I like how you did the 80’s and 90’s, so I’ll keep them.
1960’s:
1. Tom Sestak
2. Butch Byrd
1970’s:
1. OJ
2. Reggie McKenzie
2000’s:
No one
but if I had to pick 2,
1. Nate Clements
2. Terrence McGee
2010’s:
No one (yet)
but if I had to pick 2,
1. Fred Jackson
2. Kyle Williams
May not be close to consensus, but that’s my wall.