Rico

Big props to Buddy Nix for drafting Cordy Glenn instead of this clown.

Far and away TD's biggest mistake IMO, ended up ruining his career. A somewhat competent scrub, even Shane friggin' Matthews would've had that team in the playoffs in 2004, and then everything changes going forth.

Depends on if Whaley is still here next year IMO.

3rd year's the charm for KUJO!!!

Music City Miracle is a lock for the Titans.

Nice thread, I see everyone's warming up for November.

I thought I've seen Osweiler listed at 6'8" before, but a quick search shows 6'7", so OK. The 6'7"-and-up QB club includes Osweiler, Glennon, and now Paxton Lurch. Former members include Dan McGwire (1st round bust for the Seahawks) and a few other scrubs. IMO these dorks are a very easy target for opposing defenses to find and terrorize. If one of them does make it in the NFL, I will offer congrats to him and the team for taking a chance, just too risky for me though.

Gotta put Lurch Osweiler near the very bottom of this list, that dork is just way too big. Poor Texans, I don't believe there's ever been a QB that tall to have a successful career in the NFL beyond a few games, and I'd be surprised if he ends up being the first..

Kemp? You could add up all the suck QBs on this list and you still couldn't touch Fergy on this.

Yes, the best teams/GMs realize that "If a QB prospect doesn't progress, then you move on to the next prospect." You can be patient to a point, but by the time you're into year 2, you better start seeing improvement and certainly not regression, or you are just wasting a roster spot & everyone's time (i.e. DW with EJ). I don't care if Cardale isn't starting in 2017, but he does need to at least be looking the part and showing the potential to get there by then, or you move on.

Yep, POS of a QB but nice guy.

Night and day. Only a handful of people think that TT sucks, and only a handful of people think that Brain Dead Drew did not suck.

He sucked the 2nd half in 2002, was beyond brutal in 2003, had very little to do with any wins in 2004, and was the main reason why the Bills lost to the 3rd-string Steelers. He was the definition of the word SUCK, and no amount of revisionist spinning will ever change that fact.

Pretty putrid list. I would move: Kemp to Good Fergy, Reich, and TT (with the arrow pointing up) to Average and Brain Dead Drew to Suck.

Right now, I'd say 8-8. All depends on how many games TT plays. If he starts all 16, this can be a 9 win team, maybe even 10... but every game he misses is a loss. I like Cardale Jones as a developmental #3 QB, but that only works when your #1 stays on the field and your #2 isn't a total POS. Unfortunately, that's the corner in which Whaley has painted himself and this team into.

Yep. 17 and counting, hope Pegs finally wakes up this winter.

17 and counting, poor Pegs.

The next Dan McGwire... unless Whaley picks him, then he's the next EJ Manuel.

Buddy Nix has nothing to do with EJ still being on the team in 2016 though, DW owns that 100%. Not knowing when to cut your losses and move on is the sign of a weak GM. Not being able to cut your losses and move on due to salary cap mismanagement is also the sign of a weak GM.

And if they don't, hopefully Pegs cleans house after 2016, tossing Rex and all of Ralph's old trash to the curb. Now is the time to think positive thoughts and KEEP HOPE ALIVE!

Yeah, he was brutal after the Pats game in 2002, but at least he did something the 1st half of the year. 2003 though, after the 1st 2 games... most gutless team and player in Bills history that year (sorry EJ fans, but Orton in the Raiders game wasn't even close).

Here's to EJ getting a ring like JP did.

Enough Carr already, it's TT time.

The 2003 season and the last game of 2004 scarred me for life as a Bills fan.

No surprise at all, though you can usually get the same propaganda directly from the government source, Chris Brown.It's also no surprise that if you want the real deal on what's going down behind the scenes at OBD, you go to the Buffalo News.