Yes, if a bunch of "analysists" state that a player should go at 24, and he starts falling, there is generally a reason known to most GM's for that fall. Rodgers is an outlier.
The second part of the argument is that Bean had AJ too high on his board, same with Basham, if he actually took BPA, which I do not believe he did, and rather attacked what he felt were the best "edge" rushers left.
Star was such an abysmal contract. Hopefully Jones can come in and play to his contract. I'd also be fine drafting the 1T from GA if he is still available (depending on who else is available) and just sitting Star if needed.