Jump to content

Guess the QB Carousel Game


Recommended Posts

Alot of question marks for several teams at QB and there is sure to be a TON of movement.  

 

BUF - Matt Moore; Sam Darnold(we will trade both 1sts and next year's 1st)

NYJ - Kirk Cousins(Bates connection with Shanahan)

CLE - Josh Rosen

JAX - Alex Smith

DEN - Nick Foles; Josh Allen

NYG - Eli; Davis Webb

WAS - Case Keenum

MIN - Teddy; Bradford

ARI - Tyrod; McCown; Mayfield

 

How do you think it shakes out?

  • Like (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

22 minutes ago, BrooklynBills said:

Alot of question marks for several teams at QB and there is sure to be a TON of movement.  

 

BUF - Matt Moore; Sam Darnold(we will trade both 1sts and next year's 1st)

NYJ - Kirk Cousins(Bates connection with Shanahan)

CLE - Josh Rosen

JAX - Alex Smith

DEN - Nick Foles; Josh Allen

NYG - Eli; Davis Webb

WAS - Case Keenum

MIN - Teddy; Bradford

ARI - Tyrod; McCown; Mayfield

 

How do you think it shakes out?

 

Great topic.  here is my list: 

 

Buf:  Smith; Allen (not happy, but what I think will happen), Peterson

NYJ: draft L. Jackson, keep Hackenberg and Petty.  

CLE: Darnold

Jax: keep Bortles, draft Mike White

DEN: Bradford; draft Rudolph

NYG: Rosen, Eli, Webb

WAS: Cousins.  I can't see Washington not tagging him.  They have nothing behind him.  

MIN: Teddy, Keenum

ARI: Tyrod, Mayfiled. 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Matt Moore?  wtf is with the love for this guy?  he is so bad they had to ask a mediocre QB to unretire when their real starter went down and then they played David Fales instead of him vs us in the last game and he almost won.  Matt Moore might not even be in the league next year let alone a starting QB haha

Link to comment
Share on other sites

56 minutes ago, BrooklynBills said:

Alot of question marks for several teams at QB and there is sure to be a TON of movement.  

 

BUF - Matt Moore; Sam Darnold(we will trade both 1sts and next year's 1st)

NYJ - Kirk Cousins(Bates connection with Shanahan)

CLE - Josh Rosen

JAX - Alex Smith

DEN - Nick Foles; Josh Allen

NYG - Eli; Davis Webb

WAS - Case Keenum

MIN - Teddy; Bradford

ARI - Tyrod; McCown; Mayfield

 

How do you think it shakes out?

I eliminated a few teams that I don't foresee making any changes. Red = rookies, blue = free agents/trades

 

Arizona: Teddy BridgewaterBaker Mayfield, scrub veteran

Atlanta: Matt Ryan, Kyle Lauletta

Baltimore: Joe Flacco, Kurt Benkert

Buffalo: Sam Darnold, Nate Peterman

Carolina: Cam Newton, scrub veteran (possibly bringing Derek Anderson back)

Cleveland: Tyrod Taylor, Josh Allen

Dallas: Dak Prescott, Sam Bradford

Denver: Kirk Cousins, Trevor Siemien

Jacksonville: Blake Bortles, Mike White

Kansas City: Pat Mahomes, scrub veteran

Miami: Ryan Tannehill, Lamar Jackson

Minnesota: Case Keenum, Mason Rudolph

New England: Tom Brady, Luke Falk

New Orleans: Drew Brees, Chase Litton

Jets: Josh Rosen, Petty/Hack

Seattle: Russell Wilson, scrub veteran

Washington: Alex Smith, Colt McCoy, Riley Ferguson

Edited by DCOrange
Link to comment
Share on other sites

28 minutes ago, kdiggz said:

Matt Moore?  wtf is with the love for this guy?  he is so bad they had to ask a mediocre QB to unretire when their real starter went down and then they played David Fales instead of him vs us in the last game and he almost won.  Matt Moore might not even be in the league next year let alone a starting QB haha

 

Moore is not good but he does make sense if we draft a young guy who we intend to start right away. He could be the veteran voice in the room and a guy who has played for Daboll.  He is definitely not starter material. There will be some veteran in room if we draft a young guy. 

