
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch
Community Member-
Posts
9,968 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Gallery
Profiles
Forums
Events
Everything posted by Ed_Formerly_of_Roch
-
I think this off season three things could happen: 1) TP (and KP) decides to completely clean house up to and including RB, DW, and all the coaches. I kind of doubt this will happen as from what I've read, TP appreciated RB's help during the purchase process so likely he stays. I do believe RB likes DW so puts a good word in for him and DW also keeps his job. I hope this happens as I believe the Bill's would be hard pressed to find a better GM He's made more good moves than bad, the one bad one people will bring up is QB, while I don't disagree this hasn't worked out very well, 20 other teams have the same problem. It takes more luck than anything to find the answer at QB 2) Whaley instructs DM to fire Hackett and DM refuses. Then DM also gets shown the door. In defense of DM, if I were him I'd argue that it will be difficult to bring in a new OC unless DM's contract is extended as who wants to work for a lame duck coach. If I recall correctly that was the same argument Wade Phillips made to RW at the time, but it didn't work that time either. It's also possible that Whaley puts many conditions on DM hoping he'll not accept them giving him an excuse to fire him. Wade had a a much longer and successful resume than DM does, so for Wade, he could play that card and not worry about getting rehired. For Marrone if he refuses to meet conditions and gets fired, he'll likely struggle to get another shot even in college, so not so sure Doug would be dumb enough to go down that route. (I'm certain these words will get many responses) 3) All the off season stories about friction between DM and the front office are true as this thread alludes too and DM is fired for that. So will see what happens in a month, will be very surprised if at least Hackett isn't gone by New Years.
-
Ok Can We Trade Every Pick We Have Left?
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to coltrane34's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
So you get a 1st rounder, lets dream big the #1 over all .You think there's a QB out there that has an 89% chance of being great?? Winston, the guy from Oregon? The rate of failures is much higher than success. Not disagreeing that we need better QB play, but thinking a 1st rounder will solve the problem is way off base -
The Demise of the Running Quarterback?
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to 26CornerBlitz's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
While this is true in the most literal sense, it is so misleading that I don't think it's going too far to call bull ****. To say 2/3 had their franchise QB is just as misleading. There are maybe 10 true franchise QB's in the league, for round numbers we'll say 1/3, the next 1/3 that you claim have franchise QB's are the following group; Three seasons ago when time to draft RW had the following for their starting QB Jets Mark Sanchez Houston Matt Schaub Tampa Josh Freeman I could go with more, my point is these were all teams who thought they had their guy, clearly if they had correctly valued RW they would have drafted him, but they didn't think much of RW and figured their current guy was just as good if not better. Very quickly they realized their error. Even the 1/3 with true franchise QB's likely would have drafted him as a backup maybe in the second round if they did know how good RW turned out. So yes the Bill's missed out as did practically every other team in the league if his true abilities were known. Just don't make it that the Bill's were one of only a handful of teams that screwed up her, the list is long. Teams abilities to value players star skills is more hit or miss and seems mostly miss. -
QB Index: Ranking the starters 1-32
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to 26CornerBlitz's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Kind of interesting that guys like Dauton, Alex Smith and Cutler are just ahead of Orton. Not much difference there. As far as franchise QBs' a discussion form the other day, I'd cut the list off after #9, though would consider moving Flacco or Eli up into that group too. -
NFL Maps: 2014 Week 14
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to 26CornerBlitz's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
So what player on either San Fran or Oakland hails from western PA as I see this little sliver of area is getting that game while most of the remainder of the country gets Seattle @ Philly?? -
Yup another sign of a terrible front office! Actually it's probably all Hacketts fault! PS can some one tell me where to find the sarcasm button??
-
So you have 17 I said 12, not too far off. I'd also argue that without an exceptional team around him, I doubt that Wilson, Kaepernick, Newton, Dalton, and maybe even Flacco could win a SB on their own talents. I'd then lump your elite and borderline elite, plus Big Ben, Romo, Stafford, Rivers, Ryan, and Eli minus the last two seasons into my "franchise" group. Even though some like a Romo or Rivers, haven't won a SB, I do feel they are capable of it with even decent talent Though Romo will find a way to self destruct every year.
