THE FINAL 53 CHALLENGE: Results are In!!!

[Rocky Landing]

14 minutes ago, Alphadawg7 said:

 

Where are you pulling up the chart I meant?

That's what I want to know, too.

[BuffaloRush]

11 hours ago, Rocky Landing said:

That's what I want to know, too.

 

There really isn’t public place where you can see the current results.  I’m the owner of the form so I can view the results

[blacklabel]

OP - just a heads up, Keenan Robinson retired yesterday so you may want to remove him from the form, just a thought.

 

Maybe add another section for practice squad?

[Hapless Bills Fan]

On 8/22/2018 at 10:51 PM, BuffaloRush said:

Many of us often try to forecast or predict which players will make the Bills final 53 man roster.  It got me thinking -- How cool would it be to have member of TSW predict the 53 man roster before the final roster cuts on September 1?  

 

So here is GUESS THE FINAL 53!

 

I went to the Bills website and created a Google Form where you can select which players make the team and which ones will get cut.   Once the final roster comes out, we'll be able to get an overall score for your submission.  There are 53 players on the team and each correct name will be worth 2 points.  The maximum score will be 106.

 

I will post the Top 10 winners here after the roster comes out on 9/1.    FYI - the only information needed is your TSW username.  No names or emails will be necessary.

 

Hopefully you'll participate in this fun challenge to see who can predict the final 53!

 

CLICK THE LINK BELOW TO GUESS THE 53!!!!

https://goo.gl/forms/nLi1qoGfA2ZlD4aI2

 

I couldn't embed the form in the thread but you can see what it looks like below:

 

We usually get a proliferation of 53-man roster threads.

This seems like a cool tool and way to compare different folks choices, so much so Imma pin it.

 

Is there any way to add a practice squad option for the eligible guys?

 

 

 

[billrooter]

15 hours ago, Rocky Landing said:

I don't think it's a lack of love. It really just comes down to a choice between Streater, and McCloud. And, it's a tough choice! I think many feel that Ray Ray is a little more versatile, he was just drafted, and he had a great showing in preseason. He's also done some return duty in TC I think, right? Slight advantage to Ray Ray.

 

Personally, I put them both on the roster, and am calling Kerley a surprise cut. (Hey man, they happen every year!)

I went with both making it and Kerley also and Holmes being the odd man out myself. I just think Kerley is going to be a good slot guy for the Bills and I myself value that more than Holmes st abilities I guess. 

[clayboy54]

I agree that Holmes may be the odd man out. I think we have to keep Coleman, Kerley and Streater. Ray-Ray has shown enough to be the development guy, replacing Reilly. Benjamin and Zay are locks. I don't think we'll keep 7.

[26CornerBlitz]

Just now, clayboy54 said:

I agree that Holmes may be the odd man out. I think we have to keep Coleman, Kerley and Streater. Ray-Ray has shown enough to be the development guy, replacing Reilly. Benjamin and Zay are locks. I don't think we'll keep 7.

 

Highly unlikely.

[clayboy54]

You may be right, but someone's gotta go and I can't see sneaking Ray-Ray onto the PS.

[26CornerBlitz]

3 minutes ago, clayboy54 said:

You may be right, but someone's gotta go and I can't see sneaking Ray-Ray onto the PS.

 

The top five WRs have been Benjamin, Zay, Kerley, Holmes, and Streater.  Holmes plays in every ST situation and McDermott refers to him as "One of our Leaders".  He'll be on the final 53. 

[Badanswer]

1 hour ago, BuffaloRush said:

 

There really isn’t public place where you can see the current results.  I’m the owner of the form so I can view the results

I like not being able to see final results yet....skews peoples votes...like an election would

[Soda Popinski]

i filled it out 

[TPS]

kudos to those who were brave enough to select prior to the final preseason game.  I'll wait for Sunday's game myself....

[Pine Barrens Mafia]

This is freaking awesome. Entered.

 

[Rico]

On 8/23/2018 at 10:22 AM, BuffaloRush said:

Some interesting results.  We've gotten around 40 entries so far.  Here's what fans think about the WR and TE positions:

Does anyone have Mack on it?

[qwksilver]

I filled it out. However I know it's not perfect as K. Mack was not one of the choices for linebacker.

Edited August 24, 2018 by qwksilver

[Alphadawg7]

1 hour ago, Rocky Landing said:

I don't think it's a lack of love. It really just comes down to a choice between Streater, and McCloud. And, it's a tough choice! I think many feel that Ray Ray is a little more versatile, he was just drafted, and he had a great showing in preseason. He's also done some return duty in TC I think, right? Slight advantage to Ray Ray.

 

Personally, I put them both on the roster, and am calling Kerley a surprise cut. (Hey man, they happen every year!)

 

I think Streater has earned the Week 1 starting spot beside KB, or at the very least #3.  He has outplayed every WR on this roster in camp and preseason not named KB.  Zay and Coleman will get there, but they are behind the other guys having not been here most of camp and preseason and both are new to this offense too.

[GoBills808]

Just FYI wrt linebackers, Keenan Robinson just retired.

[BuffaloRush]

22 hours ago, Rocky Landing said:

That's what I want to know, too.

 

OK so there is an option where you can see the results.  If you click on the link below you can see everyone who voted, as well as the current voting status of who TSW feels is making the team.  Once I assign a grade, I'll close this option.

 

Click the link below to see which players the TSW feels will make the squad:

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfDOhH5UTaVgpSj5Uybw98zTz5CwZrKm98adifeYrRe-hsR8w/viewanalytics

[3rdand12]

some might suggest Allen will need his veterans to play steady and help him along ? Holmes and Streater. Ray Ray to PS and whatever will be will be.

[3rdand12]

WRs are still wide open.

who would we wish to keep on PS ?

 Some say that are bubble players will get swept away by the Patriots lol.
I would not build my roster because i was afraid to stash a fringe player.

 Hard to see Holmes off the roster for a rookie with " potential". Making Special Teams is how to stay on the roster as a new and young WR.

especially if someone has not stood out dramatically by now.

 

To soon to pick.
for me.

 i might have a better opinion come Monday though

21 hours ago, BuffaloRush said:

 

OK so there is an option where you can see the results.  If you click on the link below you can see everyone who voted, as well as the current voting status of who TSW feels is making the team.  Once I assign a grade, I'll close this option.

 

Click the link below to see which players the TSW feels will make the squad:

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfDOhH5UTaVgpSj5Uybw98zTz5CwZrKm98adifeYrRe-hsR8w/viewanalytics

the list looks incomplete

 and who the hell pick Dawkins to not be day one starter ? and why ?

some one cut Kyle Williams. i would like their name and home address please. Like to send a Get well soon card ..