Jump to content

Mike Pettine speculation-interviewing w Cleveland


mannc

Recommended Posts

Oh well, I never thought Pettine was that great anyway. He looks like a football coach with his bald head and fierce scowl, though. His players got some gaudy stats last season at the expense of giving up too many big plays. The better coaches were able to exploit this weakness, and were able to tear apart our defense in many games.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 1.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I once interviewed for a job for 6 months before I actually received an offer. During that time I probably had about 15 interviews with 12 different people. Ultimately I took the job. I don't think it's that unusual. What is unusual is that it's in the public eye and millions of people have a vested interest in this because they are fans.

 

I want Pettine to stay, badly, but I don't think it's a disaster for Buffalo if he leaves.

 

I also believe that Pettine needs to take this opportunity, despite the risks. Other than ownership, I think it's a pretty good situation. He probably believes that in a fairly weak AFC North, he has a chance to take that team and compete for a division title. If he does that, there is no way he gets fired in 1 year.

It isn't unusual at all in the business world. It is in the NFL. That said, usually there is competition for a coach which makes them move more quickly. Not the case here.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oh well, I never thought Pettine was that great anyway. He looks like a football coach with his bald head and fierce scowl, though. His players got some gaudy stats last season at the expense of giving up too many big plays. The better coaches were able to exploit this weakness, and were able to tear apart our defense in many games.

And that was last year. Now they have a whole year of film. I agree with you.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

ProFootballTalk@ProFootballTalk 10m

Packers could block Alex Van Pelt from moving on http://wp.me/p14QSB-9oCz

 

Welp.. looks like Pettine may need to look no further than Turk Schonert for his OC now...

 

Just goes right along with the red carpet treatment he has gotten so far.... clowns.

 

If I am Pettine, I ignore this circus/trainwreck, and just figure that even if he was the 10th choice and these guys are clowns, he's going to prove to everyone that they made the right choice.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If I were Pettine, I would take the Browns job in a heartbeat. Being too good for openings often does not serve the up and coming coordinator well. Look at Brian Schottenheimer. Remember when he was too good to even interview for the Bills opening? Within a couple of years the Jets fired him and he cannot even hope to get an interview.

Edited by Arkady Renko
Link to comment
Share on other sites

This. And I can almost guarantee you, with another solid season under his watch and other teams creating coaching vacancies next year, Pettine will not only be a great candidate, he will get to choose the team he goes to next year. He would be naive (and perhaps a little stupid, since he's pretty much the only candidate who hasn't recognized the toxicity of the Browns situation) to think he won't have a better situation next year.

Absolutely. It seems, if he takes the gig, that Pettine must be more willing than Gase or Quinn to enter a higher-risk/reward scenario. Confidence in one's own self is not a bad thing, but he'll need a lot of luck in a place that hasn't had much. Chud was basically sabotaged by injuries and an already-shaky QB situation. It's hard to say he did a bad job there all things considered. Yet he is now a retread HC in the NFL on the outside looking in. Does Pettine want that risk?

 

The Lions job would have been the one to get this winter. So many good pieces in place already up there and an underachieving team that needed a new culture. The Browns have a lot more work to do despite the high picks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If I am Pettine, I ignore this circus/trainwreck, and just figure that even if he was the 10th choice and these guys are clowns, he's going to prove to everyone that they made the right choice.

Of course that is what he will try to do... unfortunately, the circus/trainwreck pulls all the strings, so he is part of it whether he wants to be or not. But.... cha-ching!

 

If I were Pettine, I would take the Browns job in a heartbeat. Being too good for openings often does not serve the up and coming coordinator well. Look at Brian Schottenheimer. Remember when he was too good to even interview for the Bills opening? Within a couple of years the Jets fired him and he cannot even hope to get an interview.

Adam Gase is 35 and could have been a HC in the NFL. He said, "Nah, I'm good." He, along with the 5 other coordinators who chose not to go there, will be better served by not going there because of the FO and ownership. It is what it is.

 

Absolutely. It seems, if he takes the gig, that Pettine must be more willing than Gase or Quinn to enter a higher-risk/reward scenario. Confidence in one's own self is not a bad thing, but he'll need a lot of luck in a place that hasn't had much. Chud was basically sabotaged by injuries and an already-shaky QB situation. It's hard to say he did a bad job there all things considered. Yet he is now a retread HC in the NFL on the outside looking in. Does Pettine want that risk?

 

The Lions job would have been the one to get this winter. So many good pieces in place already up there and an underachieving team that needed a new culture. The Browns have a lot more work to do despite the high picks.

He was also sabotaged by his own FO, who refused to give him any control over his own personnel and then fired him because of it.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Of course that is what he will try to do... unfortunately, the circus/trainwreck pulls all the strings, so he is part of it whether he wants to be or not. But.... cha-ching!

