Kirby Jackson

They had a flawed offense with similar issues as now. They couldn’t make the play when they needed to because the receivers weren’t good enough. Obviously the defense wasn’t good enough and needed to get better. It just needed to come AFTER they addressed the offense. If someone has the energy I would love to see the investment made in offense vs. defense over the last 5 years in terms of FA dollars and draft capital. I did it a year or so ago with draft capital basically using the draft value points of each pick to show their investment. The defense was well ahead of the offense and that’s before they used their first 4 or 5 picks on defense this past year. That gap is getting even wider. It’s insanity.

They did come back against a bad Baltimore pass defense. They didn’t against Miami or Atlanta. They are not built to play from behind. They used to be but they aren’t now. If the Bills can’t run the ball and rush the passer, they’re a bad football team. If you’re behind, those are 2 things that you can’t really do. It shouldn’t have been a surprise yesterday to see Miami win the toss and take the ball. Everyone knows that’s the formula to beat the Bills. The Bills should have went on that 4th down on the 1st drive. Once they get down 2 scores they’re doomed. They are last in YPC allowed at 5.5 (tied with the Giants). They have the worst WRs in the league. If you want to make a case that they’re the 30th best or 31st best, go for it but you can’t make a reasonable case for more than that. So if teams get ahead, they run all over you. You’re forced to throw the ball and the only place that you can win is between the hashes 20 yards and in (sometimes WR screens too). Teams can take away your trash WRs and jam the middle of the field making it hard to win there. The “gameplan” to beat the Bills is simple. It’s REALLY simple. Now, can teams execute it is a different story. If the Bills get out in front they’re really tough.

The difference is that Josh Allen was playing as the best player in the world. If he regressed to “great player” this was going to be the result. The margin for error is nonexistent. The thought that, “it doesn’t matter who is out there because Josh will cover for them” is beyond flawed. They should have built a roster to turbocharge him. Instead they said, “we will focus ALL of our energy elsewhere and you can overcome it.” The Bills philosophy is the exact opposite of what it should be. It should be build around Josh and address everything else after that. The chose to try to focus on everything else and whatever is left can try to help Josh. It’s malpractice.

The issue isn’t, “can the Bills beat every NFL team?” That’s a yes. On any given day the Bills can beat any team in the NFL(and probably by multiple scores). The issue is, “can the Bills win 3 or 4 consecutive playoff games to win the title?” I don’t know how anyone can say yes at the point. They could have lost to Miami in the first matchup and got whooped by them the second time. The Saints were looking for the go ahead score late. They were pounded by Atlanta. It took a miracle to beat Baltimore. It isn’t a case of the Bills not being able to look good or win a game. It’s about them being too limited to win once the playoffs start. They can’t win from behind because their WRs suck and they can’t stop the run. So they need to throw to guys that aren’t open and try to stop teams from running despite giving up 5.5 YPC (or whatever it is now). You can’t have the worst WRs in the league AND give up the most YPC in the NFL. You can’t win 4 straight playoff games like that. The Bills can only win one way and that’s a major problem.

The culture. He came to a perennial loser and now they’re perennially a winner. I’m one of the last people on this board to give McDermott credit but he deserves some for that. Obviously, it is more tied to Josh but McDermott gets some. The public heat was turned way up even before the season. It’s only gotten worse. He’s absolutely not a lock to be back. He MAY be back but this isn’t like years past. He has been crushed publicly since April. What the public was worried about has come to fruition. I think it’s more likely than not that there’s someone else handling the roster this offseason.

I had 3 in my cart when I posted that on StubHub that were $96 each after fees. They weren’t very good.

Josh is about to be 30 (or is). You can’t wait a couple of years to do it.

Brady hasn’t been good. If we are asking, “what is worse Brady or the receivers” it’s the receivers by 8,000 miles. His scheme worked at LSU. It worked at Carolina and it worked last year with bad players. None of the Bills WRs have proven that they can consistently win. Not one has a track record of success. They’re the 32nd best WRs in the league. Brady hasn’t been good but he’s nowhere near the 32nd ranked OC.

