jahnyc

I am pessimistic that the offense can be fixed quickly. It is historically bad, and the rebuild will start from a bottom that few teams have experienced. An argument can be made that every starting position on offense needs an upgrade. This situation cannot be fixed this season or in one offseason. I don't think there are parallels to the Chicago Bears and LA Rams because both of those teams had a better base of offensive talent than we have at this point and both teams brought in coaches with strong backgrounds on offense. Another problem that we have is that we have no idea whether Allen will develop into a quality starting QB. He is very raw, and it may take a couple of more years before we know. Coaching on the offensive side is another unknown, since our personnel is so poor that it is difficult to make judgments about Daboll. We can review his prior experiences as OC in the NFL and not be particularly confident that he will have success in Buffalo, even with better players. Realistically, fixing the offense looks like a pretty massive undertaking at this point. I don't have confidence that it can happen with the speed we will want after suffering through this season.

I would feel better about the future of this rebuild if we had more draft picks in next year's draft. I understand that we have more than our usual allotment, but the additional picks we have next year are after the third round. We may hit on one or more of those picks, but chances of finding quality players are higher in the early rounds. I suppose we can trade down if there are opportunities to do so, but this team also needs pro bowl caliber players, and if we have a top five pick, we may have a shot at that kind of a player. That would be hard to pass up.

The Bills shed a lot of relatively young players (Darby, Watkins, Woods, Goodwin, Gilmore, Ragland, Darreus and even Glenn). I understand that many of these players left by choice via free agency, but this is not a group of golden oldies.

I strongly disagree with posters who state that this was all planned or this is part of the rebuild process. No one, including the Pegulas, signed up for this level of ineptitude on offense or the manner in which the roster on the offensive side was stripped and then not addressed in free agency or through the draft. It is not fair to the fans or the players on defense, and I don't see how you can have a cohesive team under these circumstances. The offense is not fixable in one offseason, and it could take years with so many upgrades that are needed. In many ways, that is the most frustrating part of all of this (the long road ahead). As to the original post in this tread, I do not disagree that Beane deserves to be fired for this mess and the way it was created and the prospects for a long repair process. He was inexperienced, and it has showed in a number of ways, including the complete mismanagement of the QB position, poor player personnel assessment and the poor trades (e.g., Darby, Glenn and Benjamin). I don't think Beane will be fired, but he has made a strong case for that happening.

I am wondering as well, but let's not forget that this year is seeing scoring at a record pace and things were different for offenses back in 1976 as compared to now in terms of rules and sophistication.

I think we have the worst offensive roster in the NFL, maybe by far.

Our players on offense are all generally below or well below average other than Shady and maybe Clay, but does Daboll make things worse? Hard for me to figure out at this point.

Dawkins has not played well this season.

If they don't play Allen for the rest of the season, then the questions are what is the severity of the injury, will it heal on its own, and whether surgery may be needed now or at a later point in time. Even if the answers to these questions are positive or somewhat positive, the Bills should acquire a quality QB (as a back-up or possible starter) in a trade or via free agency.

A few quick points: 1. I don't agree with the "would not develop here" comments. It is up to the front office and coaching staff to make sure that there is an environment in which a drafted QB can develop and thrive (including having a back-up veteran QB mentor, a better o-line and WRs, and an experienced QB coach). I continue to be dismayed at the lack of attention paid by the front office and coaching staff to do this when the plan all along was to trade up and take QB with a very early pick in the first round. They have shown a complete lack of competency, and signing Anderson, after Allen was injured, is not enough to fix it. 2. It cost us a lot to move up and draft Allen. Taking Mahomes would have started the process of developing a QB one year earlier and would have allowed us to keep valuable draft capital that this team desperately needed. I get it that hindsight is 20-20, but I am tired of the excuses, and our front office has to be judged on their successes and misses. We have missed too many times over the past number of years. 3. As other posters have suggested, we do need a head/president of football operations. I am not sure McBeane has shown the necessary competency and abilities to handle what has become a huge job to rebuild the roster. I continue to be stumped as to why the Pegulas gave so much power to McDermott upon his hiring. He had never been a HC or acted in a player personnel capacity. They should have hired a GM with experience as a GM and then let the GM pick a coach. As is typical with us, this process was done the opposite way it is usually done and we are left paying the price.

Is there really any chance that we could get a second round pick for McCoy? I would not think so given his age. I think the Bills will need to draft or sign a free agent running back next year whether or not McCoy is traded. This is another position on offense that will need attention in the offseason.

The current reality in the NFL seems to be that a lot of teams are in need of a #1 WR and upgrades on the o-line. Look at the steep price paid for Cooper by the Cowboys, and I am not sure whether Cooper is a true #1. Other teams were after him as well, including the Eagles. I doubt there will be a #1 WR available in free agency next year. This likely will need to be filled in the draft, and WRs can take time to develop, assuming that they do develop into quality players.

