I would take any of those QB's over a visionless QB that cannot pass the football or call a audible. Not only am I not watching the Dolphins game I am not watching any more games where TT is the QB or QB on another team. It's a boring brand of football.
Running Shady and then using play action off of it to open up the passing game. What the Saints have right now is what your trying to achieve, a balanced offense that can adapt to any defense. Taylor makes us a one dimensional run heavy offense.