I don’t know if he is or isn’t. It sure feels like the heat is turning up. He’s taking way more heat publicly than he has up until this point. My guess is McDermott is back unless this falls apart. He shouldn’t be back in my opinion. He did a nice job building the foundation and now it’s time for someone to take them over the top.

That’s the scary part. They’ve tried to keep it plugged together but may be time to be bold.

They literally are operating at 25% of the NIL of the big boys. If the big boys want someone, they get them. He could end up somewhere like Syracuse but not if Ohio State or Miami or Oregon or someone like that wants him. Unless they change the rules on NIL that’s the way it is.

Honestly, it’s not that reactionary. We’ve run it back year after year with the same results. It’s bold but not unprecedented. There are a handful of teams in recent history that replaced successful coaches because they couldn’t win a championship. The results have largely been positive.

That’s what I hope (I think). My guess is someone from the outside (Stefanski) but Kromer has earned a shot.

The Bills were 1st in yards and 2nd in points (I think) entering today. They did that despite having the worst WRs in the league. Do you think people, especially on the outside, think he’s failing? Of course not. If I had to guess it is LSU.

This is the 1st time since 2019 that I can’t see the Bills winning the Super Bowl. Every other year, I thought that they COULD if things went well. They can beat anyone on any given day but that have a few major holes that I don’t believe they can cover for 3 or 4 playoff games. It is sad too because they are currently $3m or $4m over the cap next year. They pretty much have to part ways with Milano, Knox, Taron and Daquan Jones. I’d probably clean house but don’t think that they will. I suspect Beane is gone, Babich is gone and Brady takes a HC job. They have struggled to draft well early and lack elite talent because of it. It’s going to be tough to take the necessary steps needed with what they have to work with. This year has been such a disappointment. They may still win the division and a playoff game or 2 but they are too flawed to be a real contender.

Same thoughts as 2 weeks ago

He hasn’t been great. He’s still considered a very good candidate. The Bills were leading the league in yards & were 2nd in points entering today. They did that with the worst WRs in the league. Do you think that teams/programs think that offense is underperforming its talent?? He will have multiple options.

I think he ends up with one of the college jobs. He will have NFL opportunities too but not sure if they’re great (Jets, Dolphins, Raiders, Cards) come to mind.

Yeah, he’s the front runner for a bunch of jobs. He’s the betting favorite for LSU as of 2 days ago.

Oh sure he is. It may be college or it may be the NFL. I’d wager whatever that he is a head coach next year. He has lots of opportunities.

Not just WR, I’m sorry for the confusion. I was talking elite talent in general

He can’t mean that. He’s going to be a HC somewhere next year. I hope that the next guy builds the offense around Josh. I’d like to see the Bills clean house top to bottom. You can’t let these guys continue squandering Josh Allen.

Of course they can’t stop the run. That’s what I said. Entering last week they were giving up the most YPC of any team in the last 50 years or whatever it was. They don’t need a passing game coordinator. Joe Brady WAS the passing game coordinator of, arguably, the greatest offense in NCAA history. Lol, this is about players WAY more than coaching. They need better WRs. Brady is going to be a HC next year anyways. He will go somewhere that’s drafting a QB.

You can’t get down 16 and then establish the run. The Bills have to play from ahead. Miami knows that. That’s why they took the ball after winning the toss. If the Bills have the lead they can run the ball and don’t have to worry about stopping the run. You can just rush the passer. This roster can only win one way. That’s really bad when you have Josh Allen.

If you watched that game and thought they were acceptable, wait for the All-22 then I guess. Pretty much every Bills account on Twitter crushed them the whole game. I wasn’t there today so could only see what was on TV. I’ve seen it all year and apparently it was worse today. They were awful. They’re no better than the 30th best WR room in the NFl and probably 32 without Palmer. That’s malpractice.