I'm comfortable with Barkley as backup, it's hard to judge backups really. But it's interesting how many Bills fans react to him. He's played 1 game for us, and did well, but that's it. Other than that , his career hasn't been any good. I didn't read the article but i'll have to assume they are basing the rankings , in part, on the players entire career, which in Barkley's case isn't any good up until now.
But it's a silly exercise in ranking players that rarely play, rarely practice with first teamer's, don't have game plans made around their strengths....