disgruntled Joe Cribbs and had the embarrassment of the team's defensive players tanking in Tampa in order to get Hank Bullough fired.  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Excellent post.  IIRC Knox quit the Bills after the 1981 season because he wanted to acquire some better players  but Wilson nixed that. Like Lou Saban in the 1960s and then the early 1970s, Knox had control of personnel but he was still subject to interference from Wilson and Wilson's advisors, several of whom were hired only because they were Wilson's pals. 

 

An interesting book on the 1980 Bills-- the team that ended zero-for-the-seventies against Miami --  is "Talking Proud - Rediscovering the Magical Season of the 1980 Buffalo Bills" by Rich Blake.

 

[Steve O]

5 hours ago, Hapless Bills Fan said:

 

At a hunch: Switch from Jaws to Cunningham at QB.  Quick's best years coincided with Jawarski's best years throwing for the Eagles.  Took Cunningham a few years to improve as a passer, and when he did he had other preferred targets (Kenny Jackson then Cris Carter)

 

But it may have just been injuries/age.  He had a 9 season career, and a lot of players didn't take as good care of themselves then as they do now.  He didn't start that many games his last 3 seasons, may have been struggling with injuries.  29 year old WR considered kind of ancient in the late '80s.

I's say this is a pretty good hunch, backing it up with some facts. Quick's productivity did decrease with Jaworski's starts. 83-85 were big years for him, Jaws missed a total of 7 starts.  He missed 7 in 86 which was his last year as an eagle, Quick's last good season. Believe it was Keith Jackson not Kenny.

[Augie]

He got less Quick? 

[BringBackFlutie]

20 hours ago, Turk71 said:

He slowed down?

Dad joke is on fire. 

[Hapless Bills Fan]

2 hours ago, Steve O said:

I's say this is a pretty good hunch, backing it up with some facts. Quick's productivity did decrease with Jaworski's starts. 83-85 were big years for him, Jaws missed a total of 7 starts.  He missed 7 in 86 which was his last year as an eagle, Quick's last good season. Believe it was Keith Jackson not Kenny.

 

Good memory, but it's both Jacksons.  The Iggles of that era had a WR named Kenny who preceded a TE named Keith

 

[SoTier]

7 hours ago, Hapless Bills Fan said:

 

Good memory, but it's both Jacksons.  The Iggles of that era had a WR named Kenny who preceded a TE named Keith

 

 

That's as bad as the Bills having three or four Williams a few years ago.

[row_33]

7 hours ago, Hapless Bills Fan said:

 

Good memory, but it's both Jacksons.  The Iggles of that era had a WR named Kenny who preceded a TE named Keith

 

 

And Harold Carmichael 

[Ridgewaycynic2013]

9 minutes ago, SoTier said:

 

That's as bad as the Bills having three or four Williams a few years ago.

Yes, but unlike the Henry offspring, all had different parentage.

[Bill from NYC]

On ‎4‎/‎13‎/‎2019 at 7:16 AM, SoTier said:

 

The Bills have demonstrated an almost magical ability to trade up to take the wrong player, which is an indictment of how bad their scouting and personnel decision making have been over the decades -- and that seems to regardless of the regime.   Their more recent trade up faux pas include trading back into the 1st in 2004 to draft JP Losman when they could have taken Matt Schaub in the 2nd or even maybe the third and gotten a significantly better QB -- or they could have simply waited until 2005 to take Aaron Rodgers with their #18 pick.  Russ Brandon and Dick Jauron traded back into the first round in 2006 to take John McCargo who barely played because of injury issues so just about anybody else would have been a better pick.  In 2012 Buddy Nix traded up in the third round to take forgettable WR TJ Graham instead of taking QB Russell Wilson.  In 2014, the  Bills traded their 2014 and 2015 first round picks to draft WR Sammy Watkins rather than Odell Beckham Jr or Mike Evans.  Finally, Brandon and McDermott traded up in the 2nd round in 2017 to take Zay Jones rather than JuJu Smith-Schuster.  Hopefully, Beane breaks the pattern because he traded up twice in the first round of the 2018 draft to take Josh Allen and/or Tremaine Edmunds.

Awesome history lesson!!!

This of course omits the times where the Bills stood pat and made insane selections such as Whitner, McKelvin, a half crippled MaGahee, and a host of others.  Then on a rare trade down, they walked away from Mahomes and Watson.

 

This particular draft will tell us much about our future.

