NoSaint

Do we actually know that fisher is an effective perimeter player, or can block well at his new weight? Seems they want to add a solid one between Sweeney, this visit and fisher. Whether they think they have one is up for debate.

By fine enough I mean with Kromer as coach and a good RG and smart qb fans wouldn’t have any noteworthy complaints but likewise aren’t buying mills jerseys. He wouldn’t be a topic of conversation good or bad, but might get the occasional mention as a spot to upgrade in the draft.

You put mills with a good coach, RG and an and he will look fine enough. Not good but serviceable. You pair him with a terrible coach, RG and erratic Qb play and he quickly looks terrible. He’s run of the mill filler quality play that will swing from non-eventful to bad depending on his situation.

Always good when “the media” includes everyone’s opinion at any given moment during a fluid situation like a negotiation

I don’t know Roberts skill set well enough I guess. Any insight into why he’d be good I’m space on returns but not screens/reverses?

Ultimately he’s competing with a tackle moving to TE. Having a low risk FA and 7th round pick battle for a goal line package role is fine by me. Neither are going to be game changers but likely at least one will be able to do a small job decently for very cheap.

I think you see him get something like 5 years 140-something. About 60 guaranteed and a good bit of that signing bonus. Can escape without future guaranteed dollars after 2 years, dead money much better after 3 and the final 2 end up ok value by the time you get to them and another round of guys has signed new deals

And yet, you’ll see a thread full of people celebrating his vision

I’ll refer back to my comment last week that beane seems to be excellent at telling bills fans what they like to hear. Regardless what I think of his work as GM (mixed) he is a pro at branding this rebuild and this helps feed a lot of fans dislike if the media and us against them feeling. I think he is quite alright playing the guy that “gets it” for the fan base. I don’t think he’s miffed as much as he plays off it to his own advantage.

On some level, it feels like if he’s working s program and was gone a full year I’d think the Nfl should consider it largely time served....

Pride.

Define issues? I don’t think mine overlap his much and I might appreciate a separate category

Ultimately, you’ve never seen him play tight end... but apparently after working him out they are at least curious.

Melt downs at funerals worry me less than ones at the gym, for instance. I’m pretty sure he was down to leave the facility with the guys head for spying on him

I’d be curious the analysis of how strong of a playcall that back corner fade is and how big a difference 5’11 vs 6’2 is when calling it. I suspect that it’s not as high quality a play as various play action and rub route type options and that the actual height only effects a very small number of incredibly tight throws. the other dynamic the last 30 years is how dynamic tight ends have become as big bodied WRs if dying to have that option in a pinch i could be wrong but my gut is that it’s a spot that’s gotten a little mythical in its reputation

It’s always been a phrase that rubbed me funny even when I’ve used it... isn’t a ref deciding not to enforce the rules injecting himself into the outcome of the game just as much

TLdr cliff notes: I have obscure interests and am upset others don’t like them

What real difference does it make to him at this point? It’s not like he’s suddenly not going to get an nfl job because of it

This is the second post in a row where you seem not happy with being here. All good man? Do we need to coach you on not clicking things that upset you before you even click them?

Ultimately, we’d all love a 6’4 guy that’s 4.4 speed, agile, explosive and soft hands. But if choosing between a mediocre receiver that is decent at jump balls or a relatively complete guy that’s 5’10, give me the better talent even if we have a few others like him. Odds are if we trot 3-4 of the undersized talented guys out there at least 1-2 will have a matchup advantage against a less agile CB that would otherwise be on benjamin

Meh. It’s a matchup league and some games that may help, others it will hurt when the opponent has a corner that’s a bit slower but super physical and good at 50-50 balls but would’ve lost to a shiftier wr. Ultimately from what I’ve seen is that max talent put in good positions wins much more than forcing your GM to fill precise roles. you stack talent and slightly look towards matchups in the division for tie breaks like that.

Always one of my favorite replies to see

Hes gotten an unreasonably high amount of attention with many projecting him to start even.

Hes a huuuuuge long shot, but I’m down to have a lottery ticket or 2 in the 90 man roster. For productive discussion around here though, fans need to plan their finances with him as a lottery ticket and not a weekly paycheck though.

Year 3 Seattle: 11-5 with 2 point loss in the divisional round, second playoff appearance. Year 1 Nola: 10-6 and lost in nfccg, year 4 super bowl champions My point being that our window is here regardless of if josh is great (as indicated by the many flashes in the pan like San Fran, for instance). If he flames out it won’t be sustained, but if he can carry a team then yes we will be in a constant cycle of immediately refreshing and reloading like those long term successful teams.