Tush Push vote failed. Still a thing

[SoCal Deek]

What’s the problem with this play? I see nothing wrong with it. 

[zow2]

The Tush Push is a football play.  It's weird that it would be banned to be honest.  The Bills used it successfully more often than not.  If there were crack back blocks and leg whips, etc.. going on I can see it being banned.  But it's just large men pushing other large men to advance the football.  That's a football play.

[ChronicAndKnuckles]

18 minutes ago, eball said:

 

A player should not receive assistance from a teammate to gain yardage -- PERIOD.  It's a stupid play and should have never been allowed.

 

Oh, you mean like blocking ? 

[SoCal Deek]

What’s next….the forward pass? Outrageous, I tell ya! 

[eball]

5 minutes ago, ChronicAndKnuckles said:

Oh, you mean like blocking ? 

 

I think you know exactly what I mean.

 

[T.E.]

58 minutes ago, Walking Tall said:

Hopefully the Bills start running this play with Knox or Kincaid under center. 

That sounds like a catastrophic mistake waiting to happen. We can't even do it efficiently with a QB who weighs 250 lbs.

[JerseyBills]

46 minutes ago, Alphadawg7 said:

I think it should stay.  Just because one team does it better than anyone else isn't a reason to get rid of it.  

 

Funniest part is the pushing of the tush isn't even the key to its success and is mostly irrelevant to whether the play succeeds or not.  Its what happens up front and what your QB does that determines if its likely to succeed or not, and THAT is what the Eagles are better than everyone else at.  

Bills are easily 2nd best at it. Ppl just remember the KC game, other than that it has been automatic these last 2 years

[bmur66]

What is this? Freakin rugby?

[Shortchaz]

2 minutes ago, bmur66 said:

What is this? Freakin rugby?

I mean, it is the essence of football 

[dickleyjones]

I have no idea why it would be banned. Seems like football at its most basic.

[SoMAn]

46 minutes ago, eball said:

 

A player should not receive assistance (pulling or pushing) from a teammate to gain yardage -- PERIOD.  It's a stupid play and should have never been allowed.

 

As a purist and traditionalist, I agree.

But, it is what it is, and when it comes right down to it, it's ours against theirs, as it is with every sub-unit on each side of the ball.

If a team wants to use a pile of humanity advancing the ball forward, the other side will just have to have a bigger and stronger pile of humanity in order to defend it. 

When the day comes that high profile QB gets seriously injured (costing the NFL ratings and $$), that will be the time the league will consider banning it. Money is the thrust behind most league decisions. 

Before the tush push, Tom Brady's scrawny little arse used to just get low and under the center when he needed less than a foot. He must've had the timing down perfectly because his win percentage was incredible with that move. 

[FloridaSnow]

33 minutes ago, JerseyBills said:

Bills are easily 2nd best at it. Ppl just remember the KC game, other than that it has been automatic these last 2 years

Was it as simple as the side we went to being too predictable? I’m still astonished by how effectively they stopped that. 

[oldmanfan]

Don’t like it.  If I want to watch rugby I’ll watch rugby.

[Low Positive]

No need to ban the play. Just tell the refs to call the false start that happens EVERY TIME the Eagles run that play. Problem solved.

[JerseyBills]

18 minutes ago, FloridaSnow said:

Was it as simple as the side we went to being too predictable? I’m still astonished by how effectively they stopped that. 

Good question,  I really don't know, but still looked like Josh got it on that 4th down , which totally changes the game 

 

But ya I was shocked as well, really good preparation by Spags, nobody stopped us like that. Assuming they gave us some unique looks, that was very impressive 

Edited 6 hours ago by JerseyBills

[JohnBonhamRocks]

I dunno, maybe figure out how to stop it instead of complaining. 

[GerstAusGosheim]

2 hours ago, Walking Tall said:

Hopefully the Bills start running this play with Knox or Kincaid under center. 

 

Nah instead let's keep running Josh over the left guard for the 5th year in a row. It's not predictable at all.

[dave mcbride]

Does the play remaining legal help the Bills? Of course it does. The Bills are only second to the Eagles in using it, and are almost as effective as them at the play. It gives the Bills an advantage, so I am all for keeping it.

 

The reason people want it banned isn't because it's not a football play or leads to more injuries (it doesn't); it's because it's basically unstoppable if you have the personnel. A play should be able to be schemed against, and the Eagles' version of the play is basically unschemable, defensively. It can't be stopped. That's why it's problematic. There should always be a defensive answer to a particular type of play. 

Edited 5 hours ago by dave mcbride

[Walking Tall]

1 hour ago, T.E. said:

That sounds like a catastrophic mistake waiting to happen. We can't even do it efficiently with a QB who weighs 250 lbs.

No, it really doesn’t. 

[Jalan81]

1 hour ago, Conlan58 said:

It is in fact a football play. 11 players on offense line up against 11 players on defense. Offense snaps the ball and defense tries to stop the play. 

 

It's on the defensive coordinators to figure out a way to stop it. Remember the wildcat? That was unstoppable until defensive coordinators figured out a way to stop it. 

 

Hell, the Chiefs stuffed our attempts multiple times. I don't think it will last much longer as defenses start to finally figure it out. 

The Chiefs stop ours when we were too dumb to actually push the Qb. Also Chris Jones was not only in the neutral zone, he move early on at least one of his stops which was ignored by the officiating.