Can the Bills Fire Joe Brady?

[SC STATE NUPE]

If you fire Brady right now, it’s Super Bowl or bust for McD. And if the Bills fail to not reach the big game, you have to most certainly clean house from a leadership and defensive perspective. Josh has a lot of blame for tonight too. Underneath and the sides were open all night. 2-3 of those sacks had Dawson crossing with at least a yard and a half step on the linebacker and all he had to do was lead him for the first down. Josh has been struggling immensely this year with leading receivers and proper ball placement. But Brady doesn’t know

how to counter aggressive defenses at all. 

[Nihilarian]

It's not "can", it's "will" they?  Bills fans keep talking about WRs, but this and other games like it are on the Buffalo offensive coordinator in my view.

[Steptide]

I don't think you can fire. As said, who is gonna replace him and revamp the offense this deep into the season? That said zif I'm McDermott, I have long talk with Brady and tell him during the extra time off, to figure something new out. This current offense is going nowhere. Granted, a big part of the problem is that they have no receivers. McDermott and Beane were incredibly stupid to think last year's offense was sustainable in any way. They bet on Coleman improving and lost 

[Pine Barrens Mafia]

Forget Brady. I want them ALL gone. From the head coach down to the third string fullback. Nuke the whole franchise, salt the earth and move on

Edited 4 hours ago by Pine Barrens Mafia

[muppy]

the Bills should fire him. I am done thinking he is good enough. He is Not.  BYE JOE

 

I really hope they do. 

 

 

[BillMafia716ix]

When you’re paying a QB $300M you expect him to get it done no matter who’s out there.  Now he has an All Pro RB. These are the same group of guys he won the MVP with just a year ago. Calling a spade a spade Josh just hasn’t been good this year. He’s had moments of greatness. But he’s taking more sacks and he’s turning the ball over, something he wasn’t  doing last year.
 

Joe Brady hasn’t been good either. He struggles adjusting in game. I mean how many times are you going to empty when the edges from the Texans are constantly beating our tackles? 10 possessions we had in this game and we only had 1 TD? With supposedly the best QB in the league? 

[muppy]

6 hours ago, Dafan said:

My question is, why the F*** are we handing off to Cook on a 4th and 1, 5 yards behind line of scrimmage.  Do the ***** QB sneak/tush-push!!!

fireable offense. absolutely brutal play call right there. Idiotic.

 

Bye Joe

 

SMH

[Pine Barrens Mafia]

Just now, BillMafia716ix said:

When you’re paying a QB $300M you expect him to get it done no matter who’s out there.  Now he has an All Pro RB. These are the same group of guys he won the MVP with just a year ago. Calling a spade a spade Josh just hasn’t been good this year. He’s had moments of greatness. But he’s taking more sacks and he’s turning the ball over, something he wasn’t  doing last year.
 

Joe Brady hasn’t been good either. He struggles adjusting in game. I mean how many times are you going to empty when the edges from the Texans are constantly beating our tackles? 10 possessions we had in this game and we only had 1 TD? With supposedly the best QB in the league? 

CORRECT.

 

This won't be popular, so you know. But I think the window to win one with Allen is closed, locked and has bars on the outside like Compton.

 

So, the question is what do we as a franchise?

 

My Idea isn't a popular one either 

[Spiderweb]

6 hours ago, The Jokeman said:

That prolific QB played like crap today. Blame the OC fine. I blame the player.

In fairness to Allen, the Oline's play was brutal, and it closes out with another FS by Dawkins at a critical point, then another heavy pressure on Allen (OPI would have negated anything we would have done). Knox was wide open and yet Allen didn't see him....anyway, all for nought

[BillMafia716ix]

2 minutes ago, Pine Barrens Mafia said:

CORRECT.

 

This won't be popular, so you know. But I think the window to win one with Allen is closed, locked and has bars on the outside like Compton.

 

So, the question is what do we as a franchise?