Edited April 14, 2019 by Bill from NYC

[Steve O]

On 4/13/2019 at 7:16 AM, SoTier said:

 

The Bills have demonstrated an almost magical ability to trade up to take the wrong player, which is an indictment of how bad their scouting and personnel decision making have been over the decades -- and that seems to regardless of the regime.   Their more recent trade up faux pas include trading back into the 1st in 2004 to draft JP Losman when they could have taken Matt Schaub in the 2nd or even maybe the third and gotten a significantly better QB -- or they could have simply waited until 2005 to take Aaron Rodgers with their #18 pick.  Russ Brandon and Dick Jauron traded back into the first round in 2006 to take John McCargo who barely played because of injury issues so just about anybody else would have been a better pick.  In 2012 Buddy Nix traded up in the third round to take forgettable WR TJ Graham instead of taking QB Russell Wilson.  In 2014, the  Bills traded their 2014 and 2015 first round picks to draft WR Sammy Watkins rather than Odell Beckham Jr or Mike Evans.  Finally, Brandon and McDermott traded up in the 2nd round in 2017 to take Zay Jones rather than JuJu Smith-Schuster.  Hopefully, Beane breaks the pattern because he traded up twice in the first round of the 2018 draft to take Josh Allen and/or Tremaine Edmunds.

re TJ Grahm - saw a special about Wilson where they showed the Seattle war room in 2012 before their third round pick. They knew they no chance to get Wilson once the Bills traded ahead of them in the third. Then they showed the announcement of the Bills pick. Big sigh of relief in the war room. Make sure you don't have anything close buy that can be thrown through your TV if you ever see the special.

Re Watkins - I wanted the Bills to stand pat and pick Aaron Donald with that pick. They also could have had Mack with the pick they traded up to

Re Jones - Ever the optimist, I'm hoping the book is still out. Moulds didn't pan out until his third year. we'll see.

Edited April 14, 2019 by Steve O

[vincec]

On 4/13/2019 at 2:01 AM, BringMetheHeadofLeonLett said:

Sorry, don't know what happened to Quick...  but if you're interested in old Eagles, Quick and McNabb were the poor man's version of Harold Charmichael and Randall Cunningham.  Keith Jackson was an unstoppable force at TE, too.  

I think saying that Randall Cunningham was a poor mans version on Donovan McNabb would be more accurate.

[SoTier]

48 minutes ago, Bill from NYC said:

Awesome history lesson!!!

This of course omits the times where the Bills stood pat and made insane selections such as Whitner, McKelvin, a half crippled MaGahee, and a host of others.  Then on a rare trade down, they walked away from Mahomes and Watson.

 

This particular draft will tell us much about our future.

 

You missed the gem of taking Aaron Maybin instead of Brian Orakpo at #9 in 2009, probably the perfect example of why a team shouldn't draft for need and also why a HC shouldn't be given control of personnel unless his name is Belichick.

[SoTier]

26 minutes ago, Steve O said:

re TJ Grahm - saw a special about Wilson where they showed the Seattle war room in 2012 before their third round pick. They knew they no chance to get Wilson once the Bills traded ahead of them in the third. Then they showed the announcement of the Bills pick. Big sigh of relief in the war room. Make sure you don't have anything close buy that can be thrown through your TV if you ever see the special.

Re Watkins - I wanted the Bills to stand pat and pick Aaron Donald with that pick. They also could have had Mack with the pick they traded up to

Re Jones - Ever the optimist, I'm hoping the book is still out. Moulds didn't pan out until his third year. we'll see.

 

I was really po'd that the Bills didn't take Wilson.  He was clearly a first round talent -- probably a top 5 pick -- if there hadn't been so much prejudice against short QBs at the time.  Wilson was the reason that Mayfield was taken #1 rather than on Day 2.

 

I don't think that Jones will ever be a top NFL WR although he could develop into a solid one.   A lot of the Bills "misses" have been of that kind -- spending more to get a solid player rather than taking an excellent player.

[Steve O]

13 minutes ago, SoTier said:

 

You missed the gem of taking Aaron Maybin instead of Brian Orakpo at #9 in 2009, probably the perfect example of why a team shouldn't draft for need and also why a HC shouldn't be given control of personnel unless his name is Belichick.

He was talking about trades to move up. Stood pat for Maybin.

1 minute ago, SoTier said:

 

I was really po'd that the Bills didn't take Wilson.  He was clearly a first round talent -- probably a top 5 pick -- if there hadn't been so much prejudice against short QBs at the time.  Wilson was the reason that Mayfield was taken #1 rather than on Day 2.

 

I don't think that Jones will ever be a top NFL WR although he could develop into a solid one.   A lot of the Bills "misses" have been of that kind -- spending more to get a solid player rather than taking an excellent player.

Well, RGIII went #2 that year, Tannehill #8 - I'm sure Washington and Miami want a redo. Trent Richardson went 3 and Justin Blackman #5 so yeah, clearly a top 5 pick.

