Was going to post something similar.
The way our defense has let us down in the playoffs essentially requires josh to play perfectly.
I believe there are aspects of Josh’s game he could improve but it’s way down the list of things the team could/should/need (to) improve.
If you follow the reasoning behind the criticism of josh it leads to criticism of McDermott. his defensive philosophy falls apart in the playoffs, or at least there are other teams that do a much better job on that side of the ball in the playoffs.