Jump to content

Quenton Nelson - Indy OG ...#6 overall was worth it


LabattBlue

Recommended Posts

6 minutes ago, LabattBlue said:

Holy crap.  Watched him last night.  He is a MONSTER.  Pencil him in as an All-Pro for the next decade. 

 

 

I guess taking a OG at #6 isn’t such a bad idea. 

 

He's the real deal.

 

I like some of our draft options this year, but not sure picking at the top 10, many are throwing Jonah Williams out there but there are some quality OT, OG, and 3 centers I like that are round 2-3 options depending what the Bills do in FA.

  • Like (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not only did Indy get the player they wanted, but they got 3 extra 2nd rounders from the Jets.  They got picks 37 & 49 in 2018 & the Jets #2 this year which will be in the mid 30s of the entire draft to move down 3 slots.  

Anyone criticizing the Bills for trading up to pick 7 (and getting pick 255 which didn't work out) by moving from 21 giving up Cordy Glenn to get to 12 & then trading picks 12, 53 and 56 should realize that the Bills made a pretty good deal.  Looking at the trade up from 12, the Bills moved 5 spots & gave up 2 lower 2nd round picks.  The Jets gave up a lot more for Darnold than the Bills gave up for Allen & at this point the 2 are pretty equal. 

  • Like (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, WideNine said:

 

He's the real deal.

 

I like some of our draft options this year, but not sure picking at the top 10, many are throwing Jonah Williams out there but there are some quality OT, OG, and 3 centers I like that are round 2-3 options depending what the Bills do in FA.

 

I agree, some great options in round 2-3.   Whoever we get, at whatever position, needs to be a disruptor that other teams need to plan around.  Allen is turning into that.   You pick top 15, that's what you need.    I think by the time we pick, the "disruptors" remaining will be either CB, WR, DL.   I see us addressing the OL in FA, IMO.  Too important to hope for a rookie to get it. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, RyanC883 said:

 

I agree, some great options in round 2-3.   Whoever we get, at whatever position, needs to be a disruptor that other teams need to plan around.  Allen is turning into that.   You pick top 15, that's what you need.    I think by the time we pick, the "disruptors" remaining will be either CB, WR, DL.   I see us addressing the OL in FA, IMO.  Too important to hope for a rookie to get it. 

 

I am not even sure any of the WRs grade out that high this year, there are a few TE's that do though.

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Colts did an outstanding job in upgrading their OL to protect Luck. But Reich was just as big an upgrade.

 

They showed a stat last night that Luck went from dead last to top 8 in terms of getting the ball out quickly. 33% of his attempts are out in less than 2 seconds. Nobody is touching you when it comes out that fast.

 

Unfortunately for the Bills, I don't believe Allen has the accuracy to get rid of the ball that quickly, consistently. He is going to need a wall built around him if they are going to run a deep drop back pass offense. 

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Taking a Guard in the top ten is fine... IF there’s an Alan Faneca type in the draft. Most years there isn’t , and Nelson was hardly a secret. The middle of the Bills OL is very soft, but an OG isn’t in the cards at 9. OT Williams would fill a spot that’s been subpar for years. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He was viewed as a generational guard prospect projected to be a Zack Martin type player right out of the gate and Nelson came in and looked the part his rookie year. Given how important each position along the O-line is now and how hard it is to find guards now (It used to be the best guards and centers drafted in the first two rounds were low risk picks not so much anymore) its no longer stupid to draft guards or centers high up. They are premium positions that aren't easily replaceable. Overall I like to see a much hyped rookie guard come in and look the part, the last time guards went high in round one (Cooper and Warmack) they busted. 

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

51 minutes ago, Albany,n.y. said:

Not only did Indy get the player they wanted, but they got 3 extra 2nd rounders from the Jets.  They got picks 37 & 49 in 2018 & the Jets #2 this year which will be in the mid 30s of the entire draft to move down 3 slots.  

Anyone criticizing the Bills for trading up to pick 7 (and getting pick 255 which didn't work out) by moving from 21 giving up Cordy Glenn to get to 12 & then trading picks 12, 53 and 56 should realize that the Bills made a pretty good deal.  Looking at the trade up from 12, the Bills moved 5 spots & gave up 2 lower 2nd round picks.  The Jets gave up a lot more for Darnold than the Bills gave up for Allen & at this point the 2 are pretty equal. 

the saddest part is we wouldn't have given up any picks for Mahomes.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, LabattBlue said:

Holy crap.  Watched him last night.  He is a MONSTER.  Pencil him in as an All-Pro for the next decade. 

 

 

I guess taking a OG at #6 isn’t such a bad idea. 

