TheyCallMeAndy

Honestly, their GM may be responsible for doing the same thing that Beane did: invest in sub-par WRs, hope to elevate mostly C and some B level defensive talent, and hang on to aging players.

6 away from 40+ for the 5th? straight year

Snow King Josh Allen

5th year is an easy 'sure,' but history is full of talented TEs who can't stay healthy and therefore floated around team to team. We will need to see some steel in year 4 and 5 to warrant any kind of extension.

Nothing for the late hit on Allen...

Interesting to me that people on this board hold Zack Taylor in higher regard than McD....

Ok everyone: what is the one weird Bills themed collection that you have? Bills Little People? Hats? Gnomes? 👀 Bobble-heads? Spill this is a judgement free zone. Sort of.

Question: Does our conservative, short game focus potentially cause these stats to be misleading?

I felt like this statement was false, but it's actually true: Groots Cap Hit Ranks 2027 - 23m: 14th in the NFL 2028 - 24m: 9th in NFL 2029 - 25m: 6th in NFL Don't be put off by him being a top 10 ranked paid DE either. Top guys are making 40, 50, even 60m, so Groots rankings will fall as new contracts and extensions are done. He would need to make around 30m a year to enter the top 5, even in 2025. Groot is also no slug. He's a 'Robin' pass rusher (needs a Batman) but as a run defender, he's Superman. Easily one of the best in the NFL.

Obviously if DS was like "Yes! See you Monday!' then changed his mind after they released JI, that's a different story.

Yea this is a pretty bad fumble. I know JI was nothing special defensively, but he could hold down the CB role and is a real good 'teamer. Lost him for potentially nothing.

He has a 16% missed tackle rate and allowing 75% completions. This isn't a loss. Shocked Beane even tried.

Tre, Bishop, Benford, and Lewis have completion percentages under 60% this season, Hairston is under 50%.

Probably deserves it's own thread: Tre White hasn't allowed more than 2 catches or a completion percentage of more than 50% since October 5th. Give that man his flowers.

Big Baller Beane II: Redemption

For anyone wondering: I'm aware Mitch Biski is a FA over 30. I'm also aware no one cares lol Edit x2 Crap, Phillips and Poyer.

To actually answer OP's question: I'd be sad, honestly. I like McD as a human and think he's a rock solid B+ coach, who's been an A- before. I completely acknowledge that there isn't much left in the "what else he can try" bucket. Do not fire him until there is an A-level coaching candidate available, though. I will stand by that. I'll take Year 9 over Tomlin, McDaniels, or Daboll. The months/weeks in-between McD and his replacement will honestly be pretty terrifying, but I'm sure we will find ourselves supporting whoever gets hired regardless of who it is. Like Tomlin, McDaniels, or Daboll.

Added!

Totally fair, should've put that as an option as well. I mean we only have one so far 🤣

Tre Day has had a low key, very rock solid 7 games. Tre as our Dime and primary backup at outside CB is an interesting thought.

Title says it all: We have a huge list of FA's and a chunk are over 30. Most won't be back, some will. Who do you think it should be? To be diabolical, you can only pick two. Poll is probably much easier if you can pick three, but you can't. I'll know. 🦬

FIFY

A lot of people are critical of the whole same play thing, I'm fine with it in rare occasions. OL beat up, QB beat up, can't stop it so just keep doing it. The worry is he will spam a playcall when it's not working, or in a critical moment when everyone knows it's coming. 4th and short, playoffs, I wonder what play they will call?

TL:DR Our WRs suck and RB/OL are awesome. Don't get Josh killed. You're welcome 😎

I was being super sarcastic btw, I feel when we win there is always a "yea, but" statement and somehow the HC that was just beat is still somehow thought to be better than ours lol