Beane reportedly looking for LB help (possible rumor)

[SectionC3]

26 minutes ago, Bleeding Bills Blue said:

 

I thought he played fine.  Rapp on the other hand... woof.  

 

I assume we'll have benford and white.  I do think its a need come draft time, but i'd like to avoid spending a 1st round pick there.  I think with our surplus of picks we can probably grab one somewhere in the draft though.  

 

WR2 - Davis UFA

CB3 - Jackson UFA

1T - Jones UFA, everyone else gone

3T - Phillips gone

S - Hyde gone

OT - Push Brown

DE - AJE free agent, same with Floyd

Did you see him get cooked by the back about -20-ish YL on the tunnel side?  It was ugly.  He ain’t it. 

[BillsFanForever19]

6 hours ago, SectionC3 said:

After last night I’m on the “try to trade for Pat Surtain” and “find a modest upgrade for Tyrell Dodson” trains.  Dodson is brutal.  

 

Patrick Surtain II is a popular name amongst fans for a trade. But they aren't going to trade him. It's been said he's 1 of the, if not THE, core player they want to build around in a rebuild.

 

It makes sense. No team sells off all of their parts in a rebuild. You need a core. They spent a top 10 pick on him just 2 years ago. 

 

And if he were available, the cost of a 23 year old, Top 10 Pick, Cornerback, with a clean bill of health, with 2 and a half years left on a Rookie contract, and who was a 1st Team All Pro just last season - would be MASSIVE. Probably multiple 1st Round picks. 

Edited October 27, 2023 by BillsFanForever19

[SCBills]

1 minute ago, BillsFanForever19 said:

 

Patrick Surtain II is a popular name amongst fans for a trade. But they aren't going to trade him. It's been said he's 1 of the, if not THE, core player they want to build around in a rebuild.

 

It makes sense. No team sells off all of their parts in a rebuild. You need a core. They spent a top 10 pick on him just 2 years ago. 

 

And if he were available, the cost of a 23 year old, Top 10 Pick, Cornerback, with 2 and a half years left on a Rookie contract, who was a 1st Team All Pro just last season - would be MASSIVE. Probably multiple 1st Round picks. 

IF he were available.. I don’t know that it would be completely out of the question for this front office to put a trade offer out there. 
 

It would likely be the admission that Tre White’s career in Buffalo is over.  Instead of drafting a RD1 CB in the next two years (we saw how that turned out with Elam) I don’t know that it would be crazy to send this years and next years RD1 picks to them for them Surtain.  Maybe Elam is included. 
 

Not sure I’d love that, as it seems McDermott can find/scheme/coach up guys like Jackson and Benford, but I could see them viewing Surtain as a piece worth trading multiple 1sts for, given where we should be drafting. 
 

Future young core of the Defense becomes Oliver, Rousseau, Bernard, Benford and Surtain. 
 

Offense returns a lot next year with the only conversations really to be had about C and WR2.  Defense will likely have a good bit of retooling. 

[Warriorspikes51]

Klein should be in for run defense and blitzing.  He would have gotten to Mayfield multiple times when they used Dodson for that

[CNYfan]

Rapp is scary bad.  

 

Then he tries to overcompensate for being scary bad by engaging in late hits and unnecessary roughness events.

[BillsFanForever19]

1 hour ago, SCBills said:

IF he were available.. I don’t know that it would be completely out of the question for this front office to put a trade offer out there. 
 

It would likely be the admission that Tre White’s career in Buffalo is over.  Instead of drafting a RD1 CB in the next two years (we saw how that turned out with Elam) I don’t know that it would be crazy to send this years and next years RD1 picks to them for them Surtain.  Maybe Elam is included. 
 

Not sure I’d love that, as it seems McDermott can find/scheme/coach up guys like Jackson and Benford, but I could see them viewing Surtain as a piece worth trading multiple 1sts for, given where we should be drafting. 
 

Future young core of the Defense becomes Oliver, Rousseau, Bernard, Benford and Surtain. 
 

Offense returns a lot next year with the only conversations really to be had about C and WR2.  Defense will likely have a good bit of retooling. 

 

Just came across this article where it's said the asking price is 2 1st Round Picks PLUS a Pro Bowl Calibur Player "just to get the conversation started":

 

https://www.si.com/nfl/cowboys/news/patrick-surtain-trade-rumor-dallas-cowboys-outrageous-asking-price-broncos-cost-deadline

 

As much as what you're saying makes sense that with Elam failing and Tre most likely not coming back, we'll need to address CB - that price is just WAY too much for one player. 

Especially when you consider our cap situation of 33 million over and the amount of other positions we need to upgrade and/or replace with the amount of FA's we have next season.

 

It's more than just C and WR2. Miller and Rousseau are the only DE's we have under contract next season. Oliver is the ONLY DT we have under contract. Cook is our only RB. Poyer (who may need to be replaced himself) and Hamlin our only Safeties. And there's still other depth players that will need to be re-signed/replaced on top of those (and that doesn't take into account upgrades as well).

 

Not to mention, we'd also have to replace the "Pro Bowl Calibur" player we'd need to package with the picks on top of it.

 

We can't afford to give up our 1st Rounder next year. Let alone also the following year AND a stud player on top of that. We just can't.

Edited October 27, 2023 by BillsFanForever19

[RichRiderBills]

We don't need Surtain ...just get a solid zone corner. 

 

 

[ExiledInIllinois]

Miss me yet?

😆 

No! 😏 

 

 

[BillsFanForever19]

4 minutes ago, RichRiderBills said:

We don't need Surtain ...just get a solid zone corner. 

 

Agreed. Definitely want another solid player opposite Benford. But not at the price it would take to get Surtain. 