 

Indy significantly upgraded their OL since Luck got hurt with Nelson being the crowning piece, the result being that their franchise QB not only has stayed mostly upright but he has played just like he was expected to play when they drafted him but never had because he was always running for his life or hurrying his throws.   QBs -- and other players --- can get hurt on almost any play, but having a good OL is about the best insurance policy a team can have.

 

The Bills have 10 draft picks in 2019.   If they are serious about developing Allen into a franchise QB and not just using him as an excuse to cover their own incompetence in figuring out how to build a competitive NFL team, they should draft at least 2 OLers, including at least one from Day One or Day Two (rounds 1-3).  With the salary cap, teams can't afford to sign more than 1 quality OLer through FA, and top OLers -- if they even hit free agency -- tend to cost only somewhat less than QBs and pass rushers.  Consequently, teams need to develop their own young OLers through the draft, so taking a good prospect in rounds 1-3 and another later is a good strategy.  Luckily,  OL is one unit where it's possible to truly find "diamonds in the rough" on Day 3.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, WMDman said:

I had him rated as the second best player in the draft,  if not fr the QBs he would have got picked alot higher

 

He’s not. No matter how good of a guard he is or will be, even the best ever, he is one in five on a unit. I see at least 3 QB’s, and probably 5, that will have a much bigger impact than he will.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, LabattBlue said:

Holy crap.  Watched him last night.  He is a MONSTER.  Pencil him in as an All-Pro for the next decade. 

 

 

I guess taking a OG at #6 isn’t such a bad idea. 

I think they also took their starting RT in the second round as well - but might be slightly off-base there, just remembering from the commentary in last night's broadcast.

 

Either way, goes to show that if you would like to see your offense improve at every level in one year, invest in the OL. Offensive success begins, and in a lot of cases this year, can stop right there. One of the larger reasons for Shady's regression this year was a lack of Wood and Incognito pulling for his running style. If we revamp successfully I would expect him to bounce back more next year, within reasonable context.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Binghamton Beast said:

 

He’s not. No matter how good of a guard he is or will be, even the best ever, he is one in five on a unit. I see at least 3 QB’s, and probably 5, that will have a much bigger impact than he will.

Mayfield and who???

 

 

i think there is a better chance that 4 out of the 5 qb’s drafted in the 1st round last year end up as nothing special(Mayfield being the exception) compared to Nelson who after 1 season appears to be very special...and should receive a lot of consideration for offensive RotY.  

 

Really early, but you are possibly looking at a HoF guard.  Which of the 5 QB’s can you say that about?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, RyanC883 said:

 

I agree, some great options in round 2-3.   Whoever we get, at whatever position, needs to be a disruptor that other teams need to plan around.  Allen is turning into that.   You pick top 15, that's what you need.    I think by the time we pick, the "disruptors" remaining will be either CB, WR, DL.   I see us addressing the OL in FA, IMO.  Too important to hope for a rookie to get it. 

What solid LT is available in FA? We go that route and you end up with Newhouse and Bodine. Bills need to get young and talented on that line, not one year stop gaps. Now is the time to sell out and improve instead of putting it off for another rebuild.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, LabattBlue said:

Holy crap.  Watched him last night.  He is a MONSTER.  Pencil him in as an All-Pro for the next decade. 

 

 

I guess taking a OG at #6 isn’t such a bad idea. 

 

Because the Colts have Luck, yes I agree. But taking an Offensive linemen that high without a franchise QB would be foolish, IMO. So, now with the Bills having Allen - yes, taking an Offensive lineman that high in the Draft, presuming it's warranted and not a reach, I'm good with it. At #9, I don't know anyone outside of Williams is worth that kind of Draft capital - but I haven't even started getting a good hold on the Draft eligible players. So, someone else I'm sure knows much better than I do. That said, I would expect the Bills to do something similar in terms of going all in on landing supporting talent for Josh on both the line and in terms of playmakers. 

 

I'm not one the guy who thinks you need a true #1 WR if the other WRs / TEs / RBs can all play well because we've seen in recent years where the teams that win, take this model. They get WRs who are 2s and 3s all over the field but put them in the right spot. Robert Foster and Zay Jones come to mind. Get two more like those two, and you're in good shape, regardless of who's #1 or #2 or #3, etc. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, LabattBlue said:

Holy crap.  Watched him last night.  He is a MONSTER.  Pencil him in as an All-Pro for the next decade. 

 

 

I guess taking a OG at #6 isn’t such a bad idea. 

 

If we didn't need Allen i really wanted this kid.

 

Also shows why we should take a RT at 9.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you get it right. Although I assume LG-RTs in the top 10 should be pretty close to sure things. I'd love a pick that lands anywhere from LG-RT so long as it's perennial All-Pro.. these guys better be a sure thing. If we're not getting the next D'Brickashaw Ferguson I'd punt down.

Edited by BarkleyForGOATBackupPT5P
Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...