Actually, Peterman is BETTER option for this offense.
Peterman is the Quicker thrower.
Peterman makes faster reads and faster decisions.
Peterman can run just as well as Tyrod does,
Argument for Tyrod is that he is ball safe. I'd argue Peterman is even better in this respect. Over their collegiate careers, Peterman had better TD-INT ratio than Tyrod:
47-17 vs 44-20.
Peterman >>> Tyrod.