He was a top 5 pick who fell due the injury. It was too tempting to pass on him. He wouldn't be ready until 2004 at the earliest, so TD still could use Henry for most of his contract (who became a RFA in 2005), then would have McGahee later on still on a rookie deal. Plus, we actually traded McGahee later for two 3rds and a 7th, which is not a bad return.