whorlnut

Mcgahee had one of the worst ACL tears I can ever remember seeing. His knee was completely destroyed.

Williams or Dotson in the 1st Tariq Woolen in the 2nd highest ranked Guard in the 3rd After that…don’t really care. Not sure what your intent is here, but it’s unfair to compare ACL’s today to ACLs 20 years ago. The technology and recovery times have come a long way.

I agree. He will only fall if there isn’t a good report. If he is ahead of schedule then someone will take him before us. He’s gonna be really good. I think I’d rather have Dotson than olave. Dotson has the best hands in the draft and isn’t afraid of catching the ball in traffic. There are concerns about Olave and his lack of physicality.

Just any corner and only one specific WR? Sorry…don’t agree. You don’t just take a corner in the first because of need. That player has to have the right skill set and be the right fit first and foremost. Waiting until the end of the second is a dangerous spot if you are targeting one specific player. Let the board fall. If a WR you like is there in round one, then take him. Drafting for need is how we ended up with EJ Manuel.

The team could get a corner in the second round or beyond. Why do people always think we need to draft defense in the first?

Cool story. In those 2-3 years, how many SB’s will we win?

Especially on offense…

My point is this…decency bias might be causing you to make a misjudged opinion. Did they finish the season on high notes? Yes. Was their play always consistent? No. Do they have major red flags to their games? Yes. Just be careful judging your opinion off of a handful of games and not their entire careers.

As fans we always “hope” they play well. Unfortunately, our fandom doesn’t always align with reality.

You are picking one game in the entire time he’s been here. I’m sorry…the other games count too. Can’t just look at one game where he looked really good and ignore the ones where he was average at best or completely inactive.

To be fair, Diggs is insanely elite, so if you put him in that average category, then you are 100% wrong. Knox has above average to elite potential. Davis has a chance to be pretty good, but we will see. Beyond that, we are very average at best. the fact that people are so gaga over the McKenzie signing baffles me. He was inactive a lot, was in the doghouse, and struggled with ball security. Singletary is painfully slow and has had a lot of times where he was completely ineffective.

Agree. Hopefully it also doesn’t mean that we don’t try to upgrade in the draft.

At the end of the year, Singletary played well and so did Bates. Are yoy willing to bet that is sustainable? I’m not. Not even close. I’m more inclined to think their true selves are somewhere between “meh” and average.

And we ALL wish we had that problem…

But we got Isiah McKenzie!!!!

Running it back is what caused the oline issues most of this season. Who cares if it’s core players? Put the best players out there and make a conscious effort to improve each off-season.

Not only that, but I guarantee this is Beane’s “fix” for the offense and almost guarantees we won’t be going with a first round offensive playmaker.

He’s had the opportunity for a while now. And oh by the way, he’s been inactive and has had ball security issues. I’m not sure why everyone is so excited about this. It’s pretty meh to me…

Exactly. There are ways. Not really sure what Beane is waiting for in freeing up some of this cap space.

The Steelers apparently have an unhealthy appetite for qbs that abuse women…

I disagree. Gronk is an elite blocker. He would benefit this offense in ways that go beyond pass catching.

This is not a good take. There are a BUNCH of splash players in this free agency class. Try harder… We are on the verge of winning it all. We have an insanely talented roster. People are gonna “flock” already…

I like him as well…will he be there in 2?

Good…pushes the wide receivers down the board…

Hope a team in front of us notices this as well…