The Trade For Diggs

[Lionel Hutz]

I'm not a fan of Beane but it's hard to criticize the Diggs trade. He had a huge and immediate impact on this team and on Josh's development as an elite QB. 

 

Obviously, with hindsight, you'd probably go back and keep the pick and draft Jefferson, but with hindsight Jefferson would also be a top-10 pick.

[machine gun kelly]

Entertaining the what if game is a fools errand.  We won and so did MN.  It’s done.

[JP51]

20 minutes ago, Lionel Hutz said:

I'm not a fan of Beane but it's hard to criticize the Diggs trade. He had a huge and immediate impact on this team and on Josh's development as an elite QB. 

 

Obviously, with hindsight, you'd probably go back and keep the pick and draft Jefferson, but with hindsight Jefferson would also be a top-10 pick.

I was gonna say... I didnt see many people on the board complaining that day we traded for Diggs...  I did see them lamenting when Antonio Brown shunned us though....  man if I just knew the winning numbers the day prior I could retire.. lol 

[Man with No Name]

7 hours ago, Bills365 said:

To my fellow Bills fans, I think about this all the time. I am curious everyone else’s thoughts on this.

 

If we hadn’t traded our 22nd pick for Diggs Justin Jefferson falls in our lap that following year. I know this is in hindsight and Beane was trying to get us a solid weapon in which he did. Diggs was great for a few years but I can’t help but wonder how different this team would’ve been for a decade plus of Allen and Jefferson.

I should read ahead before posting, but here goes. We all know the bills trade that pick to the chiefs, right? We were never taking Justin Jefferson!

[PoundingDog]

It's in the past, all the what ifs.

 

At this time, all I can say is the time has indeed passed. Once you have paid your QB, to trade for an expansive WR is not realistic. You would have to give up premium draft picks AND big time cap money. So that means you have to draft very well for the rest of the roster. Logically speaking, if you have to draft well for the team's overall success, why not draft well for a WR? That will solve the problem.

 

KC has tried more times than the Bills. We gotta give more tries. In fact Beane has spent a first round pick drafting a WR for the Bills yet.

[BuffaloBillsGospel2014]

Diggs did exactly what the team hoped and that was elevate both players, I have no beef with the trade at all and wished he'd do more like this deal.

[HappyDays]

2 hours ago, CapeBreton said:

 

Beane didn't like the WRs in 2020, so he traded for Diggs.

 

That's not true. They were definitely taking a WR that year. They decided to take the sure thing instead of the lottery ticket. Considering how well Diggs paid off I'm not remotely upset at them over it.

 

To me the more depressing "what if" scenario is when we took Cody Ford over AJ Brown, DK Metcalf, and Terry McLaurin. That was Beane's biggest whiff IMO. Epecially since it isn't just hindsight, Brown and Metcalf in particular were seen as great prospects with uncoachable physical traits.

[Mr. WEO]

9 hours ago, Taro Nimbus said:

Who’s to say the Bills would have drafted Jefferson???

 

good point.  Beane would have blown right past Jefferson as he ran to the podium to draft Noah Igbinoghene or Jeff Gladney.

[cba fan]

2 hours ago, Lionel Hutz said:

I'm not a fan of Beane but it's hard to criticize the Diggs trade. He had a huge and immediate impact on this team and on Josh's development as an elite QB. 

 

Obviously, with hindsight, you'd probably go back and keep the pick and draft Jefferson, but with hindsight Jefferson would also be a top-10 pick.

yeah this.... also Beane was in get Josh a ready #1, mode, and may have traded for a different #1 then if Diggs deal fell through.

Not sure who was available but many are for the right price. He may have had to pay more then.

[artmalibu]

A bird in the hand is better than 2 in the bush.  To get a proven pro in a cationic covid time was a smart move.  

[Bermuda Triangle]

14 hours ago, Taro Nimbus said:

Who’s to say the Bills would have drafted Jefferson???

Beane probably would have traded up for Reagor