Jump to content

Can you imagine being Allen last night?


whorlnut

Recommended Posts

1 hour ago, whorlnut said:

I can’t even imagine what was going through our star qbs head last night while he was watching that game. He saw 2 dominant OL’s completely handle the other team’s defensive front and give their qbs the time they needed to do their jobs. Allen is a team first guy and would NEVER throw his guys under the bus, but I can’t imagine for one second he isn’t envious of the Mahomes and hurts.

 

This is why Beane has no choice this off-season other than to overhaul the wall in front of Allen. His defensive heavy offseasons haven’t been the answer in the playoffs. This is an offense first league and good offensive lines can negate a good to great defensive line. 

I don't know about Allen but I was jealous of BOTH teams O lines.  That the Bills have not worked aggressively to shore up this unit is a miss of epic proportions.  They have the key piece place - an elite, once in a generation talent at QB. 

 

At first continuously pouring money and draft picks into the defensive line while allowing the O line to languish was a RISK.  Then it turned into a MISTAKE when it didn't work.  If it continues it will be an example of FOOTBALL MALPRACTICE.

 

 

 

 

  • Like (+1) 1
  • Agree 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I feel like "no sacks" was more on both QBs being very mobile and good at escaping pressure than on the OLs. I saw plenty of times the QBs were scrambling and being moved around and out of the pocket. Mahomes wasn't comfortable in a clean pocket from what I saw.

 

That being said, yes, both teams have better OLs than the Bills and we need to address it. Still chaps my ass every time I see Creed getting fired up and making plays for the Chiefs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

30 minutes ago, UKBillFan said:


😆 You’ve really got it in for Josh. 

 

He is just mad looking at the 2023 Futures NFL MVP Odds where Allen has a massive lead on Mahomes and everyone else.

 

Bills boards: Allen is a massive problem!! He isn't good enough! He turns the ball over way way too much!  He is a liability!  Wah! Wah! Wah!  

 

Vegas:  NFL MVP Favorite by a landslide.

 

image.thumb.png.8d62939f32ba4326fd0cb16bfe02e787.png

Edited by Big Turk
  • Thank you (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Last night Super Bowl should solidify for anyone, our FO included, that Offense wins Championships.  
 

You couldn’t have told me who had an average defense and who had an elite defense last night.  They both looked the same.  
 

Eagles invested more than us even, in that Defense .. and it didn’t matter when they played an elite offense.  
 

You need an average defense with some playmakers.. which we have with Von, Milano and hopefully Tre/Hyde. 
 

Yet we’ll justify re-signing Edmunds and keeping Oliver around … 24M in cap allocated to excess Defensive talent that doesn’t protect or help our QB.  
 

Edited by SCBills
  • Like (+1) 2
  • Thank you (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

34 minutes ago, Big Turk said:

 

Their defense didn't force that, Hurts simply dropped the ball untouched. Let's not pretend they did something other than being in the right position to pick up an easy fumble with nobody but 3 Chief players around it.

 

Funnily enough Mahomes had a very similar play against the Bengals.

Yep, as soon as it happened it reminded me of the Mahomes fumble against Cincy.  Only difference was there were Chiefs around to prevent them from advancing it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, Big Turk said:

 

Favre was a 3 time NFL MVP in 3 straight years between 1995-1997, are you claiming the voting was rigged or something.  C'mon man, let's stop pretending he wasn't among the best of his time. This sounds really revisionist.

Yes Brett Favre won individual accomplishments. Who cares?

 

If Josh Allen wins MVP 11 times and never wins a SB, that would not be good enough.

 

Like I said, Brett Favre isn't sitting at the table with Montana and Brady.  That's fine, bc I don't really care about that either. Just win one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, SCBills said:

Last night Super Bowl should solidify for anyone, our FO included, that Offense wins Championships.  
 

You couldn’t have told me who had an average defense and who had an elite defense last night.  They both looked the same.  
 

Eagles invested more than us even, in that Defense .. and it didn’t matter when they played an elite offense.  
 

Yet we’ll justify re-signing Edmunds and keeping Oliver around … 24M in cap allocated to excess Defensive talent that doesn’t protect or help our QB.  

And my worry is our defensive-minded HC will never figure that out.