[Hapless Bills Fan]

1 hour ago, Steve O said:

re TJ Grahm - saw a special about Wilson where they showed the Seattle war room in 2012 before their third round pick. They knew they no chance to get Wilson once the Bills traded ahead of them in the third. Then they showed the announcement of the Bills pick. Big sigh of relief in the war room. Make sure you don't have anything close buy that can be thrown through your TV if you ever see the special.

Re Watkins - I wanted the Bills to stand pat and pick Aaron Donald with that pick. They also could have had Mack with the pick they traded up to

Re Jones - Ever the optimist, I'm hoping the book is still out. Moulds didn't pan out until his third year. we'll see.

 

I am still "salty" about that move.  I don't need that special to make me saltier.  We needed to take a QB.   Yes, we have Fitzpatrick, yes we gave him a big contract, yes he's shown he can play in the NFL but how well?  he also threw 23 INTs in 2011.  That means it's the perfect time to draft a guy to develop in case Fitz doesn't take that step.  We should be doing so on a regular basis anyway.

 

So here we are in the 3rd, not only Wilson but also Foles and Cousins are still on the board.  We trade up.  I shout "YES!" 

 

I know we're gonna do it.  We're going to draft a QB.  I want Wilson, Cousins my 2nd choice.

 

We draft....WHO?

 

Sometimes it sucks being a Bills fan, and sometimes it blows great big chunks.

[Cripple Creek]

1 hour ago, Ridgewaycynic2013 said:

Yes, but unlike the Henry offspring, all had different parentage.

Diversity is good.

9 minutes ago, Hapless Bills Fan said:

 

I am still "salty" about that move.  I don't need that special to make me saltier.  We needed to take a QB.   Yes, we have Fitzpatrick, yes we gave him a big contract, yes he's shown he can play in the NFL but how well?  he also threw 23 INTs in 2011.  That means it's the perfect time to draft a guy to develop in case Fitz doesn't take that step.  We should be doing so on a regular basis anyway.

 

So here we are in the 3rd, not only Wilson but also Foles and Cousins are still on the board.  We trade up.  I shout "YES!" 

 

I know we're gonna do it.  We're going to draft a QB.  I want Wilson, Cousins my 2nd choice.

 

We draft....WHO?

 

Sometimes it sucks being a Bills fan, and sometimes it blows great big chunks.

Let the past go. You’re too young to be getting worry lines. 

 

Today is is a good day.

[BringMetheHeadofLeonLett]

1 hour ago, vincec said:

I think saying that Randall Cunningham was a poor mans version on Donovan McNabb would be more accurate.

Must be a 'Cuse guy.  Cunningham was the QB you feared playing, McNabb was the leader of a talented team.  

[BuffaloBill]

On 4/13/2019 at 6:55 AM, njbuff said:

Perry Tuttle???

 

Then Tony Hunter in 83..........

 

Then Greg Bell in 84 (even though he wasn’t awful with the Bills, just didn’t mesh when Kelly arrived in 86).

 

Ah, skill position busts in back to back to back drafts.

 

Good times indeed.

 

This scenario scares me as people talk about using the #9 this year on a TE or WR.  Seems too high of a pick to go TE and does not appear to be “lock” at WR.

[without a drought]

The OP puts in the link for Quick's career stats but then he either ignores games played or thinks the G stands for goals, because he can't seem to figure out what happened to his career.

 

 

[Hapless Bills Fan]

25 minutes ago, without a drought said:

The OP puts in the link for Quick's career stats but then he either ignores games played or thinks the G stands for goals, because he can't seem to figure out what happened to his career.

 

His YPG plummeted during 2 years where he played a full season/missed only a couple games.  It's legit to ask why.  QB switch from Jaws to Cunningham is the probable answer, and then as Cunningham "got it" injuries took their toll and the games played tell the story.

[vincec]

8 hours ago, BringMetheHeadofLeonLett said:

Must be a 'Cuse guy.  Cunningham was the QB you feared playing, McNabb was the leader of a talented team.  

Cunningham was the guy who could make a spectacular play or throw it right to the defense, to paraphrase Jimmy Johnson. There's a reason he was 1-5 in the playoffs with the Eagles, despite having one of the great defenses of the decade on his side. To me he's actually third in Eagle QB history, behind both McNabb and Jaworski.

Edited April 14, 2019 by vincec

[LSHMEAB]

7 hours ago, Hapless Bills Fan said:

 

His YPG plummeted during 2 years where he played a full season/missed only a couple games.  It's legit to ask why.  QB switch from Jaws to Cunningham is the probable answer, and then as Cunningham "got it" injuries took their toll and the games played tell the story.

To quote Dumb and Dumber, "talk about being in the WRONG place at the WRONG time."

 

I've always felt like Eric Moulds could have been a HOF WR if he hadn't been in Levy's doghouse the first two years and played with an upper echelon QB his entire career.

