Sean apologists... If McD gets fired without ever winning a Super Bowl, you will...

[Buffalo Boy]

19 minutes ago, Cray51 said:

What does he look like?  Maybe making breaking the longest playoff drought in franchise history?

 

But IDK there isn't any sample to go off of.  Oh wait.

And I dated a 10 in high school …… but that was then and this is now🤷‍♂️

12 minutes ago, MJS said:

He took the Bills to the playoffs before Josh Allen ever got here, in a year where he was accused of tanking the team.

So did Dick Jauron….. with the Bears and a better record…… a blind nut finds a squirrel once in a while 

[HappyDays]

2 hours ago, Miyagi-Do Karate said:

Those of us that support him are worried about blowing things up and making it worse by inevitably bringing in new systems and schemes and someone who is undoubtedly going to be way less experienced. It’s a lot of risk. Would be different if we weren’t so far into Allen’s career. 

 

The two #1 seeds in the NFL right now are led by new head coaches, and not so coincidentally those two coaches were the most popular McDermott replacement options brought up last year. There's a pervasive myth that turning around a team takes several years. It really doesn't though. Good systems work right away and if anything the newness of those systems will catch teams off guard in that first year.

[TheFunPolice]

5 minutes ago, MJS said:

I agree. If Tomlin had a quarterback again, he'd have a strong team.

 

Agreed also. 

 

People forget that Tomlin + HOF QB equaled 2 SB berths and one win during the era of Manning and Brady. Plus Big Ben had some great success later in his career too.

 

The current Steelers team is old, tired, overpaid, and just done. Watt is not the same guy this season as he has been, nor is Hayward. Their last couple OCs have been bad, but they also have an awful OL and barely any threats on offense to throw to or run the ball. 

 

A buddy of mine is a huge Steelers fan so I see a lot of their games and talk a lot of Steelers ball. They are not a good team. Their defense is so-so at best and their offense struggles to string together 7-8 play drives. 

 

As much as Steelers fans hate Tomlin, I think he coaches up a 6-11 team to 9-8 each season. That isn't a 11-6 roster. 

 

 

 

 

[Cray51]

7 minutes ago, Buffalo Boy said:

And I dated a 10 in high school …… but that was then and this is now🤷‍♂️

So did Dick Jauron….. with the Bears and a better record…… a blind nut finds a squirrel once in a while 

Buddy, she was a 6 at best.

 

You asked what McD would have done without Allen, I gave you the only evidence we can go off of.

 

But feel free to move the goal posts

[PromoTheRobot]

3 hours ago, ChronicAndKnuckles said:

Aaron Rodger’s, Favre, Russell Wilson, Steve Young, Drew Brees, Kurt Warner, Johnny U all only have 1. 
 

Marino, Kelly, Tarkenton, Fouts, Moon, Cunningham have zero.

 

People think Brady and Mahomes are the norm and they aren’t. 
 

It’s extremely tough to win a SB even when you have all the pieces in place, it still requires a lot of luck. I fault McDermott for 13 seconds, but it was not a given that they would’ve won it all.

 

Stop making sense.

[nuklz2594]

id have to listen to my patriots bride needle me until the end of time

[MasterStrategist]

21 minutes ago, HappyDays said:

 

The two #1 seeds in the NFL right now are led by new head coaches, and not so coincidentally those two coaches were the most popular McDermott replacement options brought up last year. There's a pervasive myth that turning around a team takes several years. It really doesn't though. Good systems work right away and if anything the newness of those systems will catch teams off guard in that first year.

Not saying it cant be done - but those are 2 teams who had a lot of cap space and top 10 draft picks.  Lets see if either makes it to the SB.

 

Lots of examples of 1 year wonders too, most recently Dan Quinn in Washington.  

 

Lets see if Pats and Bears continue to have that kind of success moving forward.

 

I think Beane has created a mess in cap and decisions at WR - even at that, this years AFC division winners (atm), are all led by QBs who haven't proven any playoff success.  Anything can happen this year in the AFC.  Likely without KC or Cincy in the way, I like our odds in any matchup if we can get in.

[Nihilarian]

The Buffalo Bills biggest nemesis finally fell on their face this year, and what stinks is Buffalo is behind the Patriots now.  While New England had a 4th-place schedule, and Buffalo had a 1st-place schedule.

 

You know what, the season isn't over yet. 

 

Right now, Denver has home-field advantage throughout and has a better defense. 

[Slippery Rubber Mats]

3 hours ago, DrDawkinstein said:

 

I'd be happy with just 1. That isnt the question.

 

 

 

Yet, that's the response we get in many threads from Sean supporters. I agree their argument is flawed.

 

Quote me a direct response that anyone is " happy sitting on a nice Regular Season win/loss record, and some AFC East Championships " Direct quote for that please, not doomer paraphrasing. I'm calling you out.

[TheyCallMeAndy]

We missed the boat with Johnson and possibly Vabrel, I'm not sure there are coaching candidates to that caliber this summer. 
 

Even the coach for Cinci, he hasn't done a thing. If he became available I don't know if he's an upgrade?

 

Folks act like it can't be worse. It totally can. You can't just "make a move," you have to make the correct move. You HAVE to be correct. The world where we miss having the 11-13 win, Divisional-AFC title knock out games absolutely exists. 
 

Pegs NEEDS to get the timing right on the next GM/HC. 
 

It's easy to pound the table and say 'make a change,' but who are we bringing in? Who replaces McD? Who replaces Beane?

 

I'll hang up and listen. 
 

Or not because I know the responses will essentially be "it doesn’t matter" over and over again.

[BillsShredder83]

3 hours ago, DrDawkinstein said:

I dont think he gets fired this year, so that isnt the question.

