Rosenthal bold face lies about EJ in an NFL.com…

[jumbalaya]

We don't know if EJ is the guy or not. We do know we have too much invested in him to draft a QB early next year. We would be smart to have a quality veteran back-up like FItz in place next year with Thad the number #3 guy. Smartest thing this organization can do is draft a T in Rd 1 and pick up a very good G in FA and build a solid ground attack. Then we can let EJ mature around a strong ground game. A #1 WR wouldn't hurt.

[Thurmal34]

IMO "not remotely ready" sez he didn't see all of Buffalo's games.

 

That said, Manuel has a TON to prove and IMprove on in 2014.

 

How hard is he going to work in the os? Is he going to go the early career Brady route and earn the parking spot awarded to the player that puts in the most work in the offseason? Is he going to shore up the accuracy issues that plagued him in his rookie year? Is he going to grab the team by the balls and lead it? Crap, is he going to stay on the field enough in 2014 to answer those questions? We'll see.

[Flip Johnson]

You don't like Gil Brandt or Mike Mayock?

 

I like Maycock. And as I said, I'm generally fine with Rosenthal. But nfl.com is not stacked with people I'd call good "writers" - the site props up the league and Rosenthal is paid to have opinions not to write good sentences.

[San Jose Bills Fan]

I like Mayrooster.

 

I wouldn't necessarily be bragging about that around here.

 

 

 

 

[3rdnlng]

I like Maycock. And as I said, I'm generally fine with Rosenthal. But nfl.com is not stacked with people I'd call good "writers" - the site props up the league and Rosenthal is paid to have opinions not to write good sentences.

Do you like it as well in April and June?

[Nanker]

We need to draft a new QB and start the process all over. And then draft another in 2015, and two more in 2016, then fire the front office and draft 12 QBs in 2017. Everyone wants rookies to play like pro bowlers.

 

Most here give no thought to how badly Fitzpatrick's leaving hurt the team this year. He left to the Flaming Thumbtacks for the same money The Bills offered, and took his pride and his NFL experience with him leaving Buffalo having to dumpster dive for a credible backup. That "dive" ended up being a 3 1/2 twisting belly flop in the pike position when they came up with Kolb.

 

Its laughable to believe that churning quarterbacks helps, not hurts a team. If Fitz had swallowed his pride and stayed, The Bills probably would be in the playoffs this year, because even if he was the backup here - as he was in Nashville when the season started - he would have won more than Tuel and Lewis and the FO could have rested EJ longer than they did.

[CSBill]

Gregg Rosenthal's assessment of NFL quarterbacks is spot on and the most accurate I have ever seen. I agree with him 100% You have to remember he is not a "homer" drinking the Kool aid. He is not biased and tells it like it is. He has no loyalty to any team so he can report honestly and accurately. That's why he gets paid the big bucks, he understands the game and can accurately report what he sees on the field. An outsider like him will give you and honest and true assessment because they are not attached to any team.

 

Thanks for dropping by Gregg's mom. I hope you had a wonderful Christmas.

 

As for EJ Manuel, the grade is clearly incomplete. He has been inconsistent at best—but he is a rookie. At this point, we all want to believe he's "the guy," but that is very hard to honestly say right now.

 

His only consistent trait this season has been injuries.

 

Only time will tell, but the problem is, this is the new NFL and QB's generally are not going to be given a lot of time. He will get next season, and then a real decisions can be made. (And as a long-suffering Bills fan, that is so painfully hard to accept.)

Edited December 26, 2013 by CSBill

[PolishDave]

Most here give no thought to how badly Fitzpatrick's leaving hurt the team this year. If Fitz had stayed, the Bills probably would be in the playoffs this year, because even if he was the backup here - as he was in Nashville when the season started - he would have won more than Tuel and Lewis and the FO could have rested EJ longer than they did.

 

If Fitz had stayed on this team, he would have won the starting job easily because even with his interception stats and accuracy issues, he is still head and shoulders above the current Qb talent on the roster. And with Fitz's intelligence he would have made an excellent mentor for EJ. And Fitz is tough as nails durable. Then maybe in a couple years EJ would have began outplaying Fitz in practice and could have become the starter. Instead, EJ gets thrown to the wolves as a raw rookie and runs a real risk of getting booed out of Ralph Wilson Stadium next year if he strings a couple "Tampa Bay" like games together.

 

The Bills ultimately screwed up when they signed Fitz to that huge contract and overpaid him. Then they screwed up again when they brought in Kolb as a supposed replacement for Fitz. Anyone who followed Kolb at all knew that signing was a mistake and a joke. Kolb is as brittle as QB's come and played like absolute crap in Arizona before coming here. There is no way EJ should have been put in a situation where he would be starting any games this year. He had to start because the other QB talent on this team was even worse. The front office screwed that up big time.

[San Jose Bills Fan]

This thread is hilarious.

 

1) After the Nix-Dominick phone call, there was no way Fitz was coming back. Even without the phone call his return was questionable at best.

 

Fitz would rather leave than be demoted and he was pretty clear about that. So why are we entertaining scenarios about Fitz being in Buffalo this season?

 

2) By a large percentage people on this board at this time last year wanted to hang Fitz. Where are those people now?

[TC in St. Louis]

EJ's qb rating is higher than most of the 8 or so players rated above him. He had a couple putrid games (Pittsburgh.....he should have sat another week) and Tampa. He's a rookie who has missed a lot of time. He is an excellent athlete, and I hardly think he's the worst.

[1billsfan]

This thread is hilarious.

