Maybe that's your code, but when I hear "athletic" I think of a QB who'll tuck it and run or extend the play with his legs. Frank Tarkenton, Steve Young, Rothlisberger are just a few who don't fit YOUR stereotype.
Personally, the guy can be a smurf with a laser rocket arm and 4.7 (though I'd take 4.6) GPA w/ 4 championships in a pro scheme - I want a winner, don't much care what he looks like!