
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch
Community Member-
Posts
9,927 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Gallery
Profiles
Forums
Events
Everything posted by Ed_Formerly_of_Roch
-
I'm not a big fan of ex QB as OC's when they have a great QB as think they see themselves in the QB's eyes and think to themselves, if I had his talent, I'd have been a star and try to get to cute in game planning and show what could do.
-
Projecting the 53 man roster
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to GASabresIUFan's topic in The Stadium Wall
But then can the come back after 4 or is it 6 weeks. Prior you could go right to IR, but if you're not first named to the 53, but say next wek put on IR, you're done for the year. -
Projecting the 53 man roster
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to GASabresIUFan's topic in The Stadium Wall
So most years, there's always a vet player or two not subject to waivers that is cut with the intent to bring back and allow someone else to be moved to the recallable IR list. With the team getting younger this year, how many of those guys to we have left that are eligible. One name I can think of is Ferguson. As has been pointed out prior, the Bills have always kept 5 LB's so can't see them going with 4 at that group. -
Bass struggling at minicamp (and now at training camp)
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to Einstein's topic in The Stadium Wall
A long time ago, but don't forget Anderson. That's probably the biggest blunder, but can understand how it happens. Bass certainly struggled last year and was up and down a couple times, but more down the up. Actually I blame it all on Jim Nantz. Bass started the year off 9 of 9, Nantz announced that as he went for his 10th kick, missed it and was down hill from there. Prior to last year though he was very good and everyone here was praising him and talking about how lucky we were to have him. -
Yeah but the problem there is when a RB is on the field in passing situations, maybe 1/2 the time he goes out on a pass pattern, the other half, he's used for blocking and do you want to trust a rookie to pick up blitzes? That was one area Cook did seem to improve on in his 2nd year as a blocker as likely may even be better yet this year.
-
Dark Horse Candidates and Surprise Cuts
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to Rocky Landing's topic in The Stadium Wall
My dark horse candidate since April has been Frank Gore Jr and I'll stick with it. -
Kim Pegula is Attending Practice Today
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to Slippery Rubber Mats's topic in The Stadium Wall
That fact that Terry had her ruled in incapacitated and he is now her guardian doesn't bode well for the likelihood much improvement IMO. Like JP51 stated, there may be some improvement, but probably not substantial. -
QB2 is a problem and has been ignored for years
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to Milanos Milano's topic in The Stadium Wall
Do you realize that back up QB's get on average about 6 snaps a week with the 1st string. I don't care how good or bad you think Mitch is, a rookie getting that little work would be a downgrade from Mitch for quite some time. Simple solution, give the backup more snaps, yeas at the expense of less work for the 1st team. 30 years ago this could work as there were little rules limiting the amount of practice time, but not today with all the rules in place regarding practice time. By the time the guy may get to be decent if ever, he'll likely be at the end of his contract and not likely he-d have any interest in resigning wit ha team where he knows the only way he's going to ever see the field is either to hand off in mop up games or if Allen were to get hurt. -
Kim Pegula is Attending Practice Today
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to Slippery Rubber Mats's topic in The Stadium Wall
I read that about during Wednesdays practice she was in a car, not sure about today?? -
that the offense wasn't going to largely center around him so he became a distraction more than he was worth. He likely would have lasted one more year based on his contract, but think things reached a level sooner than they expected so decided to bite the bullet and get rid of him now with the goal of becoming younger and felt it was worth taking the bigger cap hit this year, but giving them more flexibility in 2025 than they'd have had if they kept him another year.
-
The Quality of Our Opinions
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to hondo in seattle's topic in The Stadium Wall
While many here will likely disagree with my opinion, but I would also add to your list, for the most part local beat reporters. They have direct access to the players, coaches, and front office that none of us do. They also likely are privy to many off the record conversations. A reporter may talk to Beane off the record and he'll state "we're considering doing X" It may then be reported in an off hand way by the reporter "I wouldn't be surprised if X happens" and everyone here jumps on the reporter as what does he know, especially if they don't like the message. He's not going to quote Beane, but he does have inside information on this. National writers with a few exceptions, they more are often reading tea leaves form afar. -
Who is your surprise cut this year?