 

I think the options are:

Sign crappy veteran like Matt Moore, Derek Anderson. Drew Stanton, Chad Henne. Trade up to draft young guy we intend to start right away. 

Sign or trade for veteran to be long term starter: Bradford, Cousins, Bridgewater, Keenum, Foles. Develop Peterman and late round guy. 

Sign or trade for really good bridge Alex Smith and draft quarterback we intend to develop for 1-2 years. (this scenario makes most sense to me and could still involve a trade up)

Sign or trade for marginal young guys who still might have potential to compete with Peterman. Tyler Bray, Blaine Gabbert, Matt Barkley, Geno Smith (would not like this scenario but could see it if they really love Peterman) .It would be the Kevin kolb-EJ scenario

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We are too good of a team to either have Matt Moore who we know is terrible or a rookie who even if he's good is going to play like crap in year 1. I think we have to go next level and get Bradford or Alex Smith. If the rookie beats them out then great, if not at least you know you have a middle of the road QB in the meantime

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, BrooklynBills said:

Alot of question marks for several teams at QB and there is sure to be a TON of movement.  

 

BUF - Matt Moore; Sam Darnold(we will trade both 1sts and next year's 1st)

NYJ - Kirk Cousins(Bates connection with Shanahan)

CLE - Josh Rosen

JAX - Alex Smith

DEN - Nick Foles; Josh Allen

NYG - Eli; Davis Webb

WAS - Case Keenum

MIN - Teddy; Bradford

ARI - Tyrod; McCown; Mayfield

 

How do you think it shakes out?

 

I like your scenario for us and hope it happens :thumbsup:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Some random guesses

 

One of Manning, Brees, or Roethlesberger retires

 

Bills wave a pile of cash in front of Cousins and asks You Like That! before he eventually signs with Miami

 

Tyrod to Pittsburgh

 

Alex Smith stays in KC

Keenum and Bradford stay in Minnesota

Bridgewater to Arizona

 

Jets cut Hackenberg

 

Cleveland and the Giants pick Darnold/Rosen, or is that Rosen/Darnold?

 

Bills do not draft a QB on day 1. 

Rumors start that the Bills are trying to acquire Dalton for a second or third. 

Bills do not draft a QB on day 2

Rumors continue that the Bills are trying to acquire Dalton for a 2019 pick

Bills draft a developmental QB on day 3

 

Bills sign Hackenberg and go into camp with Hackenberg, Peterman, and a developmental QB

 

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, /dev/null said:

Some random guesses

 

One of Manning, Brees, or Roethlesberger retires

 

Bills wave a pile of cash in front of Cousins and asks You Like That! before he eventually signs with Miami

 

Tyrod to Pittsburgh

 

Alex Smith stays in KC

Keenum and Bradford stay in Minnesota

Bridgewater to Arizona

 

Jets cut Hackenberg

 

Cleveland and the Giants pick Darnold/Rosen, or is that Rosen/Darnold?

 

Bills do not draft a QB on day 1. 

Rumors start that the Bills are trying to acquire Dalton for a second or third. 

Bills do not draft a QB on day 2

Rumors continue that the Bills are trying to acquire Dalton for a 2019 pick

Bills draft a developmental QB on day 3

 

Bills sign Hackenberg and go into camp with Hackenberg, Peterman, and a developmental QB

 

 

Now, I gotta say, that certainly is extremely BILLSY, but I'm hopeful that McBeane & Co have exercised the demons at OBD and they have solid, executable plan in place to have a strong starting QB ready for the season. I have read so much about the current crop of draft class QBs and I have no idea who's good or bad anymore.

 

One thing I'd prefer when looking back at TT and Fitzy is a deadly ACCURATE QB. I think that trumps arm strength and a trait we haven't seen since Jimbo.

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Buffalo- Bridgewater, Rudolph,Peterman

NYJ- KCousins

Clev- Rosen

Denv-Foles,Mayfield

NYG, Eli, Darnold

Wash, Keenum, Allen

Ariz-Smith,Falk

Minn- Bradford,Jackson,Tyrod

Miami-Tann,White

 

I would love for them to trade up for Darnold/Rosen/Mayfield but I think they stay pat and get lucky one of the top 5 is still available and grab Rudolph without any moves since those 3 are gone before the Bills can find a trade partner.

