Jump to content

Is Nate Peteman the worst QB in NFL history?


bills6969

Recommended Posts

3 minutes ago, ngbills said:

I am starting to feel like the guys are keeping Peterman around because it makes Allen look better. Seriously, you throw Peterman out there and then Allen looks like a HOFer. 

I think it’s more incompetence and lack of ability to evaluate offensive players. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

42 minutes ago, 26CornerBlitz said:

I can't believe he's hiding behind his faith.  

 

Nathan Peterman: "It's Something I'll Learn From" (3:29)

Bills QB Nathan Peterman spoke to the media following the team's game vs the Texans. Peterman discussed having to come into the game after QB Josh Allen's injury and his state of mind after suffering a tough loss on the road.

 

What bothers me is I think that's at least 3 games now where Peterman has spoken to the media about his awful judgement as "something I'll learn from".

At some point you've got stop saying you will learn and do....or do not

  • Like (+1) 1
  • Thank you (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Kirby Jackson said:

This Peterman thing is kind of funny to me. He is the worst player to ever put on a bills uniform. It isn’t even up for debate. But still, these a-holes love him. He has had a job that he hasn’t deserved for a year and a half.

Worst player to put on any uniform. It is scary how stubborn they are to admit they whiffed on him. Put him on the practice squad if you dont want to fully admit it. But to keep putting him out there is unfair to the other players, the fans and even to Nate. 

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, Hapless Bills Fan said:

 

What bothers me is I think that's at least 3 games now where Peterman has spoken to the media about his awful judgement as "something I'll learn from".

At some point you've got stop saying you will learn and do....or do not

 

Bingo! Take a listen to McDermott if you haven't already. 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Hapless Bills Fan said:

 

What bothers me is I think that's at least 3 games now where Peterman has spoken to the media about his awful judgement as "something I'll learn from".

At some point you've got stop saying you will learn and do....or do not

 

a good point.  

 

the lack of coaching on this team is terrible.  Neither Peterman nor Allen have progressed at all since they were drafted.   Hopefully Anderson can help with that.   I'd grab antoher Vet to replace Peterman also.  

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

53 minutes ago, Fadingpain said:

The mistake these guys made was evaluating Peterman's capabilities based on what he was doing in pre-season football games, and you never judge anything based on pre-season football games, other than maybe the level of greed of the owners.

 

We needed a capable, playable QB on the roster and Peterman was not it.  

 

This administration thought he was.

 

That's a huge mistake.

 

 

It's really bad. It would have been bad last year after the Charger game. But they did it again this year and we saw the results in game one. It was obvious to a lot of people. The fact they waited a month to get a veteran in here is really troubling. 

  • Like (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's unacceptable that he has been trotted out, even thought of as a potential starter by this regime. 

 

I don't know how you can trust your gm or hc with your team making this decision. It's completely unacceptable, and the fact they both had this blind spot, makes me nervous.

 

How does neither of them look at it and say, this guy can't play? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, Elite Poster said:

 

Won the competition hands down? Were you at every practice? In the meeting rooms? Did you see what throws and coverages he was best and worst against? Did you see how he progressed within the scheme? 

 

What a bull **** comment. You saw 4 preseason games, you my friend, are a complete and utter imbecile. It took 2 quarters of NFL football for his bum ass to get benched. Won competition my ass. I attended a few practices and it was clear he was the worst; however, I'm just a fan so I trusted their judgement. Their judgement sucks. Stop giving the benefit of the doubt. He fooled this regime by making safe plays in practice where there was no pressure or pass rush. 


Good for you to get to some practices; too bad you weren't in the lockerroom any more than I was, nor listening to the position coaches. 

84

72

82

64
92
70

Look at what he did against the Bengals the only time he faced the first string defense - it was a repeat of what any person has seen watching him over the last two years. Having a few good throws when the game wasn't on the line or the top players weren't on the field means jack. Tossing some balls around in shorts - really? That's what helps you make your decisions?

On what basis do you think that Josh Allen is even the slightest bit better than Nathan Peterman, other than presumably a strong arm - even now? He's just a different sort of horrible. He has "led" the worst offense in the history of the team and in the game against Houston managed to digress to WORSE than what he was in college. 

LMAO. Sure. I'm an imbecile. And you are deluded by some sort of magic bean optimism. WTFU.
 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, 26CornerBlitz said:

I can't believe he's hiding behind his faith.  

 

Nathan Peterman: "It's Something I'll Learn From" (3:29)

Bills QB Nathan Peterman spoke to the media following the team's game vs the Texans. Peterman discussed having to come into the game after QB Josh Allen's injury and his state of mind after suffering a tough loss on the road.


This is exactly what I would have hoped he would have said. It's exactly what any Christian would have hoped to have him say. I don't know for a second what you are suggesting he said or would have wanted him to say. In fact you have a pretty comprehensive knowledge of the guy and knowing his past in college - did you expect something different?

He owned his mistake, said it was a bad read, and when asked how he keeps his head up he acknowledged that whether he wins or loses he is more than football, he is a man of God. Good for you, Nate.

Overmatched in the NFL? Sure. But to those that wanted to listen and learn instead of stand in idiotic judgement he gave a great lesson right there.

5 hours ago, Dr.Sack said:

Colin Kaepernick is available. Peterman should be cut. 


I'm a huge fan of Peterman as a human being. 

But not having CK on the roster to begin with is inexcusable. Actually starting Peterman - who was over his head as a 5th round rookie last year, and hadn't really stepped up in pre-season - that's just a slap in the face to not only this fan base but the entire fan base of the NFL.