  • Agree 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Big Turk said:

 

He is just mad looking at the 2023 Futures NFL MVP Odds where Allen has a massive lead on Mahomes and everyone else.

 

Bills boards: Allen is a massive problem!! He isn't good enough! Wah! Wah! Wah!  

 

Vegas:  NFL MVP Favorite by a landslide.

 

image.thumb.png.8d62939f32ba4326fd0cb16bfe02e787.png

 

Have to wonder how they've worked that one out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, Big Turk said:

 

He is just mad looking at the 2023 Futures NFL MVP Odds where Allen has a massive lead on Mahomes and everyone else.

 

Bills boards: Allen is a massive problem!! He isn't good enough! He turns the ball over way way too much!  He is a liability!  Wah! Wah! Wah!  

 

Vegas:  NFL MVP Favorite by a landslide.

 

image.thumb.png.8d62939f32ba4326fd0cb16bfe02e787.png

Imagine caring about Josh Allen's individual awards more than Super Bowl wins. Are you from Wyoming or Buffalo?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, Big Turk said:

 

He is just mad looking at the 2023 Futures NFL MVP Odds where Allen has a massive lead on Mahomes and everyone else.

 

Bills boards: Allen is a massive problem!! He isn't good enough! Wah! Wah! Wah!  

 

Vegas:  NFL MVP Favorite by a landslide.

 

image.thumb.png.8d62939f32ba4326fd0cb16bfe02e787.png

The odd makers must have confidence that the FO makes the necessary moves this offseason to make that possible.  I certainly hope they're right.

 

I'm looking forward to the draft, but also dreading it at the same time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Big Turk said:

As we have seen time and again, defense doesn't really matter in the playoffs against elite teams.  They are gonna score their points. Bills had the #6, #1, and #2 defenses in the NFL and got smoked all three times in the playoffs against elite offenses. 

 

Eagles had the 3rd most sacks in NFL history next to 84 and 85 Bears and got 0 last night. 2nd best D in the NFL, allowed 38 points(31 if you don't count the Defensive TD by KC). KC moved the ball and scored at will on every possession in the 2nd half. 

 

Defense only has to be around league average to be good enough. Bills need to allocate 90% of resources to offensive line and offensive weapons. The rules are simply tilted too far in the offenses favor for it to matter with defense, unless your DLine can maul the other team's OLine and usually that isn't going to happen unless multiple starters are out. 

 

My takeaway isn't that defense doesn't matter in the playoffs, it's that you have to take chances on defense. The Eagles didn't take chances. They dropped their CBs back instead of pressing which gave plenty of space for the Chiefs pass catchers to get open. It was like us against the Bengals. I saw a stat that Mahomes got the ball out of his hands in under 2.5 seconds 56% of the time last night. It's easy to get the ball out fast when your receivers are given a free release, and this helps to neutralize a great pass rushs. In the playoffs against great offenses with experienced players and coaches that style of defensive play makes it way too easy. It was an awful defensive game plan on the biggest stage.

 

The Chiefs under Spagnuolo have been willing to take chances. It burns them sometimes, but it's that or let the championship caliber offense you're playing kill you slowly. Take chances and when the QB inexplicably drops the ball your guy is there to pick it up and run it back for a TD instead of being 10 yards away from the play.

 

The Bills when healthy are plenty talented enough to slow down some of the better offenses. We've seen them do it in the regular season. But can McDermott and Frazier adjust their philosophy for playoff football when simple and safe doesn't get it done?

  • Awesome! (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

31 minutes ago, FireChans said:

I love Josh. 

 

I think the narrative that he can do no wrong and is constantly let down by everyone around him is false.

I agree. Josh has his own issues to clean up. He should not be immune from criticism.

 

Yes, the oline needs to be a lot better, and yes, the defense needs to play better in key situations, but Josh made a lot of bad mistakes of his own last year.

 

When your oline is not good, you need to get the ball out quicker, for one thing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

48 minutes ago, The Jokeman said:

Without a defensive TD the Chiefs would have loss. 


Would they have? Are you saying the Eagles wouldn’t have punted if they recovered and KC wouldn’t have scored a TD? Or KC recovered on the spot and the offense then scored?