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to BuffaloBill's topic in The Stadium Wall
That's not my point. My point is teams are good at gauging what another team will pay for player. So they either need to sign him for an "absurd" amount or they may lose him. You either pay what other teams are willing to pay or lose the player. There's also the other side of this, in the past there were players who were FA and Beane waited them out until was able to sign him for what the Bills and other felt he was worth. They waited until he came down to their level and were able to do that without fear of losing him as others also didn't value him any higher. -
Who is your surprise cut this year?
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to BuffaloBill's topic in The Stadium Wall
The problem there is likely if the Bills didn't give him that some other team would have. One thing I think the Bills and most NFL teams are very good (unlike many poster here) is gauging a players worth and knowing how much to pay someone if they want that player, whether it be re-signing their own or signing a FA, they know what to offer as do most teams. -
Who is your surprise cut this year?
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to BuffaloBill's topic in The Stadium Wall
I'll go with this direction. I was going to post with instead of a surprise cut, was going to go with a surprise of who makes the team and my pick was going going to be Frank Gore Jr. And likely for him to make the roster, Johnson would become a prime cut candidate. $2.25Mil isn't a huge deal in the NFL so that amount hardly guarantees he makes the roster over someone who outplays him. Good chance MVS is on the team, but doubtful it's because of the contract. -
Cameron Sutton Gets Slap on Wrist by Goodell
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to NoHuddleKelly12's topic in The Stadium Wall
That's one of the issues. It's much easier to prove gambling as there are often solid proof. Receipts can't recant or be payed off for silence. Like it or not, gambling also can impact the integrity of the game and potentially the players teammates where with cases involving violence, it's about one person only. As someone else posted, we still all watch the games so add to that. -
MVS working out with Aaron Rodgers
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to Commish's topic in The Stadium Wall
Rogers does think he's the GM of the Jets. Based on that I'd argue this is tampering and we should be awarded the Jets' 1st round pick in next years draft! -
Brandon Beane’s Tenure by Letter Grade—Poll is Up!
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to NoHuddleKelly12's topic in The Stadium Wall
How can he be one of the best or top 5 when the scale being given says a B means he is NOT one of the top 10. Sorry kind of picking on you guys when my complaint is more about the OP's scale. Think there's way to much of a gap between the A and B ranking. Maybe B would be better if it said he's not one of the top 5, but when say he's not even top 10 make him more average and what should be more like a C grade. -
Do think Beane will make any trades before week 1?
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to Alphadawg7's topic in The Stadium Wall
Realistically who could they trade for that A) is available, B) is a clear step up from what they have now C) they can afford the contract? D) doesn't hurt them either on the field on financially beyond this coming season Think the list gets pretty small if anyone. A guy like Allen makes all the WR's look better than they are. Add in Kincaid at TE and this team is stronger than you'd think. The team looked pretty strong the last month of the season with Diggs doing pretty much nothing. Only 5 QB's had more completions than Allen and only 4 more yards. Is not like if the team had Hopkins last year like many folks wanted Allen would have thrown another 1000 yards. It would mostly mean that others would have less yards instead. -
Josh Working With WR’s Beyond OTAs/Camp
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to Warriorspikes51's topic in The Stadium Wall
That certainly is true of Brady, was it also true with Manning? Don't recall all the talk about him in the same way it's been of Brady WRT working out, off season, etc. -
To me the key is longevity, winning multiply times with same team so do agree with the Oilers In the "modern era" of sports I'd go with Steelers of late 70's as they won 4 superbowls with most of the same roster. Reds of the 70's were pretty good to with a real all star roster. Bulls were on top for close to 10 years so they have to be one of the best ever too. Kept a good part of the roster together too over that span. Even though they never won it, do have to consider the Bills as the best roster ever for a team that never won a championship.