Nosferatu 1922
Dracula 1931
Frankenstein 1931
Halloween 1978
Honorable mentions: The Old Dark House 1932, Nearly anything from Val Lewton(Cat People, The Leopard Man, The Body Snatcher, I walked With A Zombie), The Invisible Man 1933.
What was more frustrating was not getting a touchdown after the fumble by Stroud. The Bills had the ball at the 15 and settled for a field goal.
Also, yes, Bernard's interception was fantastic. He read that perfectly.