Talent wise, that all star team would be plenty good enough to win a championship. The only question is coaching. Personally, I think Chan at HC/OC with Schwartz at DC would get it done but I can understand the doubters.
There’s no way this year’s team beats them. Maybe 1 time out of 10. You aren’t running against the all-drought front 7 from page 1 and I’m not sure which current WR is getting open with Gilmore, Clements and Winfield in coverage. On the other side, the all-drought OL would road grate the current defense with Lynch and Jackson carrying the rock. People say Bledsoe is weak and granted, he’s not nearly as good as Allen, but he’s did make the pro bowl in 2002. Plus which current CB is going to cover TO?
I’m not sure there’s a franchise out there where their current team would beat an all star team of their best players for nearly two decades. The all-drought teams weren’t even that bad. That was part of the problem. There were always stuck between 6 and 8 wins.