Your words, "he needs to play better or 12.7M is substantially overpaying for his services. As the kids say, FACTS." So, you dislike the contract he is getting. I don't have "to tell". You already told.
I don't take issue with your point of view. I take issue with your dismissing every poster who is happy the fifth year is picked up by congratulating yourself for being a "realist". No, you just have an opinion - no more, no less.