Maddog69

Somebody felt that these QBs were impressive, 4 of them went in the top 12

maybe someone like Matt Moore

the difference for me is the 1st round pick. I hated the Spiller pick, I love the Dareus pick. The rest of our draft last year was great

I agree with ICCREW. Gallery is not good, especially at tackle.

No interest in a trade for Kolb. Based on talent alone, Young seems worse a gamble, but his mental make up is what concerns me. It seems that we will be looking for one of the available free agents on the scrap heap Young Alex Smith Troy Smith McNabb (if he gets cut) not sre who else would be out there.

Not sure I trust Buddy's judgement on QB's. He and Chan installed Trent as our starter last year and did not bother to go get a decent QB last year or this year (so far)

I grade it incomplete. Too early to tell Give it three years to see how the picks pan out and what players we passed on that turn out great.

Scenario A: Mallett backs up Brady for a yr or two, plays well when given oppty and gets traded for much higher picks a 3rd rounder (like Cassell) Scenario B: Mallett backs up Brady for 2-3 years, plays well. NE trades Brady for several high picks (like Bledsoe) Scenrio C: Mallett doesn't pan out and the Pats waste a 3rd round pick. Basically a no lose proposition for the Pats. Once again they prove to be smarter thsn the rest of the league and totally piss me off.

Mallett, please

agree 100%

they just wasted their second round pick, they might just as well blow another one on this loser

Then it is a waste of a pick

I really hate this pick

They should still keep Drayton Florence. 1.) McKelvin has not proven to be able to start 2.) McGee is always injured 3.) No guarantee that this kid steps in and starts. This was a moronic pick unless it means they let Whitner leave, then I love it.

1.) Ryan had a lot of turnovers which led to or directly caused us to lose games. 2.) You have no way of knowing whether or not Dalton or Mallett will be stars. Nobody does. 3.) Average would be an upgrade from Fitz

I agree. I don;t see why people so overvalue Fitz's performance from last year. He is not good. He is better than the crap we've had since Jim Kelly, but he is not good. If you want to see what he would do with a good offense, look what he did in Cincy. When he was there, Carson Palmer was putting up ridiculous numbers, Fitz was terrible. The more we debate this, the more I want to Bills to draft a QB with our pick in Round 2 or trade for one when trading is allowed.

if you don't want to cherry pick, then look at his entire career stats and see that he sucks terribly.

the same can be said for Mallett

regardless of how you feel about their abilities, we have Kelsay and Merriman signed for decent money to play OLB. We also have Moats. I doubt we take an OLB at 2. ILB, maybe

I'd take a shot on Mallett Elite arm, can play immediately. Nix can work with his skillset to make him successful.

I like the idea of a trade down with Oakland so they can get Kaepernick, but in addition to their 2 and 3 this year, I would want their 2 next year instead of their 3

I don't think DL can wear numbers in the 50's, can they?

I love rounds 1-5. Don't know the other guys. I expect Ponder to be gone before our pick in Rd2

1.) who says it would take 2-3 years for him to contribute? 2.) Yes. We need a franchise QB who will be able to lead us back to competitiveness year after year over a long career (see: Kelly, James)

DR D is correct. It was a jealous husband situation. Marsbawn is still a douche. But in the one situation, it really wasn't his fault.