RD 5, Pick 150: WR Justin Shorter, Florida

[stevestojan]

25 pages for a 5th round pick. Man I love it here. 
 

 

go bills. 

[Augie]

2 hours ago, stevewin said:

I saw Adrian Dantley play as a rookie for the Braves - and he was great  

 

I was probably there! We split season tickets with another family back then. Great memories. I loved the NBA back then I don’t even watch the Finals now. 

 

.

Edited May 3, 2023 by Augie

[Buffalo716]

7 minutes ago, Shaw66 said:

I know.  That's the point.   

 

Think about what people are saying about this guy.   He has a lot of characteristics of great receivers - size, speed, hands.   My point was that the talk here is as though Shorter could become a true star receiver, and I agree that he has many of the characteristics, but imagining him becoming that great is the mirror image of imagining FItzgerald lasting to the fifth round.   I don't see it.  He may have a future in the league, maybe even a long future, because there's always an occasional star who appears out of the late rounds.  Much more likely that he proves to be useful for a few years and then gets replaced.    

 

Think about Shakir.   Maybe, maybe, he's a ten-year player in the league.  That would be nice.   More likely that he plays five, has some pretty effective seasons, then gets replaced by another fifth round guy.  

I understand and agree

[MrEpsYtown]

13 minutes ago, Shaw66 said:

I know.  That's the point.   

 

Think about what people are saying about this guy.   He has a lot of characteristics of great receivers - size, speed, hands.   My point was that the talk here is as though Shorter could become a true star receiver, and I agree that he has many of the characteristics, but imagining him becoming that great is the mirror image of imagining FItzgerald lasting to the fifth round.   I don't see it.  He may have a future in the league, maybe even a long future, because there's always an occasional star who appears out of the late rounds.  Much more likely that he proves to be useful for a few years and then gets replaced.    

 

Think about Shakir.   Maybe, maybe, he's a ten-year player in the league.  That would be nice.   More likely that he plays five, has some pretty effective seasons, then gets replaced by another fifth round guy.  

For me it is the 5 star recruit thing, combined with the measurables, plus the inconsistent coaching he got at Florida. There just seems to be more there. I don’t think this is the run of the mill type of fifth rounder. 
 

Diggs’ story is similar, though he is obviously not the same type of receiver size wise and style. But he was a 5 star recruit, winds up in a very up and down situation at Maryland, deals with injuries and just has a really inconsistent career. Goes in the 5th despite a strong combine. 
 

I am not saying Shorter is going to be Diggs, but there is more to the story with Shorter and that’s why he is so interesting to me. 

[Shaw66]

9 minutes ago, MrEpsYtown said:

For me it is the 5 star recruit thing, combined with the measurables, plus the inconsistent coaching he got at Florida. There just seems to be more there. I don’t think this is the run of the mill type of fifth rounder. 
 

Diggs’ story is similar, though he is obviously not the same type of receiver size wise and style. But he was a 5 star recruit, winds up in a very up and down situation at Maryland, deals with injuries and just has a really inconsistent career. Goes in the 5th despite a strong combine. 
 

I am not saying Shorter is going to be Diggs, but there is more to the story with Shorter and that’s why he is so interesting to me. 

Interesting.  I enjoyed this and comments others have made.  

 

Frankly, what I like is that he apparently can play special teams.  If so, he makes the roster without pressure to step into a significant role on the offense.  Give him a year to learn the job.   

 

Whatever.  He's intriguing.  

 

Meanwhile - what's the deal with a three-year deal for Shavers?

[Patrick Duffy]

27 minutes ago, Shaw66 said:

Interesting.  I enjoyed this and comments others have made.  

 

Frankly, what I like is that he apparently can play special teams.  If so, he makes the roster without pressure to step into a significant role on the offense.  Give him a year to learn the job.   

 

Whatever.  He's intriguing.  

 

Meanwhile - what's the deal with a three-year deal for Shavers?

 

Agreed, just to say you're likely correct ST would increase his chances a lot to make the roster, while he may not have  "significant" role on offense for the most part, at some point in the season he will get some opportunities due to injury etc. I assume he may feel a little pressure but hope he handles it well

[MrEpsYtown]

1 hour ago, Shaw66 said:

Interesting.  I enjoyed this and comments others have made.  

 

Frankly, what I like is that he apparently can play special teams.  If so, he makes the roster without pressure to step into a significant role on the offense.  Give him a year to learn the job.   

 

Whatever.  He's intriguing.  

 

Meanwhile - what's the deal with a three-year deal for Shavers?

I think most UDFA deals are for three years. I may be mistaken. 

[Buffalo716]

1 hour ago, Shaw66 said:

Interesting.  I enjoyed this and comments others have made.  