 

 

 

 

Edited by xRUSHx
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
On 1/24/2018 at 12:07 PM, DCOrange said:

I eliminated a few teams that I don't foresee making any changes. Red = rookies, blue = free agents/trades

 

Arizona: Teddy BridgewaterBaker Mayfield, scrub veteran

Atlanta: Matt Ryan, Kyle Lauletta

Baltimore: Joe Flacco, Kurt Benkert

Buffalo: Sam Darnold, Nate Peterman

Carolina: Cam Newton, scrub veteran (possibly bringing Derek Anderson back)

Cleveland: Tyrod Taylor, Josh Allen

Dallas: Dak Prescott, Sam Bradford

Denver: Kirk Cousins, Trevor Siemien

Jacksonville: Blake Bortles, Mike White

Kansas City: Pat Mahomes, scrub veteran

Miami: Ryan Tannehill, Lamar Jackson

Minnesota: Case Keenum, Mason Rudolph

New England: Tom Brady, Luke Falk

New Orleans: Drew Brees, Chase Litton

Jets: Josh Rosen, Petty/Hack

Seattle: Russell Wilson, scrub veteran

Washington: Alex Smith, Colt McCoy, Riley Ferguson

 

I'm off to a good start!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 1/24/2018 at 11:12 AM, BrooklynBills said:

Alot of question marks for several teams at QB and there is sure to be a TON of movement.  

 

BUF - Matt Moore; Sam Darnold(we will trade both 1sts and next year's 1st)

NYJ - Kirk Cousins(Bates connection with Shanahan)

CLE - Josh Rosen

JAX - Alex Smith

DEN - Nick Foles; Josh Allen

NYG - Eli; Davis Webb

WAS - Case Keenum

MIN - Teddy; Bradford

ARI - Tyrod; McCown; Mayfield

 

How do you think it shakes out?

Kirk Cousins wants to play on a team in competition so he can say a big :censored: you to Washington.  

 

Cleveland and the NYETS are not those teams.  

 

How does JAX get A Smith when he's the Skins QB?   DC knows what AS can do,   CK is still a bit of a ???  

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'll place my bet:

 

BUF - Mason Rudolph and vet FA like Chase Daniel or Derek Anderson

NYJ - Sam Darnold (6th overall)

CLE - Baker Mayfield (4th overall) backing up AJ McCarron

JAX - Bortles

DEN - Kirk Cousins

NYG - Josh Rosen (2nd overall) backing up Eli Manning

WAS - Alex Smith 

MIN - Teddy Bridgewater (contract tolled) backing up Case Keenum

ARI - Lamar Jackson backing up Nick Foles

Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, ShadyBillsFan said:

Kirk Cousins wants to play on a team in competition so he can say a big :censored: you to Washington.  

 

Cleveland and the NYETS are not those teams.  

 

How does JAX get A Smith when he's the Skins QB?   DC knows what AS can do,   CK is still a bit of a ???  

 

 

These predictions were all posted before the Alex Smith trade happened.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

- Buffalo- Keenum, White

- Cleveland- Darnold

- Jets- McCown, Allen

-  Giants- Manning, Rosen

- Broncos- Mayfield

- Minnesota- Cousins

- Arizona- Bradford, Rudolph

- Pittsburgh- Jackson

- New England- Lauletta

- San Diego- Falk 

- Jacksonville- Bridewater, Bortles

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

35 minutes ago, billspro said:

- Buffalo- Keenum, White

- Cleveland- Darnold

- Jets- McCown, Allen

-  Giants- Manning, Rosen

- Broncos- Mayfield

- Minnesota- Cousins

- Arizona- Bradford, Rudolph

- Pittsburgh- Jackson

- New England- Lauletta

- San Diego- Falk 

- Jacksonville- Bridewater, Bortles

 

 

The interesting part of your list will be the obvious long term comparison between the Bills and the Cardinals. One of those two teams will end up being the winner.  I sure hope it's the Bills.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...