 

Adam Gase is 35 and could have been a HC in the NFL. He said, "Nah, I'm good." He, along with the 5 other coordinators who chose not to go there, will be better served by not going there because of the FO and ownership. It is what it is.

 

He was also sabotaged by his own FO, who refused to give him any control over his own personnel and then fired him because of it.

Sounds like a great gig. "There are only 32 of these! Sign me up for the dysfunction!"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's official, the Browns wiki page has been update:

 

post-13907-0-94055600-1390487135_thumb.png

 

http://en.wikipedia....leveland_Browns

In January 2014, the "Three Stooges" <ref>http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/eye-on-football/24392157/reporter-asks-browns-owner-haslam-if-team-is-run-by-three-stooges</ref> of the Cleveland Browns held one of the most ridiculous coaching searches in NFL history. Desperately searching for any coaching candidate that would be interested in being the Head Coach of an organization that recently fired a Head Coach after one year, the team held round after round of interviews. Including interviewing their "fall back option" <ref>http://www.ohio.com/blogs/cleveland-browns/cleveland-browns-1.270107/espn-s-adam-schefter-says-browns-may-have-a-curve-ball-coming-in-coaching-search-1.461064</ref>, Mike Pettine, an almost unheard of, three times. This type of lack of leadership and decision making does not bode well for the future of the organization.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I remember when everyone was laughing at Cleveland for trading Richardson a few months ago. I don't know, you add a defensive guy like Pettine, they have the ammo to move up and take whatever QB they want in draft, they have good players on offense and defense. At least they have 8 home games. Not sure, how Bills fans can laugh at anyone right now. Oakland and Jax probably only head coaching job worse than Bills. We were lucky last year to land a guy other teams were actually interested in.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wish Pettine well, but this could end poorly for him if the Browns' FO doesn't rebound.

 

Could be like in Jax, where Mularkey was hired, and then was promptly fired after 1 year because they brought in an entire new FO, which wanted their own guy as HC.

 

And how would he be in a bad position if that happened. He'd be sitting on a bunch of guaranteed money and then when that ran out he'd likely be able to go back to being a DC somewhere. It's a pretty no-lose situation.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

And how would he be in a bad position if that happened. He'd be sitting on a bunch of guaranteed money and then when that ran out he'd likely be able to go back to being a DC somewhere. It's a pretty no-lose situation.

Most coaches don't think that way.

 

I remember when everyone was laughing at Cleveland for trading Richardson a few months ago. I don't know, you add a defensive guy like Pettine, they have the ammo to move up and take whatever QB they want in draft, they have good players on offense and defense. At least they have 8 home games. Not sure, how Bills fans can laugh at anyone right now. Oakland and Jax probably only head coaching job worse than Bills. We were lucky last year to land a guy other teams were actually interested in.

The problem with the Cleveland job, aside from no QB, is not the players.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why?

If you don't understand at this point in time you never will.

 

Pettine will have opportunities to interview for HC next year but if he looks like a desperate puppy with no pride willing to take **** from a screwed up organization his value as a HC and leader goes down.

 

How is going to lead the team as the "Fall Back" Plan Head Coach?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you don't understand at this point in time you never will.

 

Pettine will have opportunities to interview for HC next year but if he looks like a desperate puppy with no pride willing to take **** from a screwed up organization his value as a HC and leader goes down.

 

How is going to lead the team as the "Fall Back" Plan Head Coach?

The leaders on this team have already been quoted as being embarrassed and disappointed about the Chud firing after 1 year, after two other coaches who lasted 2 years apiece. MP will be lucky if they even bother to learn his name at this point...
Link to comment
Share on other sites

And how would he be in a bad position if that happened. He'd be sitting on a bunch of guaranteed money and then when that ran out he'd likely be able to go back to being a DC somewhere. It's a pretty no-lose situation.

Unless perhaps Pettine really wants to be head coach and win games. If you take a job with a dysfunctional franchise and fail miserably its a long wait until you get another shot at HC. You might not ever get another shot.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I remember when everyone was laughing at Cleveland for trading Richardson a few months ago. I don't know, you add a defensive guy like Pettine, they have the ammo to move up and take whatever QB they want in draft, they have good players on offense and defense. At least they have 8 home games. Not sure, how Bills fans can laugh at anyone right now. Oakland and Jax probably only head coaching job worse than Bills. We were lucky last year to land a guy other teams were actually interested in.

 

Keep in mind they have to hold together the roster and I don't expect that to happen. That locker room has been through inconsistent or missing leadership for years and I think firing Chud after 1 year may have been the tipping point.

 

Pettine is inheriting a mess, players do not trust ownership and the FO. Plus, as others have said on here, it's not like Pettine has some awesome resume. I too wonder if he'll be any good as a HC considering the better teams were able to run holes in his defense with no answer/adjustment. It's not all bad he's leaving, if we get Wade back I will view the entire situation as a positive outcome.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...