 

Frankly, what I like is that he apparently can play special teams.  If so, he makes the roster without pressure to step into a significant role on the offense.  Give him a year to learn the job.   

 

Whatever.  He's intriguing.  

 

Meanwhile - what's the deal with a three-year deal for Shavers?

All UDFA who’s sign and make the team are given 3 year deals 

 

getting cut and placed on PS nullifies it 

11 minutes ago, MrEpsYtown said:

I think most UDFA deals are for three years. I may be mistaken. 

You are correct … all UDFAs who make a roster have a 3 year deal 

 

getting cut and going to PS nullifies it

[Shaw66]

1 minute ago, Buffalo716 said:

All UDFA who’s sign and make the team are given 3 year deals 

 

getting cut and placed on PS nullifies it 

You are correct … all UDFAs who make a roster have a 3 year deal 

 

getting cut and going to PS nullifies it

Thanks.  Obviously, I didn't know that.  

[BADOLBILZ]

18 minutes ago, MrEpsYtown said:

For me it is the 5 star recruit thing, combined with the measurables, plus the inconsistent coaching he got at Florida. There just seems to be more there. I don’t think this is the run of the mill type of fifth rounder. 
 

Diggs’ story is similar, though he is obviously not the same type of receiver size wise and style. But he was a 5 star recruit, winds up in a very up and down situation at Maryland, deals with injuries and just has a really inconsistent career. Goes in the 5th despite a strong combine. 
 

I am not saying Shorter is going to be Diggs, but there is more to the story with Shorter and that’s why he is so interesting to me. 

 

 

Diggs did have a pretty great true freshman year, though.    I'm really not sure what to make of Shorter never having a good season.   Seems likely there has been a comparable player who has panned out but I can't think of one. 

[Ralonzo]

2 hours ago, Shaw66 said:

I've been waiting for an "Adrian who?"

 

A few of us have Gar Heard of him

[Sierra Foothills]

1 minute ago, Ralonzo said:

A few of us have Gar Heard of him

 

That is Mac-Atrue!

 

[Buffalo716]

5 minutes ago, Shaw66 said:

Thanks.  Obviously, I didn't know that.  

Yea but most UDFAs are released and brought back to PS so given 1 year deals and a futures contract in the off-season 

 

this kid has a legit shot and maybe they wanted the 3 years to be known … because they expect him to make the 52

[stevewin]

4 hours ago, Augie said:

 

I was probably there! We split season tickets with another family back then. Great memories. I loved the NBA back then I don’t even watch the Finals now. 

 

.

We cut coupons off milk cartons and sat in the Orange .  God I loved the Braves

[Shaw66]

12 hours ago, Sierra Foothills said:

 

That is Mac-Atrue!

 

Gar Heard and Mac-Atrue.   Love it!  Thanks.  

 

I had left Buffalo by the time the Braves arrived, so I never followed them all that closely.  Until just now, I'd forgotten that Dantley played there.   

 

Every time I'm reminded of McAdoo, I'm amazed that a player could have been THAT far ahead of his time.   I mean, Iverson would have been incredible in the 2023 NBA, but he was only 20 years ago.   McAdoo was 50 years ago!!!  He'd be as great today as he was then. 

[OldTimer1960]

7 minutes ago, Shaw66 said:

Gar Heard and Mac-Atrue.   Love it!  Thanks.  

 

I had left Buffalo by the time the Braves arrived, so I never followed them all that closely.  Until just now, I'd forgotten that Dantley played there.   

 

Every time I'm reminded of McAdoo, I'm amazed that a player could have been THAT far ahead of his time.   I mean, Iverson would have been incredible in the 2023 NBA, but he was only 20 years ago.   McAdoo was 50 years ago!!!  He'd be as great today as he was then. 

Where is the Ernie D. love?  He was such a great passer.

[Dr. Who]

5 minutes ago, OldTimer1960 said:

Where is the Ernie D. love?  He was such a great passer.

It's rather difficult to make a pun out of DiGregorio.

[Shaw66]

4 minutes ago, Dr. Who said:

It's rather difficult to make a pun out of DiGregorio.

I tried for about five seconds and gave up.   

 

Ernie was just SO slow.  He was perfect in the college game, but he couldn't play very long with the NBA talent.  It was too bad, because he was a magician.  

[Ralonzo]

11 hours ago, stevewin said:

We cut coupons off milk cartons and sat in the Orange .  God I loved the Braves

 

Did you catch either of Moses Malone's games?

[Prospector]

13 hours ago, BADOLBILZ said:

 

 

Diggs did have a pretty great true freshman year, though.    I'm really not sure what to make of Shorter never having a good season.   Seems likely there has been a comparable player who has panned out but I can't think of one. 

Dawson Knox