 

What I do know is Philly’s vaunted defense had no answer in the 2nd half for the Chiefs last night.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, HappyDays said:

 

My takeaway isn't that defense doesn't matter in the playoffs, it's that you have to take chances on defense. The Eagles didn't take chances. They dropped their CBs back instead of pressing which gave plenty of space for the Chiefs pass catchers to get open. It was like us against the Bengals. I saw a stat that Mahomes got the ball out of his hands in under 2.5 seconds 56% of the time last night. It's easy to get the ball out fast when your receivers are given a free release, and this helps to neutralize a great pass rushs. In the playoffs against great offenses with experienced players and coaches that style of defensive play makes it way too easy. It was an awful defensive game plan on the biggest stage.

 

The Chiefs under Spagnuolo have been willing to take chances. It burns them sometimes, but it's that or let the championship caliber offense you're playing kill you slowly. Take chances and when the QB inexplicably drops the ball your guy is there to pick it up and run it back for a TD instead of being 10 yards away from the play.

 

The Bills when healthy are plenty talented enough to slow down some of the better offenses. We've seen them do it in the regular season. But can McDermott and Frazier adjust their philosophy for playoff football when simple and safe doesn't get it done?

The Chiefs didn't stop the Eagles for a single second bro. Jalen Hurts just dropped the ball. They didn't return it for a TD because of Spags.  That's insane.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

21 minutes ago, UKBillFan said:


No. The issue is Mahomes or Burrow seem to have a hideous game and move on. Josh’s errors seem to permeate across a run. Maybe fewer in a single game but they build up across a number.

I live in Cincinnati and follow the Bengals almost as closely as the Bills and Burrow does have multiple games were he doesn't play his best.  As for Mahomes and the Chiefs all you're seeing is the brilliant ability of Andy Reid to correct mistakes and adjust the Offense when there is a problem.

 

Everything I've seen over the last few years reinforces the following opinions:

 

*  Allen is elite and every bit as good s Mahomes & Burrow or any other QB in the NFL.

 

*  The Bills have struggled for YEARS on the O line.  By any objective measure Buffalo's O line is bad.  Allen hides many of it's deficiencies.  Such poor O line lay will lead to inconsistencies on offense and the occasional games in which Allen struggles.

 

*  Allen has been handicapped by an organization that is not offensively geared.  Success in the current NFL is overwhelmingly characterized by offensive coaches and organizations. Watching KC rebuild its O line while paying big bucks to Mahomes is exactly the template the Bills should be copying. 

 

Notice I didn't even include skill players.  Sure Allen doesn't enjoy the riches in play makers that Tua, Hurts or Burrow enjoy but if you put a great O line in front of Allen and put Andy Reid as his coach Bills fans would already be celebrating a Super Bowl win or two with a more to come.

 

Do I think McD & Bean can get the Bills a Super Bowl victory? Yes I do.  But it starts this off season with a 180 degree pivot in the Bills approach to the offensive side of the ball.

 

 

 

 

 

   

 

 

 

 

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

33 minutes ago, LABILLBACKER said:

This organization had every opportunity to build a dominant OL in front of Josh in 2019 and beyond.  They've failed him, plain & simple.  They choose defensive failures over protecting and supporting your greatest asset.  Let McD wrestle with that.

Yep, we can claim Josh isn't on a level playing field with guys like Mahomes, but the Bills really have no one to blame for that besides themselves.  

 

I'm hoping after watching this Super Bowl in particular, the lightbulb comes on and they figure out that it's the offense that matters most in today's NFL.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

26 minutes ago, FireChans said:

Lmao what

 

Allen led the league in TO's by a decent amount.  Led the league in RZ TO's. 

 

These are bad statistics for your QB to be the worst at

And until this year Allen was incredible in the Red zone and then something happened....  Oh yea, coaching and play calling where many successful Red zone were the result of individual playmaking, not schemes or calls. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Billsfan1972 said:

And until this year Allen was incredible in the Red zone and then something happened....  Oh yea, coaching and play calling where many successful Red zone were the result of individual playmaking, not schemes or calls. 

 

Don't need to be a coach to tell you "don't throw this ball" lmao.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, HappyDays said:

 

My takeaway isn't that defense doesn't matter in the playoffs, it's that you have to take chances on defense. The Eagles didn't take chances. They dropped their CBs back instead of pressing which gave plenty of space for the Chiefs pass catchers to get open. It was like us against the Bengals. I saw a stat that Mahomes got the ball out of his hands in under 2.5 seconds 56% of the time last night. It's easy to get the ball out fast when your receivers are given a free release, and this helps to neutralize a great pass rushs. In the playoffs against great offenses with experienced players and coaches that style of defensive play makes it way too easy. It was an awful defensive game plan on the biggest stage.

