All Activity

What part do think is the strawman? The premise is questioning how NFL teams evaluate the quarterback position, why QB performance fluctuates, and if it's better to build an elite team with a less elite QB vs having an elite QB with a less elite team. There's no gotcha here. It just comes off like you want to be mad about something and you're taking it out on this guy.

Can't she still be? I didn't read the article. Is she backing off or something?

If the ground was starting to Crack in April shouldnt it be all the way destroyed by October?

Uh... yeah. Was I supposed to post someone else's video when referencing that he posts strawman videos for clickbait? We'll have to agree to disagree on this. If you believe we have a very successful passing offense and watched the video of him calling Mahomes and the QB position as a whole overrated and think "this guy's cooking" - there's really nothing to talk about anymore.

Cmon Jays take care of business tonight!

i got it 👍 ok so i have to ask- is he graphing the optimum run/pass mix on offense or did he actually graph the optimum run/pass playcall on defense? i think those are two separate things

Oh *****… sorry dude, my bad… no wonder I couldn’t find it lol

Just get Brady a couple of big guys who can get open and catch. Everything will take care of itself.

you posted HIS own video. You're trying to use his own content to prove he's a fraud and that his science is invalid? How? I watched that video already.

What on earth are you talking about? I *literally* posted a video example in the post you last replied to...

You're going to make me get out a dictionary.

Tua can be their transition QB. Shouldn’t stop them from maneuvering to try and get a new QB to groom.

There's no evidence to any of this, and this is an evidence based discussion. He follows a rigorous, science-based approach to all of his content, and you're literally the only person I've ever seen try to dismiss him out of hand as a fraud. If he's so intellectually dishonest, I'd love to see your own proofs. Should be easy for you, right? You can't disagree with something you don't even understand.

Look at the posts above I was replying to. They were in reference to getting Jermaine Burton.

It always seems to happen every game against the Chiefs that there is a Bill's long pass play or run play and it's nullified by a questionable holding call. Or, a roughing the passer call that saves the Chiefs from a crucial turnover.

Because you're using an infamous creator who is known for taking straw man stances as clickbait. And arguing specific aspects in team sports to either magnify or diminish others. Like in the video I sent, it's not that Mahomes is great, but Andy Reid. Or the Offensive Line. No - Mahomes is great and they are also great. This is no different. I don't have to watch it. The idea that bc Cook is the 2nd leading rusher in the league doesn't denote we have a great passing game "or Elite offense". This is a classic McKelvie idea for a "wtf is this?! I'll click on it" video. The YPA and Attempt metrics don't mean we're not doing well just bc we don't have to. We have the on field results based evidence that that's not the case. We couldn't even beat the friggin' Falcons when we needed to pass to win. We couldn't keep up with the Patriots when we needed to pass. This isn't "crying" about the passing game. This is looking at someone saying "our Offense is Elite" and "our passing game is actually pretty good" and disagreeing.

At 5:20 he graphs expected yards per play when the offense runs and the defense uses a run defense vs pass defense and does the same for pass. I don't know where he got the expected yardage values for the calculation, so if we want to say that's wrong, that's fine. I missed where I said I was relying on hope for anything. This whole discussion is about the Bills showing us their plan already, or at least the framework for it, and whether or not it just might be deceptively effective.

This is about Jermaine Burton not Brian Thomas JR, unless I’m confused Brian Thomas JR ??

Hope isn't a plan, but I appreciate your optimism. Also, Henry and Barkley couldn't be more physically different than Cook. The record book for 100+ YPG isn't littered with small RBs.

I only see where he graphed the scenario wherein defenses react rationally to corresponding changes in run/pass%?

Of course she's disappointed and depressed. She was on her way to become a huge pop megastar actress, even bigger than J-Lo !! Has anyone seen Sinners? That was a true Oscar worthy performance by her !!

If you watched it, why would you say that when he talked about it explicitly in the calculation and graphed it. Right, but they aren't leading the league this year. Every year is its own beast. You don't go into it with the same plan. This year James Cook is the top dog, and barring injury, he'll likely stay that way.

Sure it was: Barkley has done to once in his career--he isn't even close this year. Henry has done in once in the last 3--he won't get there this year. Also, in 2 of the 3 games where Cook was under 100 yards, the Bills lost, with only 200 yards passing on average. So, no.

Their first names don't start with a "J". And Rob Johnson wouldn't have caught a whiff of the playoffs if it weren't for Doug Flutie.

‘Zero’ reacted, as if the shoe fits, and it does.