NewEra

I would!! I’d bet $100- whatcha say @Brennan Huff? 😉 I don’t think he’s a lock, but I do think he’s top 6 and a 1.1M dead cap if cut helps his case

That’s fair- you don’t like his decisions on who he decided to start. I didn’t either. I was also hoping for elam and Dorian. From my vantage point sitting at the bar with a beer and not in the clubhouse, I can pretend to know what’s best too. Problem being, we can’t see much from the bar. We don’t know if dorian was able to play Mike efficiently and call the plays. and like I’ve said forever- I agree, our coaching isn’t on par with KC. I also don’t think there’s a team in the league that is on par with them. Hence back to back SBs with below average WR units

I agree 💯 I wasn’t saying McD isn’t without fault. I’d just like to see how he does in a game without @GoBills808regarding how many defensive starters we were missing- milano, Bernard, Tre, Benford, von miller (he played but nowhere near 💯), floyd played 38% of the snaps and was useless, jones was coming back from major injury and wasn’t heard from all game, Dodson managed to play 78% of the snaps on one leg, Douglas almost didn’t play due to his knee injury suffered the previous week, 2nd string MIKE Spector would have been a starter over AJ. Poyer and Hyde were shells of themselves. But yeah, we were missing 3 players. 4 of 11 starters were out- a would be starter in Spector was out- 5. That’s almost 50% as I had stated plus several others that had ability changing injuries.

i agree that sometimes it is a big issue. I agree that, under Frazier, the scheme wasn’t challenging enough. It was a huge issue. And I agree that he’s making changes on that side of the ball to try and diversify the defense. I’m sure we both agree that we’re happy about that. Every coaching staff needs to evolve. He’s doing that. But the bottom bolded, I think you’re exaggerating. How did we hold KC to 20 and 17 points in two of the last 3 games we played if they’ve become fish in a barrel? Maybe Reid and Mahomes weren’t trying that game? 🤷🏻‍♂️ your narrative that Reid/Mahomes always have their way with McD’s D is wrong. Funny how that always happens when we are healthier and have better players on the field. Beat them in 21 with Tre- lost to them in 13 seconds without Tre. Beat then in 22 with Von. Beat them in 23 with Benford, TB, healthy Douglas. Lost without them. Burrow, well that’s been a different story. He’s stomped on McDs D. Ain’t no doubt Moving the goalposts. But I that’s what you’ve done this entire debate. It’s all based on your dislike for McD. And that’s all. You’re entitled. But it doesn’t mean that you’re right

Well great, neither do I. This is the problem with your guys’ stance on this topic. I’m not blaming it on one thing (injuries). I’m blaming it several things. I don’t think that “injuries hopelessly derailed” our season. I think Injuries played a part. As I’ve stated several times. Yet it keeps coming back to you guys implying that my argument rests solely on injuries. That’s bs and not my argument. if you guys want to put the blame of not winning a SB on one person so be it. You’re wrong and you should know better. There was more than one factor. Not acknowledging it is strange That’s it for me here. I’ve said my peace on the matter.

Yeah….they can perform…..vs another banged up team…. 🤦🏻‍♂️

Whatever that means.

got it. Stating it was their PS…..while not acknowledging that we were also missing Von, hyde, daquan and phillips. Ed, Tre and Poyer all playing hobbled. Shaq, Ankou, Jaquan Johnson, marlowe, settle, elam, boogie and Dane all played significant snaps. uet it was their PS vs our starters? Riiiiight. Much respect to ya, but not acknowledging any of our injuries, while also using Cinci’s injuries as leverage is a weak battle. you don’t believe in McD. Cool. I’m not sure I do either. But I can acknowledge that it’s not one persons fault. That’s just ridiculous

You don’t think injuries played any part? Execution? just McD. All his fault. Got it

No, but their superstar elite difference maker that always seems to put his stamp on big games has never missed a playoff games. He’s different and we don’t have that. Von was that guy vs KC in the 22 regular season. He WAS the closer we needed. He closed that game out in KC, a true PTPer. Then he was gone and so was our PTPer. Maybe it’s McDs fault that our DL can’t win one on ones in the biggest games of the year. Guys need to make plays. It’s not 💯 coaching Yes, Spags is one of the best DCs ever. Another reason why McD hasn’t been able to overcome. McD had Allen and Diggs- no other elite players or coaches. KC has Reid and Spags calling all the plays. 2 elite HoF coaches. Mahomes, Kelce, Jones. 3 first ballot HoFers all likely top 5 in their positions all time. Mahomes and Kelce may end up both being the best. Plus several all pros many would call elite. And McD is supposed to beat them with half of his best players on D injured?

It’s funny how you people can’t acknowledge how our talent level on defense was crippled due to injury. Acting as if a defensive coach should be able to overcome Mahomes and Reid with a bunch of backups on the field. Which team has done that before? Were the bengals missing half of their starting D when they beat KC in the playoffs? How about the Tampa D in the Super Bowl? The pats in 2019? No, no and no. again…..injuries weren’t the only reason. I acknowledge that McD has his shortcomings and they have contributed to us not winning any SBs. As has execution. As has injuries. Luck matters. 31 teams end up losers every year. Not acknowledging that the injuries have played a role in our defensive performances is just being stubborn. The resounding narrative: Allen needs better WRs. Implying that in order to win, he needs better players. Meanwhile, McD is expected to overcome the adversity of fielding backups at almost 50% of starting D positions….while playing against Mahomes and Reid. Got it. Say samuel, Dawkins and Kincaid miss the playoffs. Overcome adversity. Riiiiight. No. Season over.