 

The Chiefs under Spagnuolo have been willing to take chances. It burns them sometimes, but it's that or let the championship caliber offense you're playing kill you slowly. Take chances and when the QB inexplicably drops the ball your guy is there to pick it up and run it back for a TD instead of being 10 yards away from the play.

 

The Bills when healthy are plenty talented enough to slow down some of the better offenses. We've seen them do it in the regular season. But can McDermott and Frazier adjust their philosophy for playoff football when simple and safe doesn't get it done?

True, but that game also showed that you don't even need great receivers to beat a good defense.  You just need good play calling, good blocking up front, and a QB that can deliver the ball on time and the defense is going to have a hard time stopping you no matter what they do.

 

That's how the league is designed these days.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, DrDawkinstein said:

I feel like "no sacks" was more on both QBs being very mobile and good at escaping pressure than on the OLs. I saw plenty of times the QBs were scrambling and being moved around and out of the pocket. Mahomes wasn't comfortable in a clean pocket from what I saw.

 

That being said, yes, both teams have better OLs than the Bills and we need to address it. Still chaps my ass every time I see Creed getting fired up and making plays for the Chiefs.

There was some of that but at one point they flashed a stat where the QB had only been hurried on 5 of 33 pass attempts.  This pales in comparison to Allen who is routinely hurried on one third to one half of his drop backs. Imagine enduring that game after game after game over a 17 game season?

 

Also because the O lines yesterday were so good what you often saw was ONE guy or a blitzer get in quick and force Mahomes or Hurts to move round.  But across the line you saw guys holding their blocks enabling the QB's to move and reestablish themselves for the throw.

 

 

 

 

 

 

  • Like (+1) 2
  • Agree 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

32 minutes ago, FireChans said:

 

Don't need to be a coach to tell you "don't throw this ball" lmao.

If I remember, Allen's explanation for that was the rusher at the top of the screen that was being blocked and later broke free to get closer to Allen blocked his view and he never saw the defender there.  Either way, yeah, not a good ball.  He should've recognized the coverage.

Edited by Billz4ever
Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, FireChans said:

The Chiefs didn't stop the Eagles for a single second bro. Jalen Hurts just dropped the ball. They didn't return it for a TD because of Spags.  That's insane.

 

They actually did when it mattered in the 2nd half. That's what helped give them the lead, a key stop on 3rd down, a bad punt and a return to the 5 yard line.

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 minutes ago, UKBillFan said:

 

Have to wonder how they've worked that one out.

My guess is that they factored in that Allen was 3rd in the voting this season so right there he should be a top 5 candidate.  Then they considered Allen's elite skill set and that bumped him into the top 3.  Then they look at the Bills and asked the question "where do they have to get better"? and the logical answer is on the O line and in the number of play makers.  In other words Allen is going to get more help.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, FireChans said:

The Chiefs didn't stop the Eagles for a single second bro. Jalen Hurts just dropped the ball. They didn't return it for a TD because of Spags.  That's insane.

 

No I get that, but they weren't going to stop them no matter what they did. The Eagles offense is much more talented than the Chiefs defense. So they blitzed a lot and took some chances. They got some hits in on Hurts, made him as uncomfortable as possible, and when the moment came for a game changing play they were there for it. Compared to what the Eagles did where they let Mahomes on a bad ankle stand there comfortable the whole game and pick them apart. I know which game plan I prefer.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

53 minutes ago, McBean said:


Beane has no choice? Lol, you mean McDermott.

 

Beane looks at the books and the cap. McDermott runs this entire organization.

What evidence do we really have to make such a definitive statement. I'm not saying that McDermott doesn't have input as most any head coach I expect does but that doesn't mean he runs the entire organization.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, HappyDays said:

 

No I get that, but they weren't going to stop them no matter what they did. The Eagles offense is much more talented than the Chiefs defense. So they blitzed a lot and took some chances. They got some hits in on Hurts, made him as uncomfortable as possible, and when the moment came for a game changing play they were there for it. Compared to what the Eagles did where they let Mahomes on a bad ankle stand there comfortable the whole game and pick them apart. I know which game plan I prefer.

