Did you actually just include Liuget as a "loss?" That's funny.
Lawson has youth, but he has not shown that he will ever provide the sort of pass rush Addison brings. They are different types of players -- Lawson wins with power, while Addison has speed. At worst for the Bills it's a push, but I think most would give the Bills the nod here. Phillips was, to me, an enigma -- seemed to be dominant for stretches (Titans) but disappeared far too often. Jefferson and Butler more than make up for his departure.
In my opinion the Bills' DL is absolutely better today than it was on Sunday -- and Beane isn't done.