Jump to content

Bills to trade Kiko Alonso for LeSean McCoy


CNY315

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 1.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Reading the national responses makes me feel even better. A lot of people viewing it as Chip not getting along with Shady, dumping one of Roseman's picks, believing he can plug any RB and just getting another Oregon player.

 

 

We all love Kiko. Dude plays like his hair is lit on fire all the time. But I don't know how people can't have concerns about his knees and he's not big enough to play outside or inside in a true 3-4 like Rex wants to run. It's shocking to see him gone, but we just added LeSean McCoy without losing anyone off last year's team. That's a win.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thoughts:

 

1. I don't like it. $12 million would be better applied elsewhere.

 

2. I don't hate it. Kiko: 2 knee surgeries. Loved watching him, but 2 knee surgeries. We don't know the entire story -- are the Bills wondering about his health? Is Rex wondering whether he fits in his D? Some breakout guys like this have turned out to have PED issues behind that breakout. Not saying Kiko did. Just saying we don't know.

 

3. We also don't know the full plan for 2015. What I do like: no fear. The typical response to our "up and coming" 9-7 season would be "add a guard (or two). Hope EJ gets it, or maybe sign a McCown as insurance. Don't let any of our performers go -- Hughes, Kiko, Sammy, Dareus -- they've all got to stay. They're the core. Untouchables. A little tweak here and may get us to 10-6 and just over the hump." There's no playing it safe here. Rex and Doug will sink or swim and it'll happen fast. It shows guts. Sometimes guts and stupidity are joined at the hip, but still ... it shows guts.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

^^ This

 

Anyone on here trying to down-play Kiko's pure instinctual football talent is insane and/or ignorant. The guy is a football player. An exceptional linebacker. The guy always seems to be around the ball, and has a knack for making plays. That said, he does have his shortcomings. While a sure tackler, he sometimes get overpowered by bigger backs/blockers. Also...two ACL injuries on the same leg? Complete knee ligament reconstruction? Let's say I had my worries about his longevity.

 

I think good trade, overall.

Different legs. He's now torn both

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Basically an even trade for both teams in which the drop off from what they gave up is less than the benefit from what they gain. Both teams traded from their strength to improve their weakness. Sounds like a pretty reasonable trade to me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kiko was our answer to Gronk. Now what?

I am in complete favor of the trade...but very good point....the Pats had Hernandez and Gronkowski when Alonso was drafted. Alonso is fantastic at coverage of the TE, this skill will be missed. Have to trust that Rex will have a plan on this.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Basically an even trade for both teams in which the drop off from what they gave up is less than the benefit from what they gain. Both teams traded from their strength to improve their weakness. Sounds like a pretty reasonable trade to me.

Agree. The only thing I did not like was that we gave up our 2nd Rd pick (Kiko), and effectively a Top-10 Pick (Spiller) for a Veteran Running Back. Whaley and Rex want to win now. Kiko became expendable with emergence of Preston Brown. Spiller's injury last year put a lid on this team. Rex is a Run-first guy. I think he got a great player.

 

The Eagles will gain the upper-hand if they can sign Spiller to a moderate FA contract. Spiller could succeed in Kelly's system.

Edited by ganesh
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

It's not 12, it's 9 and change.

I think you've been slightly low in your framing the numbers -- it's salary of 9.75, 6.9 and 7.6, with this year having an additional 500k in roster/workout bonuses and 250k each of the next two years. So 10.25, 7.15 and 7.85 are the numbers Edited by NoSaint
Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...