On the TD to Skyy Moore, the Eagles blitzed up the middle and the Chiefs had the perfect counter called.  The blitz came and Mahomes simply tossed it to a wide-open Moore.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, HappyDays said:

 

No I get that, but they weren't going to stop them no matter what they did. The Eagles offense is much more talented than the Chiefs defense. So they blitzed a lot and took some chances. They got some hits in on Hurts, made him as uncomfortable as possible, and when the moment came for a game changing play they were there for it. Compared to what the Eagles did where they let Mahomes on a bad ankle stand there comfortable the whole game and pick them apart. I know which game plan I prefer.

What? 

 

The Eagles hit Mahomes 5 times. The Chiefs hit Hurts twice.  You are trying to force a narrative with the wrong data. The Chiefs game plan was just as terrible as the Eagles. Mahomes just didn't drop the ball randomly. That's it.  

 

Jalen Hurts had 370 yards and 4 TD's.  That's not "picking them apart?"  11 of 18 on first down.  10 more minutes TOP. 72 offensive plays.

 

I understand this is your "Leslie Frazier lost the Super Bowl for the Eagles magnum opus" but come on bro.

Edited by FireChans
  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Billsfan1972 said:

I thought this would be about Hurts Fumble TD, which hasn't been discussed enough and one of the worst plays I've ever seen.

 

If that was Allen people would lose it about his issues "holding on to the ball". 

That would be because Allen, like it or not has ball security issues…, 

which would get better if he had an above average O-line, which he doesn’t….,

Edited by Don Otreply
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, Billz4ever said:

On the TD to Skyy Moore, the Eagles blitzed up the middle and the Chiefs had the perfect counter called.  The blitz came and Mahomes simply tossed it to a wide-open Moore.

 

The Eagles have apparently been susceptible to pre-snap motions all year long and Andy Reid clearly knew that. On that and the TD to Toney, whoever was supposed to cover them got confused and abandoned their man. I don't think the blitz had anything to do with it. They went into man coverage which they had barely done the rest of the game and got confused.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Radar said:

What evidence do we really have to make such a definitive statement. I'm not saying that McDermott doesn't have input as most any head coach I expect does but that doesn't mean he runs the entire organization.

Evidence?

 

Ran the first draft that was a disaster.

 

He then hand picked Beane after draft.

 

Beane is a puppet. McDermott is the Czar.

  • Eyeroll 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Quote

The Chiefs were not statistically terrible on defense this season. They ranked 18th in defensive EPA and were young in key spots. Kansas City’s No. 32 ranking in special-teams EPA accounts for the No. 29 ranking in combined EPA in the two phases Mahomes cannot control.

 

The “Quarterback Betrayal Index” we published before the season showed only five established starting quarterbacks over the previous decade getting less support from their own defense/special teams than Mahomes had gotten from his. Drew Brees, Justin Herbert, Tony Romo, Matt Ryan and Aaron Rodgerscombined for zero Super Bowl victories over that 10-year run from 2012-21. Mahomes had won one, and now he has another.

From The Athletic. This is interesting, because to me the Chiefs defense has proven time and time again to step up and make the plays when needed. I’m not sure what this Betrayal Index is, but I’m positive it’d list Allen as one who has the most help from his defense/ST, yet look which unit consistently folds when it matters… We need a Spagnuolo/Anarumo type of DC.

  • Agree 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, FireChans said:

What? 

 

The Eagles hit Mahomes 5 times. The Chiefs hit Hurts twice.  You are trying to force a narrative with the wrong data. The Chiefs game plan was just as terrible as the Eagles. Mahomes just didn't drop the ball randomly. That's it.  

 

Jalen Hurts had 370 yards and 4 TD's.  That's not "picking them apart?"

 

I understand this is your "Leslie Frazier lost the Super Bowl for the Eagles magnum opus" but come on bro.

 

From a talent perspective the Eagles are more talented than the Chiefs. I don't think the Chiefs could have really done anything to stop them. Maybe the Chiefs versus the Bengals is a better analog. They took some chances and slowed them down.