Edited by Tyrod's friend
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, Elite Poster said:

The only reason he is still on the team is because he went to Pitt. McDermott is that type of guy. 

 

When I think of a QB school the last 30 years, Pitt sure ain’t on the list

 

 

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, ALF said:

That nice TD pass he threw , then back to reality is frustrating .

 

For sure

 

then the D huddled and said this is Peterman 

 

maybe rhey hey let him get the TD to boost his confidence for the big big big fall

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, mattynh said:

This guy kills me, he looks the part on a lot of plays but I am convinced he goes with his presnap read NO MATTER WHAT.  Which gets the ball out on time and works well for a few plays, til the defense realizes they can bait him and just take the game.

 

you are rightly convinced because that is exactly what he does.

8 hours ago, Tyrod's friend said:

and all the people that thought Josh Allen was capable of playing in the NFL Day 1, please also reveal themselves.

If you thought that Peterman wasn't the best QB in the preseason, you're a flaming idiot. He won the competition hands down, and it wasn't close, and Josh Allen hasn't done one thing to indicate to me YET that he can play in this league. A complete Kirk Cousins meltdown doesn't make Josh Allen a QB. 

 

The two things are separate. I wasn't high on Josh coming out, I thought he was incredibly raw and if he was ever an NFL QB it wouldn't be day 1 starter type..... however, I also knew beyond any doubt that you couldn't start Nathan Peterman because he just is not an NFL level player and hence Josh was the last bad option. The real question is how did the Bills get themselves in that position in the first place? Oh and I also didn't like the chances of McCarron proving adequate either. They just bungled the whole thing and a big reason why is because they had and maybe still have more confidence in Peterman than any reasonable person should have. 

  • Like (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, Foreigner said:

"It's something I'll learn from".

 

If Peterman ever puts on a Bills uniform again, the entire organization should pack it in.

 

Pegula should really step in at this point. He should say "I'm sorry guys I know you are the football professionals and I am not but this is my team and I am not willing to have that guy out there again because he is making us a laughing stock." The guys on British TV almost couldn't complete their highlights round up as they broke into a fit of giggles watching the Peterman picks "how can they keep playing this guy?"

  • Sad 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I remember there being a poster Savior Peterman here.  I’m guessing he might have changed his screen name by now. 

 

I think with Peterman it just comes down to the game is to fast for him to process at this level.  EJ I think had this issue too but not as bad.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

22 minutes ago, GunnerBill said:

 

 

 

The two things are separate. I wasn't high on Josh coming out, I thought he was incredibly raw and if he was ever an NFL QB it wouldn't be day 1 starter type..... however, I also knew beyond any doubt that you couldn't start Nathan Peterman because he just is not an NFL level player and hence Josh was the last bad option. The real question is how did the Bills get themselves in that position in the first place? Oh and I also didn't like the chances of McCarron proving adequate either. They just bungled the whole thing and a big reason why is because they had and maybe still have more confidence in Peterman than any reasonable person should have. 


Fair enough. You simply cannot expect a 5th round pick to be an NFL quality starter in either their first or even second year. A team that puts NP behind center, on the road, against one of the best defenses in the NFL at the time gets what it deserves.

It's absurdity; it's the same level of thinking that puts a WR coach in control of a rookie QB, or an ownership group that learned absolutely nothing about pairing a defensive HC (Rex) with a zero as an OC and then puts Brian Daboll in a room with a raw player like JA.

I grew up in NY Metro and I'm a long time fan of the Mets. Our manager put a presumably defensively talented rookie first baseman in left field, without the proper glove to play the game (oh yeah. At the same time, the guy playing first base really wasn't a 1B).

You don't have to study game tape or understand football at a D-1/pro level or watch every practice to realize when you are watching incompetence in any sport. 
 

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, ALF said:

That nice TD pass he threw , then back to reality is frustrating .

 

The thing I don't see discussed is that TD pass, right now I can't imagine Allen having made that pass and showed Zay Jones making a play when given a chance.   We have two guys who cant process anything post snap, one does not care and just throws it to the first read no matter what the other is trying to read things but cant do it fast enough to execute.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Tyrod's friend said:


This is exactly what I would have hoped he would have said. It's exactly what any Christian would have hoped to have him say. I don't know for a second what you are suggesting he said or would have wanted him to say. In fact you have a pretty comprehensive knowledge of the guy and knowing his past in college - did you expect something different?

He owned his mistake, said it was a bad read, and when asked how he keeps his head up he acknowledged that whether he wins or loses he is more than football, he is a man of God. Good for you, Nate.

Overmatched in the NFL? Sure. But to those that wanted to listen and learn instead of stand in idiotic judgement he gave a great lesson right there.


I'm a huge fan of Peterman as a human being. 

But not having CK on the roster to begin with is inexcusable. Actually starting Peterman - who was over his head as a 5th round rookie last year, and hadn't really stepped up in pre-season - that's just a slap in the face to not only this fan base but the entire fan base of the NFL.

 

His interview was about his play as an NFL QB and the response was a weak deflection to disarm any questions about his career viability.  His beliefs are immaterial to the conversation just as they are for any other player. 

Edited by 26CornerBlitz
  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

From Peter King:

Goat of the Week

Nathan Peterman, quarterback, Buffalo. Two interceptions in the final 90 seconds of a tie game in Houston, the first one giving the Texans a pick-six by Jonathan Joseph, and the second a desperado last gasp with 30 seconds left by Kareem Jackson. Texans 20, Bills 13, and Peterman’s first two NFL seasons continue to be an arduous exercise in personal torture.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...