It was astonishingly bad defense. And again- We were missing our two stud Lbs that were the pulse for our defense to start the season. our mlb and player that gave up 2 TDs, was on the couch every Sunday a month prior. We were missing both of our starting corners and Douglas had an injured knee. Our biggest investment on D (von) was useless. Our biggest offseason acquisition (floyd) played 38% of the snaps after having already run out of gas in week 11. Our 2 best DL (Rousseau and Oliver) got dominated in their one on ones. our starting safeties - 1 signed for 2M. The might be retired. But yeah- Stop Mahomes and Kelce. More importantly, stop them with AJ Klein covering Kelce.

Right, in games where we had no defensive lines and no pass rush. He needed more pass rush talent because Beane invested in the wrong guys. (Murphy, star, Addison, butler). We had one starting caliber DL, Jerry. You know this. We all know you know this. We’ve all read your posts stating how Beanes poor allocation of resources into our DL has cost us big time. Every offseason we talked about how we can fix our pass rush because Jerry wasn’t enough. Ed oliver to the rescue. Rousseau, epenesa, Basham all drafted to fix the problem. That didn’t happen. So we break the bank for Von Miller. And that actually worked…..until that unfortunate Thanksgiving day that we lost von for the next 2 playoffs (and maybe his career). so McD is supposed to stop KC and Cinci with addison, Shaq, butler, settle, always injured Phillips, star, Murphy, Basham and AJ rushing the passer. Got it. Rousseau is a very good DL, but only a slightly above average pass rusher. AJ is solid. Floyd and Miller were nonexistent in the playoffs. Ed is great, but was completely shut down vs KC in the playoffs- as he had to play 80% of the snaps. Mcdermott couldn’t find a way to stop Mahomes and Kelce with AJ Klein out there the entire game with no pass rush. Talent matters…..just like it matters for playmakers offense. How many super bowls are won by teams with no pass rush and a crap DL? Not many. That said, I don’t think McD is without fault. He has been part of the problem in season ending losses. Other parts include injuries, offensive/defensive game plan and execution.

lol, yeah it was 2021 that had the delay. We had our way with them, partly because Chris Jones didn’t play due to injury.

Right. As if Von Millers injury hasn’t thrown a massive monkey wrench into our defense for the last 2 playoff runs. As if missing 2 starting corners doesn’t matter. As if missing all of our starting LBers hasn’t mattered. As if our best two DTs being injured vs Cinci didn’t have an effect on our D (plus von miller). all this talk about us not surrounding Josh with enough weapons every year (and I agree, I wish we had invested more on O)…..we can’t get it done because we don’t have enough talent on O…..yet McD is supposed to stop Mahomes and Burrow in the playoffs with even lesser talent (due to injury) than Josh has on O? If we had added hopkins last offseason and he and Kincaid would’ve gotten injured, that would’ve certainly been one of the factors that led to our season ending. That’s what’s happened to our D. Every season, our biggest investments and key players have been getting injured and missing the playoffs. I’d love to see KC win the SB without Chris Jones. If he had torn his acl late in 2022, they wouldn’t have won the last two SBs. No one could convince me otherwise. Was that the rain delay game? Or was that 3 years ago?

And the defense is missing several key players every year in the playoffs. Not 1 or 2 or 3 players on d. 3,4,5 key players/investments. what was McD supposed to do last year when every DE got shut down by the KC OL? When AJ Klein is out there in coverage vs Kelce playing 98% of the snaps because the teams 3 original LBs were out with injury. When Douglas was out there on one ankle while Benford and Tre were already out? Leonard floyd gets injured (38% snaps), miller injured and useless. we held top 5 O Miami to 20 and 14 points. We held KC to 17. We the top scoring offense in Dallas to 10. We CAN. I maintain that we just need to be relatively healthy, game plan better and execute. We don’t NEED a top 2 offense to win a SB. Sorry, I just don’t think that’s the reality.

It’s not really a check book though. It’s a salary cap thing. Trading him this year would be one of the dumbest moves in team history as we just rewrote his contract. We would’ve had less dead cap if we just kept it as it was. So trading him, we’d have to restructure someone else to free up 16M and kick another 16M down the road. Just doesn’t make sense.

This is ridiculous. We need to get some stops….like every Super Bowl winner gets. The last 11 super bowls, only 3 champions have given up 25 points or more. In the last 6 super bowls, the winner has given up 22 or less in every game except KC vs Philly. Stay relatively healthy, game plan properly and execute. Having a top 2 O with a below average D = no championship. 9/10 times

According to his new contract, this is DEFINITELY not the case. unless you’re talking about next season, which we’d have to pay 3M more than his cap hit if we moved him. This year….we’d pay over 16M more than his current cap hit. He’s a bill in 2024 💯

No they dont- they just have to be healthier than last year, have a better game plan and execute. everyone likes to talk about the roster as being the basis of winning or losing. The chiefs were a lost cause in December of 23. Everyone said their WRs suck and that KC left Mahomes out to dry by not giving him proper weapons. Then they win the SB. Why? Because they were healthier, well coached and executed when they had to. That’s what we need. The best roster in September rarely wins the SB imo.

Gtd $ 1.2 vs 3 bonus up to 4.5 vs up to 8.25 almost the same = over twice as much?

As bad as this looks now, just wait til Ben Johnson leaves after the season.

He doesn’t drop all of them. He came up big for them en route to the Sb

I’m one of his biggest detractors. That said- he made some huge play last post season. I’m sure he’d revert back to the unreliable version if we signed him, but he’s worth a shot considering our current WR5-6. He’s brings us a deep threat

Definitely hard to project. I just think that 12 will be part of our identity. 50% or so is my prediction