 

The WR position is really dependent on the right QB.

[biggerdaddynj]

I know what happened to Mike Quick .. he just announced the Eagles pick in the second round.  ?

[NYGPopgun10]

On 4/13/2019 at 7:16 AM, SoTier said:

 

The Bills have demonstrated an almost magical ability to trade up to take the wrong player, which is an indictment of how bad their scouting and personnel decision making have been over the decades -- and that seems to regardless of the regime.   Their more recent trade up faux pas include trading back into the 1st in 2004 to draft JP Losman when they could have taken Matt Schaub in the 2nd or even maybe the third and gotten a significantly better QB -- or they could have simply waited until 2005 to take Aaron Rodgers with their #18 pick.  Russ Brandon and Dick Jauron traded back into the first round in 2006 to take John McCargo who barely played because of injury issues so just about anybody else would have been a better pick.  In 2012 Buddy Nix traded up in the third round to take forgettable WR TJ Graham instead of taking QB Russell Wilson.  In 2014, the  Bills traded their 2014 and 2015 first round picks to draft WR Sammy Watkins rather than Odell Beckham Jr or Mike Evans.  Finally, Brandon and McDermott traded up in the 2nd round in 2017 to take Zay Jones rather than JuJu Smith-Schuster.  Hopefully, Beane breaks the pattern because he traded up twice in the first round of the 2018 draft to take Josh Allen and/or Tremaine Edmunds.

 

I think the Bills finally are headed in the right direction. They got their QB last year in the very athletic Josh Allen. Now, they wound up with a good defensive player and line help to protect Allen. Maybe they finally have a plan. It's a lot better than the circus in East Rutherford. 

[Albany,n.y.]

3 hours ago, NYGPopgun10 said:

 

I think the Bills finally are headed in the right direction. They got their QB last year in the very athletic Josh Allen. Now, they wound up with a good defensive player and line help to protect Allen. Maybe they finally have a plan. It's a lot better than the circus in East Rutherford. 

Which one?  The one that gutted their roster & drafted a player at #6 who they hope doesn't play for 3 years, or the team that hired a head coach who looks like a mental patient and then hired 2 assistants who hate each other?  

[Reader]

On 4/13/2019 at 4:16 AM, SoTier said:

 

The Bills have demonstrated an almost magical ability to trade up to take the wrong player, which is an indictment of how bad their scouting and personnel decision making have been over the decades -- and that seems to regardless of the regime.   Their more recent trade up faux pas include trading back into the 1st in 2004 to draft JP Losman when they could have taken Matt Schaub in the 2nd or even maybe the third and gotten a significantly better QB -- or they could have simply waited until 2005 to take Aaron Rodgers with their #18 pick.  Russ Brandon and Dick Jauron traded back into the first round in 2006 to take John McCargo who barely played because of injury issues so just about anybody else would have been a better pick.  In 2012 Buddy Nix traded up in the third round to take forgettable WR TJ Graham instead of taking QB Russell Wilson.  In 2014, the  Bills traded their 2014 and 2015 first round picks to draft WR Sammy Watkins rather than Odell Beckham Jr or Mike Evans.  Finally, Brandon and McDermott traded up in the 2nd round in 2017 to take Zay Jones rather than JuJu Smith-Schuster.  Hopefully, Beane breaks the pattern because he traded up twice in the first round of the 2018 draft to take Josh Allen and/or Tremaine Edmunds.

 

The only challenge with that criteria is that the odds of being THAT successful are <1%. Pretty much any trade up will leave at least one player who will be more talented.

[Poleshifter]

On 4/13/2019 at 6:31 AM, LabattBlue said:

The floodgates are open.  I can see it now...

 

Hi guys!  Anyone know what happened to Don Majkowski?

 

Next day...

 

Hi guys!  Anyone know what happened to Brett Favre?

 

Next day...

 

Antonio Freeman

Robert Brooks

Bryce Paup

Jimmy Bratworst

Harold Sauerkraut

etc...

 

 

 

 

 

So why do you enter such a thread? Just to complain about it? OP liked that a WR was named Quick.

 

Go visit some other thread, fer chrissake.

 

[SoTier]

6 hours ago, Reader said:

 

The only challenge with that criteria is that the odds of being THAT successful are <1%. Pretty much any trade up will leave at least one player who will be more talented.

 

The problem with the Bills is that they have missed so often on their trade ups, most notably with Losman, McCargo, and Graham.  All three were busts so anybody they would have taken in their places would have been better simply because they would have had the extra picks.  Your view is dead on with Watkins and Jones, although since the Bills didn't keep Watkins, that move was a waste of draft capital, and Jones has yet to prove that he's not a bust.