[Floydboy12]

I’d prefer they try to unload some unwanted contracts if humanly possible and acquire some picks. It’s not happening for the Bills this year. Much of it due to injury, but they’ve looked like a contending type team in exactly one game this year. It’s tough to swallow, but best for the organization. 

[Aussie Joe]

1 minute ago, Floydboy12 said:

I’d prefer they try to unload some unwanted contracts if humanly possible and acquire some picks. It’s not happening for the Bills this year. Much of it due to injury, but they’ve looked like a contending type team in exactly one game this year. It’s tough to swallow, but best for the organization. 

Whilst I wouldn’t exactly say I’m overconfident about their Championship prospects this season .. I would expect at 5-3 that they are buyers … not sellers …

[Floydboy12]

1 minute ago, Aussie Joe said:

Whilst I wouldn’t exactly say I’m overconfident about their Championship prospects this season .. I would expect at 5-3 that they are buyers … not sellers …

Oh I agree that they probably are. Just don’t think that will be for the best in the future. 

[Bleeding Bills Blue]

33 minutes ago, CNYfan said:

Rapp is scary bad.  

 

Then he tries to overcompensate for being scary bad by engaging in late hits and unnecessary roughness events.

 

Yeah - he'd probably be alright playing... actual safety.  But when they bring him in for the dime packages i'm holding my breath.  I'd rather see Neal tbh.  

[thenorthremembers]

7 minutes ago, Floydboy12 said:

I’d prefer they try to unload some unwanted contracts if humanly possible and acquire some picks. It’s not happening for the Bills this year. Much of it due to injury, but they’ve looked like a contending type team in exactly one game this year. It’s tough to swallow, but best for the organization. 

The only way you sell at the trade deadline at 5-3 is if you dont have a franchise QB.   Teams with franchise QBs are in it until they are legitimately eliminated from playoff contention.  The Bills would look like total idiots to be moving any players of substance right now.   If they want to move Kaiir Elam, be my guest, but they shouldnt be trimming salary for draft hopes.

Edited October 27, 2023 by thenorthremembers

[Bleeding Bills Blue]

6 minutes ago, Floydboy12 said:

I’d prefer they try to unload some unwanted contracts if humanly possible and acquire some picks. It’s not happening for the Bills this year. Much of it due to injury, but they’ve looked like a contending type team in exactly one game this year. It’s tough to swallow, but best for the organization. 

 

We currently have 11 draft picks, including an extra 3, an extra 5, and 2 extra 6s.  

2 minutes ago, thenorthremembers said:

The only way you sell at the trade deadline at 5-3 is if you dont have a franchise QB.   Teams with franchise QBs are in it until they are legitimately eliminated from playoff contention.  The Bills would look like total idiots to be moving any players of substance right now.   If they want to move Kaiir Elam, be my guest, but they shouldnt be trimming salary for draft hopes.

 

I don't see much of a point cutting elam.  No one on the PS is better, there are like no cap savings cutting or trading him, plus you then lose money replacing him.  

[Floydboy12]

25 minutes ago, Bleeding Bills Blue said:

 

We currently have 11 draft picks, including an extra 3, an extra 5, and 2 extra 6s.  

 

I don't see much of a point cutting elam.  No one on the PS is better, there are like no cap savings cutting or trading him, plus you then lose money replacing him.  

You need all the ammunition you can get to move around for players you like in draft and in season. Personally I’d at least test the waters in what I could get for players like Dawkins, Poyer, Miller etc. This is not a contending football team. It’s just not. 

[Solomon Grundy]

1 hour ago, RichRiderBills said:

We don't need Surtain ...just get a solid zone corner. 

 

 

So McDermott could sit him on the bench? I'd highly doubt that if the Bills acquired a top notch CB, that McDermott would sit either Jackson or Benford.

[BillsFanForever19]

53 minutes ago, Floydboy12 said:

I’d prefer they try to unload some unwanted contracts if humanly possible and acquire some picks. It’s not happening for the Bills this year. Much of it due to injury, but they’ve looked like a contending type team in exactly one game this year. It’s tough to swallow, but best for the organization. 

 

You're looking at things from a Bills fan point of view of "Super Bowl Title or Bust". And while logically, there is some sense to be made that the Defensive injuries and some of our inadequacies combined don't pass the eye test for a Super Bowl champion team - that's simply not how a Front Office looks at things. Front offices don't say "well, right now this doesn't look like a team that can hoist the Lombardi, so pack it in".

 

The fact is we're 5-3 and still competing. Anything can happen in the NFL. Josh could get White Hot when it matters and overcome things. Players could step up and play at a level we hadn't imagined. Other teams along the way could become just as injury riddled. You never know in the NFL.

 

And our unwanted contracts? Why would they be wanted by other teams? Bad deals like Dawson Knox, Jordan Poyer, or Poona Ford - teams aren't going to take those unwanted contracts off of our hands and on themselves AND give us compensation for the privilege of doing so.

 

Kaiir Elam is the only player I could see yielding some kind of return as he was a 1st Round Pick just last year and is a bad fit in a Zone scheme Defense - but could work out in a change of scenery. 

Edited October 27, 2023 by BillsFanForever19

[Logic]

41 minutes ago, Floydboy12 said:

I’d prefer they try to unload some unwanted contracts if humanly possible and acquire some picks. It’s not happening for the Bills this year. Much of it due to injury, but they’ve looked like a contending type team in exactly one game this year. It’s tough to swallow, but best for the organization. 

You can't make this stuff up.

Someone actually posted this. In real life. 

Incredible.

[Warriorspikes51]

Poyer is essentially being moved to LB it looks like