 

Terry and many folks here seem to be happy sitting on a nice Regular Season win/loss record, and some AFC East Championships (although those days seem to be over now that there's a better HC in the Division).

 

When we go another few years of this garbage, and Josh has officially entered the end of his career, how happy will you McD Apologists be with nothing to show for it all?

I agree and have come around completely to it this year.

 

We all know it won't happen though. If were hell bent on not changing, WTF is stopping us from going out and hiring the best G-D OC & DC possible. Stop being cheap.

 

We can pay backups a few million... but shelling out a few mill a year for top coordinators seems like an incredibly cost efficient, highly predictable output chances. 

[HappyDays]

11 minutes ago, MasterStrategist said:

Anything can happen this year in the AFC.  Likely without KC or Cincy in the way, I like our odds in any matchup if we can get in.

 

I mostly agree with this. Our passing offense scares me though. In 6 games since the bye week we've only seen the passing offense have 2 good games. It's just hard to imagine winning 3 road games in a row and then the Super Bowl with such an inconsistent passing offense. I guess the optimistic scenario is we get Kincaid and Palmer back healthy and that ends up being enough. We will still have to mostly rely on the run game though and I worry about what will happen when we inevitably get in a playoff matchup where the run isn't successful.

 

Edited 24 minutes ago by HappyDays

[DrDawkinstein]

1 minute ago, BillsShredder83 said:

I agree and have come around completely to it this year.

 

We all know it won't happen though. If were hell bent on not changing, WTF is stopping us from going out and hiring the best G-D OC & DC possible. Stop being cheap.

 

We can pay backups a few million... but shelling out a few mill a year for top coordinators seems like an incredibly cost efficient, highly predictable output chances. 

 

Pretty sure we've made Brady a top paid OC. I dont think it's a spending issue. I think it's more a McD needs to be the biggest fish issue. 

 

Brady was specifically the "Passing Game Coordinator" that legendary year at LSU. He ran a pass-happy offense before, and started that way here. But McD wore him down and enforced a run-first, "Complementary" gameplan (aka dont expose the precious defense).

 

We certainly arent going to bring in an experienced DC that runs a different scheme than McD's. No change to a Schwartz/Spags/etc type. Plus those guys could be hired as Interim HC. So aint happening.

[Chaos]

2 hours ago, Chaos said:

The last QB as impactful as Allen to not win a Super Bowl was Dan Marino.  Its a pretty rare situation.  Given his past history the Dolphins were never going to fire Don Shula.  Sean McDermott has not earned the forebearance that Don Shula earned.  In reality this is a unique situation in the history of the NFL. 

To be fair, some might consider the often injured lamar jackson to be just as impactful. 

[DrDawkinstein]

1 minute ago, Chaos said:

To be fair, some might consider the often injured lamar jackson to be just as impactful. 

 

But to your forebearance point, Harbaugh has won a SB (with Joe Flacco at QB, during the Brady/Manning era) and earned a bit more leeway. 

 

The Bills are definitely a very unique situation.

[FireChans]

1 hour ago, MJS said:

If he gets fired, he'll get immediately hired by another organization and turn them into a perennial contender as well.

????

 

Do you think he's a far better coach than Tomlin? Or Bill Belicheck?

 

McD would be great for a crappy organization to become a serious team. But unless he can take Josh Allen with him, he isn't turning any team into a perennial contender.  That's just not how it works.

[nedboy7]

I think everyone will enjoy this....

 

 

[MasterStrategist]

9 minutes ago, HappyDays said:

 

I mostly agree with this. Our passing offense scares me though. In 6 games since the bye week we've only seen the passing offense have 2 good games. It's just hard to imagine winning 3 road games in a row and then the Super Bowl with such an inconsistent passing offense. I guess the optimistic scenario is we get Kincaid and Palmer back healthy and that ends up being enough. We will still have to mostly rely on the run game though and I worry about what will happen when we inevitably get in a playoff matchup where the run isn't successful.

 

Yeah I agree - it will need to be a healthy Kincaid and Palmer.  And our offense/defense clicking at the right time, getting back to winning the turnover battle.

 

Lots of things need to become more "consistent", but with Josh at the helm, I'd take us in any matchup.  We are having issues "stacking" victories right now, this week will be another playoff type game then same at the Pats.

[DrDawkinstein]

Just now, FireChans said:

????

 

Do you think he's a far better coach than Tomlin? Or Bill Belicheck?

 

McD would be great for a crappy organization to become a serious team. But unless he can take Josh Allen with him, he isn't turning any team into a perennial contender.  That's just not how it works.

 

Depends on how you define "perennial contender".

 

I agree with @MJS and others that he'd be hired right away, and could elevate a bottom-dweller. He wouldve been perfect in Carolina the last couple of years. Weakish division. They'd be in the hunt and favored to take that Division every year, therefore a perennial contender.

 

But that doesnt change anything here, and isnt even relevant to our situation and conversation.

 

McD pretty much admits it himself. The signs all over OBD say "Playoff Caliber". He's never changed them to "Championship Caliber" when that is the current goal.

[Generic_Bills_Fan]

12 minutes ago, FireChans said:

????

 

Do you think he's a far better coach than Tomlin? Or Bill Belicheck?

 

McD would be great for a crappy organization to become a serious team. But unless he can take Josh Allen with him, he isn't turning any team into a perennial contender.  That's just not how it works.

I think Bill’s problem is he couldn’t envision a world where he couldn’t be coach and gm.  Very likely would’ve been scooped up again otherwise 

 

Tomlin will get scooped up very fast if he leaves also imo.  With that anonymous report that a veteran hc is lookin for a change of scenery and staring at their first below .500 season in awhile I think that’s probably Tomlin wanting to go to NYG 

 

Edited 3 minutes ago by Generic_Bills_Fan