 

But the Eagles gameplan against the Chiefs I will stand by my assertion that it was a historically bad defensive game plan in the Super Bowl.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, HappyDays said:

 

From a talent perspective the Eagles are more talented than the Chiefs. I don't think the Chiefs could have really done anything to stop them. Maybe the Chiefs versus the Bengals is a better analog. They took some chances and slowed them down.

 

But the Eagles gameplan against the Chiefs I will stand by my assertion that it was a historically bad defensive game plan in the Super Bowl.

The Eagles got burned when they blitzed. They got burned when they dropped.

 

They had a front 5 that had 56 sacks on the year. They had a league leading 70 sacks. None of them got home.

 

Relying on your players that got you there and were terrorizing opposing teams all year is not a bad gameplan lol.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, CincyBillsFan said:

My guess is that they factored in that Allen was 3rd in the voting this season so right there he should be a top 5 candidate.  Then they considered Allen's elite skill set and that bumped him into the top 3.  Then they look at the Bills and asked the question "where do they have to get better"? and the logical answer is on the O line and in the number of play makers.  In other words Allen is going to get more help.

 

 


That’s logical. They have more faith in McBeane being logical than I have at this early stage.

  • Agree 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, Don Otreply said:

That would be because Allen, like it or not has ball security issues…, 

which would get better if he had an above average O-line, which he doesn’t….,

That was one of the worst turnovers I've ever seen (in running with butt fumble) and on the biggest stage and was glossed over.

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, McBean said:

Evidence?

 

Ran the first draft that was a disaster.

 

He then hand picked Beane after draft.

 

Beane is a puppet. McDermott is the Czar.

 

I would hope this wouldn't be the case. Preparing for the draft starts in September when CFB starts. Beane has his scouts covering all the conferences. Beane can split his time between the Bills and college football. McDermott really can't since he is focused on the Bills season. For all we know Beane probably travels to some CFB games if a Bills scout tells him come to see a specific player and then flies back to where the Bills are playing that Sunday. My point is Beane and his scouts have been paying to attention to these players in college all season long. They are the ones who put together the Bills draft board based on what they have seen. Why should McDermott run the draft when he hasn't focused on CFB like Beane and the scouts have. I hope Terry tells McDermott that Beane has the final say on who the Bills draft. That way McDermott can't do anything about it. Terry is the real Czar in Bills land.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Billsfan1972 said:

That was one of the worst turnovers I've ever seen (in running with butt fumble) and on the biggest stage and was glossed over.

How  Does this change the fact that Josh has been a bit sloppy over his career as to ball security? Earning that rep…,

Link to comment
Share on other sites

55 minutes ago, Big Turk said:

 

Favre was a 3 time NFL MVP in 3 straight years between 1995-1997, are you claiming the voting was rigged or something.  C'mon man, let's stop pretending he wasn't among the best of his time. This sounds really revisionist.

 

It feels like @FireChans is saying one thing and you are taking it and running too far with it. 

Favre is great. Had a great career. Belongs in the pantheon of QB folklore. But nobody is mistaking Favre for a top 5 QB. If you gave Belichick Favre, they would be a really good team still, and Favre might have a better career, but he still wouldn't be better than Brady That is what the comparison to Mahomes and Allen is. Allen is great. Love him. Love it. But ultimately Mahomes is the better QB by a wide margin, even in comparison to other great QB's.

I think if Mahomes ended his career tomorrow he is likely a first ballot HoF'er. Allen would not be close. Part of that is environment, and part of that is the player. 

55 minutes ago, SCBills said:

Last night Super Bowl should solidify for anyone, our FO included, that Offense wins Championships.  
 

You couldn’t have told me who had an average defense and who had an elite defense last night.  They both looked the same.  
 

Eagles invested more than us even, in that Defense .. and it didn’t matter when they played an elite offense.  
 

You need an average defense with some playmakers.. which we have with Von, Milano and hopefully Tre/Hyde. 
 

Yet we’ll justify re-signing Edmunds and keeping Oliver around … 24M in cap allocated to excess Defensive talent that doesn’t protect or help our QB.  
 

 

 

The current version of Hurts is going to hold the Eagles back once he gets his big deal. He puts his receivers in too many difficult positions. He has a lot of talent around him that makes up for that, but once he gets paid he will have to make due with less. Nothing I saw last night tells me he is capable of that. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This topic is OLD. A NEW topic should be started unless there is a very specific reason to revive this one.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...