It's a case of whether or not you believe it should be about the entire career or what the represented at a time in the NFL.
Kurt Warner and the greatest show on turf was a very big moment for the NFL. It was just insane what they were doing. FFL leagues had him, Bruce, and Warner going 1-2-3. Never have I seen such a thing.
TD just couldn't stay healthy. But when he did for those few seasons, I'd compare him to any RB in history. He was just a tank.
I can see both sides of it. But for me, I want to walk the hall of fame and see the transition of greatness through history. Those two and what they represented were part of that.
I'll get flamed here, but Andre Reed is less deserving that those two. He was very good for a long time, but never dominant. To me, I'd rather have TD in his prime on my team than Andre Reed.