-
Out of 32 teams in the NFL, there are around 20 who lack franchise QB's. So not finding one in a generation is about average for the league. That's the basic problem in the league, there are 32 teams and 10 great QB's. So teams get "desperate" and hope someone like an EJ or JP or Trent become that guy. If not move on.
-
The same thing was stated another time, around 1986. Kelly's 1st or 2nd year, defense was good, but if only the offense would play decent.
-
Bills awarded TE MarQueis Gray from Vikings
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to YoloinOhio's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
The first catch I sdaid, "Who is this guy" so Googled him. Didn't even find out very much there other than the date the Bills picked him up! -
Official Pre-Game Thread: Week 13, Browns at Bills
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to Dan's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Over the years there's been many players who've been inactive pretty much their entire rookie year, 2nd year, they got stronger and things slowed down and they became decent players. Will he be goign to the pro-bowl, probably not, but that's OK too as long as he can become a decent starter. Same with Richardson, give them another year. -
Tony Moeaki: He's no Lee Smith!
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to The Frankish Reich's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Hey don't let any actual facts get in the way of a chance to rip Bills management. You got an agenda, go for I'm aure you'll get 20 others with the same agenda to totally agree with you. -
Why I think Marrone should be fired...
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to C.Biscuit97's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
We play Green Bay before Oakland. I think Hughes may sign elsewhere regardless as I just don't know if we can afford him. You can only put so much money into one area of the team and you'll be needing to pay Dareus big $$ here too. The only way I see us signing him if if we don't bother trying to re-sign Spikes. Personally I think we need the run stopper more, last year had the same line minus Spikes, look how they played. Though I will say this Schwartz is known for being good at stoping the run, so he may be able to mold one of the other LB's into a great run stopper. If he can do that, then I'd be OK with letting Spikes go and using the money on Hughes, but just don't think we can afford both and fill other needs too. Regardless of the amount of money Terry is willing to spend, still have ot deal with a salary cap too. -
Who wants to apologize to Danny Crossman?
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to YoloinOhio's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Did you ever think that maybe his "career" of poor coaching was due to bad players. From what I recall reading he did have a couple good years, they weren't all bad . Maybe the moral of the whole thing is doesn't matter who the coach is, you need the players first. -
So I was listening to the Dan Lebetard show this afternoon, he had on John Clayton who was taking calls. Someone asked where Clayton thought Ray Rice would play next year and he stated Buffalo as Terry P had a connection with him though the sports agency he was involved with.. Obviously pure speculation, but that was his response.
-
Will Rex Ryan make it past Tuesday?
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to 1B4IDie's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
These days it's rare for an NFL coach to be fired mid season. 30 years ago, happened all the time, frequently by the Bills. Jauron elected to leave, he wasn't fired. -
Jets at Bills MNF - 2nd Half Game Thread
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to 26CornerBlitz's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Yeah I was thinking the same thing. I was wondering who that was, saw the Bills logo on him -
Jets at Bills MNF - 2nd Half Game Thread
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to 26CornerBlitz's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
For all the knocks on Hackett, we were saying the same thing last year about the ST coach and look at the play of ST this year. Makes a difference when you actually have players. Not that the offense doesn't have players, but still have a shaky line and QB play is rather unsettled. Not trying to say Hackert is the answer, but he's also not as big an issue as many make him out to be either. -
Anyone else having issues w/ Sunday Ticket Ap?
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to dayman's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
OK where's the game, it's now 7:01 according to my PC -
Anyone else having issues w/ Sunday Ticket Ap?
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to dayman's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
OK he we go at least there's a logo on the screen now! -
Official Pre-Game Thread: Week 12, Jets at Bills
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to Dan's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Wish all Monday night games started at 7:00, I need my beauty rest! -
Bills to play Jets in Detroit 7pm Monday
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch replied to YoloinOhio's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Well they just stated during the Raider KC game, Monday night Bills game to be broadcast by CBS in Buffalo and NY markets only.