Considering the current talent level, I think a quick turn around for next year is unlikely. We also will have new holes next season if KW, KB and McCoy do not return. We do not have enough picks in the early rounds to expect a bunch of instant starters from next year's draft, and a number of teams have significant cap space for free agent acquisitions, so it will be competitive getting quality free agents to sign with the Bills. I think this rebuild is going to take time, both in terms of upgrading the roster and the development of Allen. As noted above, there is a lot of work that is needed to improve this team.

I want to have confidence in McBeane's ability to rebuild the roster, but I don't because of their head scratching personnel moves and lack of a plan at QB (both in terms of developing and mentoring Allen as well as the failure to sign an adequate back-up QB). At this point, they have opened themselves up to second guessing and criticism, which I think is more than fair. I assume that they will get at least through 2019 to straighten out this mess, but I understand the collective frustration and those that think they already should be on the hot seat.

Hippodrome was crowded and overall pretty good to watch the Bills play the Colts. They showed all of the NFL games upstairs (except for maybe the Browns) and they set up a separate viewing area for the Bills-Colts, which was comprised of a small sitting area with maybe six or seven rows with three chairs in a row plus a long sofa along the side of the seating area. Only one Indy fan in the group, but I am not sure how many were fans of the Bills because there were people wearing different team jerseys. I think some people were waiting for the later games. Surprisingly, I think the biggest crowds were there to watch the Panthers and the Texans. There also seemed to be a fair number of Eagles fans. Food was fine. They had Buffalo wings, but, unfortunately, I am trying to eat healthy.

Unfortunately, I believe that our options have been more limited than most teams when it comes to hiring new GMs and coaches, as well as free agent acquisition, due to the combination of recent franchise reputation, ownership and the realities of being a small market team. This also has impacted our ability to retain players. It probably does not help that the Pegulas do not have a team structure with a strong president, which may have helped mitigate these issues. Overall, there has been a level of front office ineptness over the last 20 plus years that is difficult to fathom. I am tired of each new regime trying to convince us that they are smarter than everyone else and then failing miserably with head scratching decisions.

Thanks, GB. She is living in Kensington, near Queen's Gate. Great area. She is doing a semester abroad program, and having a great time in London.

Thanks! Have been enjoying our time in London and visiting with our daughter.

Thanks for all of the replies. Likely will check out the Hippodrome Casino on Leicester Square. I did do a Google search before posting and asking the question. Results included some of the casinos in Leicester Square (including the Hiippodrome), Riley's, Belushi's and Naughty.

Any recommendation for a good sports bar in London that will show the Bills game against Indy and other NFL games? Staying in Mayfair but I should be able get to other places pretty easily.

I think Roman (or at least the Roman schemes) was the best recent OC for the Bills. The offense produced based on his system with a below starting QB (Taylor). I wonder how much better his offense would have been with a better QB. Gailey also was able to get more out of a below average group of players on offense.

None of us know how Allen will develop (or not develop). He is a project, and, if anything, more raw than I expected. He should not have been the starter in his first year. This is going to take time to evaluate, and the Bills will need to figure out a viable back-up QB in the interim.

The combination of drafting Allen and moving up with picks and trades to have that opportunity is the thing that I would have to at least consider as the biggest redo of the offseason. I know that the Bills were determined to get their QB of the future in the most recent draft, but you can never force these situations if the players that are most likely to fulfill that need are not available to you. I don't know who the Bills had as their top choice or choices at QB in the draft, but they could not get in to position to take Mayfield or Darnold if that is what they really wanted. I thought the Bills only pursued McCarron after some of the other veteran QBs were signed by other teams (i.e., McCown, who I thought was their first choice). Bridgewater likely would have been an upgrade, and maybe he should have been considered as both a potential short and long term solution so that we would not have believed it necessary to move up and take Allen. Of course, the reality may have been that McBeane really wanted Allen more than any of the other choices. If this is the case, I would question the ability of this front office and scouts to evaluate talent. Allen is a project and has a long way to go before he is playing even at the level of Darnold and Mayfield. I don't have the feeling that Allen can be developed as quickly as we would like.

Allen is really raw and it shows. He has a lot of natural gifts, including arm strength and good athleticism, but he is a project. He also has come into arguably the worst situation of the four rookie QBs in terms of talent around him and overall support (in terms of coaching on offense, QB coaching and veteran support (which hopefully will be better now with the arrival of Anderson)). He does seem less developed in many respects compared to Darnold and Mayfield. I do think it is a good thing for him to play this season. We do not have five years for him to develop. He needs to show improvement during this season and next for us to have some confidence that he can be the guy at QB.

I agree that McD can coach. The overall talent on this team is poor, and he has coached the team to two wins against good teams so far this season. I understand there also have been blowout losses, but I think it is a mini-miracle that this team is 2-3 at this point. I do have concerns about the coaching on the offense side of things, but I think McD is good at keeping the players believing that they can compete, even after bad losses. McD needs a stellar OC. I do not believe that Daboll is that guy, and if he is not, then McD needs to find one as soon as possible.