 

My Idea isn't a popular one either 

It’s not closed because Allen is still great but it’s clear an obvious that he’s not comfortable in Joe Brady’s offense. Joe gotta go for sure. And there needs to be a trade for a WR1. Kincaid also has to stay off the damn injury list. Right now Josh has zero faith in his WRs to win on the outside

[Pine Barrens Mafia]

1 minute ago, BillMafia716ix said:

It’s not closed because Allen is still great but it’s clear an obvious that he’s not comfortable in Joe Brady’s offense. Joe gotta go for sure. And there needs to be a trade for a WR1. Kincaid also has to stay off the damn injury list. Right now Josh has zero faith in his WRs to win on the outside

My guy, it's closed. His roster hit is too high, and his talent level is too high as well. What that means is you're drafting late in rounds, missing out on elite talent year in and year out. That gives you a starting roster of Josh Allen and 21 Terrell Bernard types. 

 

This team will never again with Josh Allen under center rise to the level of a super bowl contender.

[SoonerBillsFan]

8 hours ago, uticaclub said:

There is no one to replace him, by design. McDermott hired yes men over experience and Beane allowed it

Actually the QB coach knows the system, promote him

[CEN-CAL17]

9 hours ago, JohnNord said:

I think that’s why he was holding onto the ball.  You can’t do that with Houston’s pass rush but there was no where to go wit the ball

Not if the scheme isn’t a man beater by design, and yes it’s gotta be quick throws, run the ball play action 

[Best Williams Available]

Pegula is not going to fire McD and possibly not Beane either (I think Beane of the 2 should go). However both coordinators are terrible, inexperienced, and haven’t earned ANYTHING is this league. They’ve just waited in the wings until the guy in front of of them left and got the job. Other teams have ex Head Coach coordinators. That 💩 matters. Get them both out of here and hire established guys who have done something in the NFL.

[BuffaloBaumer]

Joe Brady was getting absolutely murdered this morning on ESPN radio. They were saying that their defensive coordinator ran circles around Joe all night and that we could not figure out how to adjust.

[rjbbills]

Thought I would read/see more about how poorly the offensive line played. They were getting shredded. Looked lost and like they were playing together for the first time. 

 

In regards to firings, oh yes. And you have to look at all of the assistants as well. These F heads are not doing a very good job. 

[GunnerBill]

He had a bad night last night. A real bad night. And why he is getting away from Cook I have no idea. Early 4th Quarter, down 1 score Cook who had our only offensive touchdown.... had ELEVEN carries. 

 

That is inexcuseable.

[Billsatlastin2018]

10 hours ago, The Jokeman said:

That prolific QB played like crap today. Blame the OC fine. I blame the player.

Really?

 

17 is looking at a posse of absolute ass WRs! They simply CANNOT separate to catch a football! 
 

2025 Stats?

 

And remember, the rest of the WRs in the league play their catchup game on Sunday.

 

# 28 Shakir - helped greatly by the 4th & 27 desperation hook & ladder.

#79 Keon Benchedman.

#96 Josh, 18 catches in 8 games, Palmer. Paying him $11 ***** million in 2026 for that performance!

#207 9 catches in 9 games- Moore!

#239 SEVEN CATCHES IN SIX GAMES @ $9 Mill- Samuel!

 

 

ABSOLUTE ASS!

 

And this is ALL on, I know better than everyone on the planet- Beanbrain.

The Bills didn’t need #10 WR Waddle! 
What a failed buffoon!

 

 

 

[tigerthelion]

1 hour ago, SoonerBillsFan said:

Actually the QB coach knows the system, promote him

Exactly.  What could go wrong with another internal hire?  

[Pete]

9 hours ago, Simon said:

 

That clip was after the failed 4th/1 where they ran Cook over G for the 4th play in a row (3 to the L, one to the R).

Cook was gassed at that point.  Braindead decision imo