Jump to content

Erie County to spend 3mill on updates at New Era, including new field


YoloinOhio

Recommended Posts

3 minutes ago, TFBillsfan said:

Wouldn’t the Carrier Dome in Syracuse be a viable short term solution if they decided to do an overhaul of the Ralph?

 

No. The Carrier Dome is not up to NFL standards, as told to me by a former executive for the Bills, when asked if they'd ever do a pre-season game there. 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Chill said:

NY better be careful, Cali is hungry for another team. 

As a Cali resident i can tell you that this is a no.  Oakland can't afford a new stadium.  Diego will get the Chargers back one day, but that city will not get hi-jacked be the NFL stadium committee.  California won't pay for a new palace.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

22 minutes ago, BUFFALOBART said:

It's not about 'having faith in our city', but it IS about 'bang for the buck'. We already have what we need, if you are not fixated on the superficial....

 

Respectfully, ‘bang for the buck’ precludes spending $300M every few years to constantly update a 47 years-old stadium, when a brand spankin’ new one could be built for approx. $750M.

 

Nothing “superficial” is required - no tourist attraction, no shopping malls, water parks, etc.  That would just drive up the cost, when all folks want and need is a great place to watch NFL football.

 

The Ralph was great - and thank God it’s serviceable for a few more years while we build something new - but, like the Skyway, it is functionally obsolete, structurally deficient, fracture critical, and has outlived its usefulness.

.

 

Edited by The Senator
  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Just Jack said:

 

No. The Carrier Dome is not up to NFL standards, as told to me by a former executive for the Bills, when asked if they'd ever do a pre-season game there. 

 

I wonder what would be needed? Was the University of Illinois or the soccer stadium the Chargers played at any better?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, TFBillsfan said:

I wonder what would be needed? Was the University of Illinois or the soccer stadium the Chargers played at any better?

Could the Bills survive a temp. move like that? 

 

Chargers are struggling in LA. 

9 minutes ago, purple haze said:

As a Cali resident i can tell you that this is a no.  Oakland can't afford a new stadium.  Diego will get the Chargers back one day, but that city will not get hi-jacked be the NFL stadium committee.  California won't pay for a new palace.  

Sooner or later San Diego will get a new owner and a new team. Stay tuned. 

Edited by Chill
Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 minutes ago, Chill said:

Could the Bills survive a temp. move like that? 

 

Chargers are struggling in LA. 

Sooner or later San Diego will get a new owner and a new team. Stay tuned. 

I'm sure they will. The Chargers.  And whomever the owner is will pay for all or the majority of the cost; just like other, recent NFL owners.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

28 minutes ago, BUFFALOBART said:

If it was up to me, I'd be inclined to follow the Packers model.

The Ralph may be butt ugly, but I believe it is more economical to keep it going, as opposed to a downtown stadium, which like it or not, will be the virtual end of tailgating. Economics dictate that this will be so. Every burger,and beer consumed outside of the stadium is lost revenue for the Bills.

The brownfield Bethlehem complex is the only economical possibility, as generous tax credits would be available to reclaim, and re-purpose that land. I still don't like it, as I feel the 'average' fan will be shut out. Including myself, who is on the cusp of retirement.

 

You know, over the years, I have posted many,   many times that the Bethlehem site would be an ideal spot for a new, waterfront stadium.

 

It’d be right smack on the lake, plenty of acreage for parking (and tailgating), has an existing rail infrastructure, is only a few minutes from downtown, and has plenty of vehicular access (I90, Rt.5, Milestrip, etc.)

 

Plus, what the heck else can that site be used for?  No one is ever going to live atop that giant toxic dump, but you could convince me to spend a few hours there, once a week, 8-10 times a year.

 

Only problem I see is, the Bills players and staff would be there every day.

 

But is really is a good place for a stadium, I think.

 

 

(Did you know that John Albright, of Albright Knox Art Gallery fame, conned someone into practically giving him that all that land, under the pretense that he would use it to grow flowers for the Pan Am Exposition?  Once the land acquisition was completed, he and his partners brought in the Lackawanna Steel Company!)

.

Edited by The Senator
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Brianmoorman4jesus said:

Real grass please

Only way that happens is with something like Arizona did with roll-in natural grass field which will be harder for they will need greenhouse for grass since Buffalo's weather will not sustain grass thru winter including possible playoffs.  It is likely they would need to double down with more fields growing than Arizona. 

  • Awesome! (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

57 minutes ago, The Senator said:

 

You know, over the years, I have posted many,   many times that the Bethlehem site would be an ideal spot for a new, waterfront stadium.

 

It’d be right smack on the lake, plenty of acreage for parking (and tailgating), has an existing rail infrastructure, is only a few minutes from downtown, and has plenty of vehicular access (I90, Rt.5, Milestrip, etc.)

 

Plus, what the heck else can that site be used for?  No one is ever going to live atop that giant toxic dump, but you could convince me to spend a few hours there, once a week, 8-10 times a year.

 

Only problem I see is, the Bills players and staff would be there every day.

 

But is really is a good place for a stadium, I think.

 

 

Bills could have a practice facility and only go to stadium day they needed it. What would county do with current site?

But I think the transit issues are more difficult there (one less direction to go) and tailgating would probably have to be on new stadium site and it would be diminished compared to current tailgating.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Limeaid said:

 

Bills could have a practice facility and only go to stadium day they needed it. What would county do with current site?

But I think the transit issues are more difficult there (one less direction to go) and tailgating would probably have to be on new stadium site and it would be diminished compared to current tailgating.

 

A practice facility is an excellent thought and maybe the current site could be used for that, with the county selling off the excess land for development purposes.

 

 As for one less direction, I’m sure some fans would love to arrive and depart by boat (JK), but I don’t understand why you think tailgating would be any less fun on the lakefront than in Orchard Park?

.

Edited by The Senator
Link to comment
Share on other sites

55 minutes ago, BUFFALOBART said:

The brownfield tax credits could be worth on the order of $35 million, and of course, the state could sweeten that pot. The land would have to be remediated before any construction took place. If Erie County, and the State were serious, they could make this happen:

https://www.tax.ny.gov/pit/credits/brownfield-redevelopment-credit.htm#Acceptance on or after 7/1/15

 

The remediation process would like add another 5 years to the timeline - there is cyanide literally seeping up through the griund in some spots.

 

But the extra time would certainly please fans of The Ralph!

.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

22 hours ago, Just Jack said:

 

 

Batavia Downs. There's already a large enough field with a grandstand. 

Yeah, and isn’t the gin mill that Thurman Thomas shills for there?!  A few blue tarps from Valu and we’ll have a home away from home during the ‘extreme makeover’.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...