rice was a dominant wr1 all of his career. edelman was not. jerry rice helped make his qbs. edelman was not. i understood the analogy, i just didn't love it.
i was a bit surprised when TD got in, but i understood it. when he was healthy, TD was arguably the best at his position. edelman was never that.
i think the win and the mvp are so fresh that it's causing a reaction. not to take anything away from edelman, but he's just not a hof guy. if he ends up getting in, i won't be upset, but i will question the criteria.