 

1) After the Nix-Dominick phone call, there was no way Fitz was coming back. Even without the phone call his return was questionable at best.

 

Fitz would rather leave than be demoted and he was pretty clear about that. So why are we entertaining scenarios about Fitz being in Buffalo this season?

 

2) By a large percentage people on this board at this time last year wanted to hang Fitz. Where are those people now?

 

 

They're the same people who were happy the Bills drafted EJ Manuel and were willing to give him time and live with the ups and downs of a rookie QB and who are now done with him even though he's given them the up and down season they were expecting at the beginning of the season.

[Beerball]

EJ's qb rating is higher than most of the 8 or so players rated above him. He had a couple putrid games (Pittsburgh.....he should have sat another week) and Tampa. He's a rookie who has missed a lot of time. He is an excellent athlete, and I hardly think he's the worst.

Are you sure about this? He's better than average for a QB maybe, but he appears clumsy on the field to me.

[bobobonators]

…article.

 

"The Bills are in a tough spot with Manuel. He missed too much playing time and didn't look remotely ready when he started."

 

This is an article from nfl.com. This is not from some fanboy blog. What, there are no editors at nfl.com to tell Gregg that this comment on EJ Manuel was blatantly false? EJ has had FIVE games with a QB rating above 86. Three of those they won and a fourth game was the Atlanta game where he led the Bills on two game winning type drives that were blown up by receiver fumbles.

 

http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap2000000304038/article/quarterback-index-yearend-rankings

 

 

This is what passes for quality writing at nfl.com? I won't even get into the silly rankings of the bottom guys who he considers better than Manuel.

 

I could care less about subjective QB rankings. However, im not sure why you get so defensive about the statement. Its not that far off the mark.

 

There are many question marks about EJ after one year. And in a few games, EJ did not look ready to be playing in the NFL.

[26CornerBlitz]

I could care less about subjective QB rankings. However, im not sure why you get so defensive about the statement. Its not that far off the mark.

 

There are many question marks about EJ after one year. And in a few games, EJ did not look ready to be playing in the NFL.

 

That means you actually care.

[1billsfan]

EJ's qb rating is higher than most of the 8 or so players rated above him. He had a couple putrid games (Pittsburgh.....he should have sat another week) and Tampa. He's a rookie who has missed a lot of time. He is an excellent athlete, and I hardly think he's the worst.

 

The ratings at the bottom are bs, but that wasn't even my beef. It's too bad this writer or maybe even his editors couldn't be be called out on this outright false statement. I don't know what EJ did to tick off this writer, but Manuel has had five games above 86 QB rating and three of those were above 100. He's even had a fourth quarter comeback and game winning drive against a team that is a true Superbowl contender and who without question has a top five defense. Then there is the Atlanta game were with the playoffs life and season on the line, Manuel came through twice with big time clutch plays at the end of the game.

 

So why does nfl.com think it's ok to lie and say Manuel "didn't look REMOTELY ready when he started"? It's not even an opinion, it's a false statement and I wish that nfl.com could be called out on it. I clearly still don't know if Manuel is a franchise QB or not, but when I saw this comment I was angry that nfl.com let this writer get away with this. Very few in the country watch the Bills, so a lot of people reading that are thinking that Manuel has been a horrific train wreck when he's only had a very normal rookie up and down season.

Edited December 26, 2013 by 1billsfan

[BuffaloBill]

We need to draft a new QB and start the process all over. And then draft another in 2015, and two more in 2016, then fire the front office and draft 12 QBs in 2017. Everyone wants rookies to play like pro bowlers.

 

As a person who supports taking another QB high if one is available you miss the point. It is understood that rookies will not play like probowlers but do we have to go through another three years of evaluation only to discover that maybe we don't have "the guy." The Bills need to think about options and a plan "B" because EJ has hardly shown enough to convince anyone that his isn't just another in a long series of wrong choices for the Bills.

 

This is a QB driven league and until the Bills find one they will be perpetually mediocre or just plain bad.

[1billsfan]

I could care less about subjective QB rankings. However, im not sure why you get so defensive about the statement. Its not that far off the mark.

 

There are many question marks about EJ after one year. And in a few games, EJ did not look ready to be playing in the NFL.

 

He didn't add that. That kind of matters. If you were a Arizona Cardinal fan reading that, you would have no idea that EJ did look like a starting QB in four or five games. In fact you would think the opposite is true and the Bills Manuel is a train wreck of a pick. Doesn't the truth matter anymore? Or is it just plain cool to just dump on the Bills because it's funny even if you have to make the stuff up.

Edited December 26, 2013 by 1billsfan

[pimp 2]

We need to draft a new QB and start the process all over. And then draft another in 2015, and two more in 2016, then fire the front office and draft 12 QBs in 2017. Everyone wants rookies to play like pro bowlers.

 

+1

Thank you.

[Beerball]

 

 

+1

Thank you.

I agree with you. We should wait until Manuel's contract is about to expire before making a decision. After what we've been through another 3 seasons don't amount to a pimple on an elephants buttocks.

[NoSaint]

I am not sure that I disagree with him. They dumbed down the playbook in week 14. He made poor reads and audibles. EJ struggles with accuracy. I have been one to support him but have not seen anything that tells me that he is going to be a quality NFL starter.

 

its a tough spot. hes shown some flashes, and some qualities you want to see but.... coming out there was some talk of him being a project and having been beaten up hes gotten the least amount of time to work on his craft. additionally, we just dont know how much his injuries are effecting his mechanics (both physically not being 100%, and the mental aspect). hopefully with a full offseason getting starter reps we get to see 16 games that tell us the story on the guy next year.